Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[innsaneink]

Turuva should stay on the wing. You don't weaken one position to strengthen another, and it's debatable he is a better fullback then Bula in any case. Bula will be one of our most improved players in 2026, mark my words.

Hopefully the sprint training hes been doing gives him that little bit extra he just couldnt find so often, how many times was he 3/4 way thru a gap?

 

[magpies forever]

Jesse Colquhoun is a great young player, but has had a few injuries to start his career, seemed to go ok last year.
I like Curran, dogs got exposed this year for being too small upfront, think he goes better with us good, mobility and covers any of the front 5.

We have a huge question mark over Pole, last season was bad, previous season good. What will 26 bring? If Pole is only playing on here to repay debt to WT (wasn't that what he said last season) and his heart is back in Melbourne, Curran would be a good replacement, but timing is key. Not sure we will know with Pole before Curran wants to sign somewhere.

 

[Tigerstigerstigers]

We have a huge question mark over Pole, last season was bad, previous season good. What will 26 bring? If Pole is only playing on here to repay debt to WT (wasn't that what he said last season) and his heart is back in Melbourne, Curran would be a good replacement, but timing is key. Not sure we will know with Pole before Curran wants to sign somewhere.

Doesn’t need to be either or. Just add him in. We need competition for spots. Which in itself could bring the best out in Pole

 

[Muffstar]

I can only see Geyer being a stop gap.
Roberts could be something.

I reckon Geyer will head to Perth once his year with us is finished.

 

[innsaneink]

I reckon Geyer will head to Perth once his year with us is finished.

The way Perth are going they may have to accept anyone who wishes to go there...only got about 6 players so far

 

[bptiger 0]

He can leave in any direction but WTs.

Really ?

 

[Tucker]

We have a huge question mark over Pole, last season was bad, previous season good. What will 26 bring? If Pole is only playing on here to repay debt to WT (wasn't that what he said last season) and his heart is back in Melbourne, Curran would be a good replacement, but timing is key. Not sure we will know with Pole before Curran wants to sign somewhere.

I agree, Pole looked disinterested pretty much all year.

 

[gregjm87]

Jesse Colquin from the sharks testing the waters

Josh Curran apparently lookin around

Bula deal hopefully announced soon apparently all sorted

Apparently all sorted according to whom?
Colquhoun would be a great signing, assuming he can get his body right (which I back him to sooner rather than later).
Curran would be very handy but I don't see him wanting to be here. Even after signing with Dogs because no-one else came close to matching their offer he was still kicking stones about not finding a contract at a stronger club.

 

[Buttface]

considering this thread has been the general discussions thread for as long as you’ve been here - maybe it’s not the problem…

Some of us like to live in continuous hope. It’s part of being a Balmain Magpies fan. 😎

 

[innsaneink]

Apparently all sorted according to whom?
Colquhoun would be a great signing, assuming he can get his body right (which I back him to sooner rather than later).
Curran would be very handy but I don't see him wanting to be here. Even after signing with Dogs because no-one else came close to matching their offer he was still kicking stones about not finding a contract at a stronger club.

Kade7 mentioned it yesterday....i think his info is usually pretty good

K

Post in thread 'Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion'

Sunday at 9:21 AM

believe bula's deal has now been finalised

also as much as i dislike the hbg
richo isnt as innocent as he is coming across
i am glad that this has all unfolded before then start of the season

• kade7

• 
• 

 

[Squater]

Yes Shaun Mielenkamp is a much younger,, much more honest and a much better value for money CEO than what Richo was, so we have obtained a great outcome with Richo leaving.
However it’s an absolute disgrace a CEO is receiving a 1.5 million dollar payout, he knew what he was doing and only joined us to top up his super annuation.

Great character assignation mate. You must be so proud

 

[Vicious]

Great character assignation mate. You must be so proud

He is not squeaky clean in this whole matter, I cannot believe how many people cannot see it.

 

[weststigers]

I can only see Geyer being a stop gap.
Roberts could be something.

Excited by Roberts. Looks to have something

 

[Tucker]

He is not squeaky clean in this whole matter, I cannot believe how many people cannot see it.

He is spoken about as if he’s a god on here for some reason.
Apart from financially, he did a pretty average job here for mine and if it’s true he was double dipping or ripping us off to boot then I’m glad he’s gone.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

For us atm i think Bula is a must keep, purely because we need a win after all this garbage the HBG caused and despite a few short comings is pretty talented at the back he's just an athlete.
Now having said that he's a must keep, he isn't a keep at all costs there's a reason we didnt activate his clause and no one else picked him up at the quoted prices. He just isn't worth that yet... Not to say he won't be one day just isnt now.
Hopefully we've hashed something out suitable to both parties i find it hard to believe it's done because Richo would have been driving things he isnt here now i dont think SM can pick up from where Richo left off that quickly, kudos if he did however.

 

[Squater]

He is not squeaky clean in this whole matter, I cannot believe how many people cannot see it.

Put up the proof so you can sway us. I ll be the first to apologise to you if you do. But to Lay claims without proof you will only have people like me standing up for Richo. I would do the same for anyone who can't defend themselves.

 

[Odessa]

Yes Shaun Mielenkamp is a much younger,, much more honest and a much better value for money CEO than what Richo was, so we have obtained a great outcome with Richo leaving.
However it’s an absolute disgrace a CEO is receiving a 1.5 million dollar payout, he knew what he was doing and only joined us to top up his super annuation.

If he has a contract and HBG breaks it why would he not be paid adults getting into contracts have lawyers and legal advice it's not like it's to two 15 year old kids

 

[Vicious]

If he has a contract and HBG breaks it why would he not be paid adults getting into contracts have lawyers and legal advice it's not like it's to two 15 year old kids

Of course he will get paid according to his contract, I’m of the opinion he was never really planning to see out the full term,

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

Of course he will get paid according to his contract, I’m of the opinion he was never really planning to see out the full term,

Don't you think it's about time HBG sell and let an owner with more dough have a go V.

That's how I feel they've had years to get it right and keep stuffing up this latest bomb they dropped just ruined the harmony every supporter was enjoying, they have had enough time for a change.

 

[weststigers]

Of course he will get paid according to his contract, I’m of the opinion he was never really planning to see out the full term,

The plot thickens...what else was that scallywag scheming?