Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[SeanT]

No chance I was told awhile ago Katoa is trying to get to Souths

Bennett has to get rid of Dodd for that to happen with the cap space Bennett needs all of Dodds money for that to happen katoa and bud the future South's halves

Katoa won't leave the Dolphins. Why would he.

 

[The Chad]

Have you not seen Lehi Hopoate?

Whenever I hear talk of how good Hopoate is I think of this game.

Try 3, Kennedy....that's some special effort from Hopoate in there...

All Tries –  Sharks v Sea Eagles

All the tries from the clash between the Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks and Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles in Round 6 of the 2025 Telstra Premiership

www.nrl.com

 

[twentyforty]

Whenever I hear talk of how good Hopoate is I think of this game.

Try 3, Kennedy....that's some special effort from Hopoate in there...

All Tries –  Sharks v Sea Eagles

All the tries from the clash between the Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks and Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles in Round 6 of the 2025 Telstra Premiership

www.nrl.com

Brooks still got his pace.

 

[JC99]

Brooks still got his pace.

That's just about all he's got... he's playing awful this year. Thank god we finally cut ties with that loser

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Thank god we finally cut ties with that loser

I know right. We went on to get ANOTHER spoon.

 

[Red88_Tiger]

I’d agree with you any other time, but he really does seem to be playing like he’s gone on for one season too many. I think retirement beckons. We don’t need to sign any more has beens, no matter how good they once were.

Were competitive most parts now I just think he’d provide extra composure in the tighter games
If Latu is heir (supposedly) and out plays him then you’re in a good position. With a club favourable contract say he plays well and you take an extra year you are still only carrying load in the cap for 1 year. It would be like other wastes we’ve had sponging for multiple years

Edit- we seem also to be infusing younger players so experience is a plus. Not to mention he did have enough form to get selected for qld. Yes he got dropped but did earn his original selection

 

[Moh]

I know right. We went on to get ANOTHER spoon.

What do ya mean? It was all Brooksies fault!!!

 

[Demps]

Positions / back with Magpies?

Hasn't returned.

Was mentioned on here.
Nothing official.

 

[Odessa]

Katoa won't leave the Dolphins. Why would he.

He has said he wants to return to Sydney let's see what happens

The rumour he is going to Newcastle is wrong he wants to come home to Sydney

 

[Odessa]

I don’t think I’ve seen him play, but has Dodd turn out to be a Dudd ?

Dodds is on 750K and is enjoying the Sydney holiday could be hard to get rid of him

Bennett won't play him in first grade unless he has to

With katoa Bennett can win a title

 

[Aceshigh]

If David Fifita does play for a Sydney club I reckon he'll go to the rabbitohs to play under uncle Wayne

They got no spots or cap space

 

[Odessa]

Whenever I hear talk of how good Hopoate is I think of this game.

Try 3, Kennedy....that's some special effort from Hopoate in there...

All Tries –  Sharks v Sea Eagles

All the tries from the clash between the Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks and Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles in Round 6 of the 2025 Telstra Premiership

www.nrl.com

The injured Hopoate in Canberra is pretty good as well

 

[TigerTone]

Where'd that get invented?

He was Born in Brisbane and Did most of High School at Keebra.

My bad i must've been thinking about some one else.
You're right.
Either way maybe a change of scenery will be good for him.

 

[batboy]

My bad i must've been thinking about some one else.
You're right.
Either way maybe a sea change will be good for him.

See change?

He lives on the Gold Coast
😂😂😂

 

[batboy]

Katoa won't leave the Dolphins. Why would he.

Money - Career Future....
He's their best player, And would be the same or one of wherever he went.

 

[weststigerman]

Ah, but they would / might actually be in their proper positions with Moses 7 and Brooks 6. Would be interesting for posterity to see if the suspicion of them being played the wrong way around was more correct than wrong.

They were definitely played the wrong way. We can thank Jason Taylor for that wisdom.

 

[Big Red]

the guy that just offered an Ageing Reynolds Almost 1mill more than the next guy,
To come play over the top of every other half currently at the club.

He's accountable as anyone else, Seen previous admins blown to bits for lesser decisions.

Agreed that he is accountable but there was an ineptitude in the previous admin that we don’t have now. Sure Richo didn’t get his mark but we weren’t left with egg on our face like the failed Lattrell or JAC signings of the past admin. There’s a big difference in a player declining an offer because he doesn’t want to move interstate away from his family, and a player who rejects our offer to go to another Sydney club.

 

[Big Red]

Signing Reynolds would have been the definition of reactionary.

It could also have been a master stroke.

 

[weststigerman]

He has said he wants to return to Sydney let's see what happens

The rumour he is going to Newcastle is wrong he wants to come home to Sydney

If he goes on the market he’s possibly the first $1.5m player.

2nd best halfback in the comp and only 21.

 

[batboy]

Agreed that he is accountable but there was an ineptitude in the previous admin that we don’t have now. Sure Richo didn’t get his mark but we weren’t left with egg on our face like the failed Lattrell or JAC signings of the past admin. There’s a big difference in a player declining an offer because he doesn’t want to move interstate away from his family, and a player who rejects our offer to go to another Sydney club.

The Point seems to be missed here...

We bought Luai to be the man, Luai came here to be the man...
Now we just offered huge money to a bloke to come have Luai play under him.
It's NOT a back up plan, It's a complete change in direction.
What does that tell Luai about the clubs direction and belief in him?
(All previously well sold, I'm sure)

If I was top class, at the top of my game at my job
and my boss was looking to buy an old bloke on his last legs to come in over me,
I'd certainly be reassessing my options - Especially if I had as many as Luai does.
(And all the contract options to go along with those options)