Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[weststigers]

Lomax asked for a release mid year, and Pezet manager was all over the situation well before the end of the season - claiming Lomax had played his last game for the Eels (he knew where the money was coming from and where it was going)

Browns money was spent not long after he announced he was moving on and Lomax money was spent on Pezet and Kelly.

If they didn’t spend it on Pezet and Kelly, where is it - they knocked him back when he was looking to return.

Furthermore, where are they getting the money for Stefano, Coates etc.
they haven’t got a mill sitting there, even if Melbourne would release one.

It's a good dinner table discussion. Perhaps even for the pub, but should we care?

Shouldn't we be positive?

Where are all the guys that want to play devils advocate and ignore the past in this situation?

Anyone? Hello?

 

[Bus 2 Terrigal Lagoon]

If a Storm player was to go over to them and it would be a decent one, it would definitely have the smell of stinky salary cap syndrome.

The same faint whiff coming from some of the clubs through the years.

I’m sure HBG have got their finger prints all over this mess.
#Typical

Word on the street is - Lorax to Melbourne: Storm Man to Parramatta - a like for like swap.

#RugbyLeagueIsTheWinner

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

I’m sure HBG have got their finger prints all over this mess.
#Typical

Word on the street is - Lorax to Melbourne: Storm Man to Parramatta - a like for like swap.

#RugbyLeagueIsTheWinner

I promised that I wouldn't mention you know who for the time being, don't poke the bear.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Mate what do you know 🤣 he hasn’t played any prop other than a year in cup

He’s been a second rower and lock for most of his career

Instead of talking about a kid who has done more this morning than you have done your whole life, why don’t you celebrate that we have a wealthy and fruitful junior system promoting our cubs

Sukkar was hitting hard in defence and got into good position to unload near the Rooser's line especially when he got one on one with the defender. I like his progress and certainly if he is a client of Moses, it says a lot about his ceiling.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

Tony is 104 kg and 186 cm, which is a decent size but fairly typical for an NRL forward, and he’ll only be 22 this year.

Most forwards take time to establish themselves in the NRL because the physical advantage they relied on in juniors disappears, forcing them to develop technical, tactical, and mental attributes before they can compete effectively.

I haven't seen much from him that suggests he has or had something else other than some size in juniors. It can translate to NRL, but he's not particularly aggressive like Sam Fainu...it's actually what I worry about with KPP too. Seyfarth...aggressive without the size to back it up.

I'm certain Tony is a good bloke though.

And we have to remember not every player in our top 30 is signed with potential to be a superstar. We need solid depth players who know Benji's system & can play the role set for them.

I thought Sukkar was very good in the trial on Saturday and actually was strong in contact on both sides of the ball.

 

[Tigerscout]

Sukkar was hitting hard in defence and got into good position to unload near the Rooser's line especially when he got one on one with the defender. I like his progress and certainly if he is a client of Moses, it says a lot about his ceiling.

100% mate, his potential is right up there

Would love to see him evolve over the next few years

 

[Tiger Tarl]

Got some 2nd hand signing info from reliable source that may have been posted here already.

Bula was offered a 4 year deal (new deal starting 2027 not extension) worth $3.5M late last year. Apparently his manager said they only want 2 years. Tigers then presented a 2 year offer but it turns out Bula is happy to stay longer (mixed messages from his manager).

Twal's extension was a renegotiation, ie. Took less over more years. Also, as I've hinted at before, Bird is gone. Not sure why they haven't announced it yet. He thinks the English club may be waiting for us to kick in more or its a visa thing. Regardless, there's no waiting on his release for cap relief as we are in a good spot and even able to frontload some of the bigger contracts which could mean a play for a big signing for 2027. Although, internally very settled and the coaching team wants to see how we go before closing in on a target. He still thinks we were heavily in the box for a big name forward but hasn't heard anything else about that for a while.

 

[Tiger in boots 🐅]

Sukkar has actually played most of his footy days as a prop. So no, it's fair. He only played second row due to a lack of other options, like Seyfarth. They're both props. As is Roberts.

That’s why he is called Balmain Boy, he is just a Boy! The problem is he has NFI - Team did well for first trail game. This week will be interesting to watch with minimal chop and changes

 

[Betterdays22]

Got some 2nd hand signing info from reliable source that may have been posted here already.

Bula was offered a 4 year deal (new deal starting 2027 not extension) worth $3.5M late last year. Apparently his manager said they only want 2 years. Tigers then presented a 2 year offer but it turns out Bula is happy to stay longer (mixed messages from his manager).

Twal's extension was a renegotiation, ie. Took less over more years. Also, as I've hinted at before, Bird is gone. Not sure why they haven't announced it yet. He thinks the English club may be waiting for us to kick in more or its a visa thing. Regardless, there's no waiting on his release for cap relief as we are in a good spot and even able to frontload some of the bigger contracts which could mean a play for a big signing for 2027. Although, internally very settled and the coaching team wants to see how we go before closing in on a target. He still thinks we were heavily in the box for a big name forward but hasn't heard anything else about that for a while.

Great info mate cheers

 

[weststigers]

Sukkar has actually played most of his footy days as a prop. So no, it's fair. He only played second row due to a lack of other options, like Seyfarth. They're both props. As is Roberts.

I thought you weren't that invested brother?

 

[Ecto-1]

Got some 2nd hand signing info from reliable source that may have been posted here already.

Bula was offered a 4 year deal (new deal starting 2027 not extension) worth $3.5M late last year. Apparently his manager said they only want 2 years. Tigers then presented a 2 year offer but it turns out Bula is happy to stay longer (mixed messages from his manager).

Twal's extension was a renegotiation, ie. Took less over more years. Also, as I've hinted at before, Bird is gone. Not sure why they haven't announced it yet. He thinks the English club may be waiting for us to kick in more or it’s a visa thing. Regardless, there's no waiting on his release for cap relief as we are in a good spot and even able to frontload some of the bigger contracts which could mean a play for a big signing for 2027. Although, internally very settled and the coaching team wants to see how we go before closing in on a target. He still thinks we were heavily in the box for a big name forward but hasn't heard anything else about that for a while.

Birds delay is Visa Issues. Was in an interview with Brad Arthur.

 

[Oldman]

I agree with you mate. It’s difficult to be yourself when you’re in such a rigid system.
As I said previous, I remember him as a player who was pure aggression and 100% attack. Maybe the coaching staff have a mould for him and expect him to stick to it

You guys do know that once kids get into grade they are taught 2 things
1. When you have the ball it’s land on your stomach and get a quick play the ball
2. Defence wise hold the attacker up don’t let him get to ground until another teammate or hopefully 2 arrive and then put him on the ground on his back.

Unless of course you are a superstar then you can still play eyes up football.

The games not what it used to be 😩

 

[diedpretty]

Lomax asked for a release mid year, and Pezet manager was all over the situation well before the end of the season - claiming Lomax had played his last game for the Eels (he knew where the money was coming from and where it was going)

Browns money was spent not long after he announced he was moving on and Lomax money was spent on Pezet and Kelly.

If they didn’t spend it on Pezet and Kelly, where is it - they knocked him back when he was looking to return.

Furthermore, where are they getting the money for Stefano, Coates etc.
they haven’t got a mill sitting there, even if Melbourne would release one.

I think they knocked him back because they don't want him and why would they - what they want is a decent compensation - not the pennies Melbourne are offering

 

[tiger05premier]

Got some 2nd hand signing info from reliable source that may have been posted here already.

Bula was offered a 4 year deal (new deal starting 2027 not extension) worth $3.5M late last year. Apparently his manager said they only want 2 years. Tigers then presented a 2 year offer but it turns out Bula is happy to stay longer (mixed messages from his manager).

Twal's extension was a renegotiation, ie. Took less over more years. Also, as I've hinted at before, Bird is gone. Not sure why they haven't announced it yet. He thinks the English club may be waiting for us to kick in more or its a visa thing. Regardless, there's no waiting on his release for cap relief as we are in a good spot and even able to frontload some of the bigger contracts which could mean a play for a big signing for 2027. Although, internally very settled and the coaching team wants to see how we go before closing in on a target. He still thinks we were heavily in the box for a big name forward but hasn't heard anything else about that for a while.

Great info thanks mate

 

[Spartan117]

Isn't kit going to Perth?

Younger brother Luke Yes...

Hopefully the Tigers retain Kit.

Can never have enough good Props

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Bulla needs to sign up by Friday , this is just taking to long , 2 contracts and he still cant sign , let him go and use AD this year and Attard next year , Bulla and his manager are just pissing us around , club is bigger than both of them

Or what? Just because fans hate waiting?

Yeah lets chuck an impatient tantrum and never play finals.

Attard isn’t close to NRL level and AD at fullback is long past. Turuva is the next up option.

 

[tiger_one]

Got some 2nd hand signing info from reliable source that may have been posted here already.

Bula was offered a 4 year deal (new deal starting 2027 not extension) worth $3.5M late last year. Apparently his manager said they only want 2 years. Tigers then presented a 2 year offer but it turns out Bula is happy to stay longer (mixed messages from his manager).

Twal's extension was a renegotiation, ie. Took less over more years. Also, as I've hinted at before, Bird is gone. Not sure why they haven't announced it yet. He thinks the English club may be waiting for us to kick in more or its a visa thing. Regardless, there's no waiting on his release for cap relief as we are in a good spot and even able to frontload some of the bigger contracts which could mean a play for a big signing for 2027. Although, internally very settled and the coaching team wants to see how we go before closing in on a target. He still thinks we were heavily in the box for a big name forward but hasn't heard anything else about that for a while.

Luv ya work champion @Tiger Tarl

 

[bigsiro]

I'm saying a fair and reasonable offer is OK.
BUT NOT AN INFLATED PRICE TAG as a top 4 fullback may demand.
No paying overs to someone who has $$$$ in their eyes and ready to leave for another club if we don't cough up the big dollars.
We must manage the cap with a touch of reality. There are other important players to fit under the cap.
Is that clear enough for you?

Not quite. The cap rationale makes sense.

I still don’t see the logic in Attard’s “nil drop off” relative to a 24 year old Bula who hasn’t peaked.

The tone didn’t help. I’ll leave it there.

 

[balmain boy]

Firstly Welcome to the WTF.

Kit is 20. He is a mini mountain.
Got tons of development and growth to come.

I hope both he and the Tigers stay patient.

He's gonna be a fan favourite

Mini mountain?
A small big guy?

He's no mountain . If he had a great career maybe he'll be able to emulate someone like fui fui moi Moi.

He's the smallest prop in the NRL. He's learning how to go from a lock to a 10 minute impact bench prop.

He still has some potential but the odds are firmly stacked against him. He had a good match the other day and hopefully builds on that

 

[balmain boy]

In the last 10 years lol....ive watched him since he was 8 years old. He never gets dominated carrying the ball, never. Your biased against him big time and its clouding your eyes.

That being said, I may be biased towards him because i never thought he would play NRL, so im surprised he has gone ok at a young age. Maybe that clouds my judgement a little. He was average on Saturday. Never got dominated like you make up, but he got stood up badly twice by footwork just hanging the arm out. And it reminded that he has always just hung an arm out when footwork is put on him. If he doesn't fix that then he is gone. For the record I dont know him. My son played against him and I always respected Tony because he was bigger and faster than everyone in the comp but he was never a grub. So I wish him well.

I think sentiment is clouding your judgement. He's like a Temu Twal. Tries hard, good bloke but gets dominated in attack and defence. We have Twal already secured, there's some value in a quiet worker. We don't have space for another one.

He wouldn't make any other team's top 30 at this stage. We signed Geyer and Roberts so we wouldn't need to rely on him. He's not terrible, but he's not a first grader. See how he goes in Cup. Hopefully he can give time to youngsters line Godinet who could but shouldn't be rushed into Cup anytime in the next few months.