Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

craigtob said:
I never said we need to replace the above...... my issue is we are still a mile off the top 8, or even the top ten teams, as you have pointed out signing the above players and only winning 1 more game so far is that really a improvement.
Click to expand...
I answered you. I said yes. It is improvement. Objectively, we have improved. We have more wins and we have been competetive in most games this season. I can name 5 from 18 where we have been totally outclassed on the day.

Melbourne
Manly
Parramatta
Penrith
Brisbane

2024, we were outclassed in most games.

Parra is rumoured to be signing Furmor and now people are saying he should be coach of the year on here. I mean this is hard to listen to when people just throw shit out and have no back up to the point their making.

You say don't getbrid of the players, but you imply they haven't made a difference. If getting new players is not the answer, what are you wanting to see from the club that will make you happy they've done the right thing?
 
weststigers said:
I answered you. I said yes. It is improvement. Objectively, we have improved. We have more wins and we have been competetive in most games this season. I can name 5 from 18 where we have been totally outclassed on the day.

Melbourne
Manly
Parramatta
Penrith
Brisbane

2024, we were outclassed in most games.

Parra is rumoured to be signing Furmor and now people are saying he should be coach of the year on here. I mean this is hard to listen to when people just throw shit out and have no back up to the point their making.

You say don't getbrid of the players, but you imply they haven't made a difference. If getting new players is not the answer, what are you wanting to see from the club that will make you happy they've done the right thing?
Click to expand...
Who said that he should be coach of the year? No one said that here
 
mtd#2 said:
There seems to be talk that Makasini will get game time... So how's that fixing the issue if we are bringing fresh 18 year olds in way too young?
Click to expand...
I would say Makasini is an exception and not the rule. He has the physicality of a 23 year old. I hope we don't play him, or need to play him this year, however I'm pretty sure he would handle it. I would rather keep him as our secret weapon in rd 1 2026.
 
weststigerman said:
Exactly. Sign players in a position of need, not just any player who becomes available.
Click to expand...
Really don't get the obsession with getting players to change positions. Same goes for Sam Fainu leave hin where he is, he might end up in the middle in about 3 years not now, only played Front for in u19s SOO because he was twice the size of every other forward on the paddock.
 
Vicious said:
I doubt the Titans would release a player such as Beau Fermor for 2026, but just say they did and we could potentially sign him.
What would be wrong with Fermor, Samuela Fainu and KPP all battling it out for our 2 edge back rowers starting spots and potential for whoever misses out to play 13 or start off the bench ?
Click to expand...
It's a waste of salary cap space, and none of those players are suited to 13 or will be happy playing off the bench.

It creates a problem without actually solving the issues in the squad.
 
weststigers said:
I answered you. I said yes. It is improvement. Objectively, we have improved. We have more wins and we have been competetive in most games this season. I can name 5 from 18 where we have been totally outclassed on the day.

Melbourne
Manly
Parramatta
Penrith
Brisbane

2024, we were outclassed in most games.

Parra is rumoured to be signing Furmor and now people are saying he should be coach of the year on here. I mean this is hard to listen to when people just throw shit out and have no back up to the point their making.

You say don't getbrid of the players, but you imply they haven't made a difference. If getting new players is not the answer, what are you wanting to see from the club that will make you happy they've done the right thing?
Click to expand...
Please winning 1 more game in my eyes is not improving, nor is coming 16th instead of 18th.
Blind Bettty can see we need hard running forwards that has the other teams looking for them, but what do we have Alex 1 and Alex 2, they would not get a start in any other team but are always picked in ours.
And just on new signings is it true we have just signed 2 more halfbacks ???????? why!!, as the games i have attended this year, that is not our weakest spot.
Oh well always next year right.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 442 (members: 44, guests: 398)
Back
Top