Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Tiger-ferret]

Worst backline in the NRL when at full strength?

If you line it up, position by position, where do you rank us? Take potential out of it.

 

[Betterdays22]

If you line it up, position by position, where do you rank us? Take potential out of it.

IMO better than Dogs, Gold Coast, Dragons, Eels at the very least. You could argue at least on par with Manly, Raiders, Cowboys

 

[batboy]

IMO better than Dogs, Gold Coast, Dragons, Eels at the very least. You could argue at least on par with Manly, Raiders, Cowboys

You looking at last weeks line ups, or at full strength...
Take Parra,
Addo Carr is better than our Wingers, Iongi probably not that far behind Bula (If at all) We have a better Centre in May - But I'd take Simmonson over any of our Wingers. Penisini and Russell probably better than what we're offering up for the most part.
Gold Coast have a Tier 1 Rep Fullback and Origin Winger - Maybe on par with ours?

 

[IronFist!]

We are playing Haywood in Flegg plus occasional bench games in cup for this same reason

As he should be. He doesn’t even turn 20 until December. Even Reserve grade is a stretch for him defensively.

Pattie is 22.

Cronilla players play 40 odd games of reserve grade before becoming first graders.

Wests Tigers push kids into first grade far too soon.

 

[Betterdays22]

You looking at last weeks line ups, or at full strength...
Take Parra,
Addo Carr is better than our Wingers, Iongi probably not that far behind Bula (If at all) We have a better Centre in May - But I'd take Simmonson over any of our Wingers. Penisini and Russell probably better than what we're offering up for the most part.
Gold Coast have a Tier 1 Rep Fullback and Origin Winger - Maybe on par with ours?

Maybe at least equal with the Eels? Dont forget when we were going well our backs out of yardage were great.

Bula - 7/10
Iongi 6/10

Turuva 7/10
Simmonson 7/10

May 8/10
Russell 6/10

Makasini 5/10
Penisini 7/10

Laulili 6/10
Fox 7.5/10

Tigers 33
Eels 33.5

Might be being a bit harsh on Makasini. Eels backs also have the benefit of playing with an elite half in Moses

 

[batboy]

Maybe at least equal with the Eels? Dont forget when we were going well our backs out of yardage were great.

Bula - 7/10
Iongi 6/10

Turuva 7/10
Simmonson 7/10

May 8/10
Russell 6/10

Makasini 5/10
Penisini 7/10

Laulili 6/10
Fox 7.5/10

Tigers 33
Eels 33.5

Might be being a bit harsh on Makasini. Eels backs also have the benefit of playing with an elite half in Moses

Yeah - Maybe....
Based on his last few games, Might also be generous.

On the same Sheet,
If Laulilii is only 1.5 points behind JAC - I'll eat my hat.

 

[Wezt]

Tigers Vs Storm in Vegas

Eels v Titans 2nd game

Surprisingly dolphins miss out

 

[Tiger-ferret]

IMO better than Dogs, Gold Coast, Dragons, Eels at the very least. You could argue at least on par with Manly, Raiders, Cowboys

I reckon Dogs centres and wingers chew us up. lol about manly. Agree for titans dragons and eels. Cowboys and raiders I’m on the fence. IMO we are easily in the bottom half of the comp, if not bottom quarter.

 

[mtd#2]

I reckon Dogs centres and wingers chew us up. lol about manly. Agree for titans dragons and eels. Cowboys and raiders I’m on the fence. IMO we are easily in the bottom half of the comp, if not bottom quarter.

Dogs fans are losing it over how shit their edges have been the last few weeks.

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Dogs fans are losing it over how shit their edges have been the last few weeks.

Agree they have been poo but they are a broken team. Bar tracey I reckon they formidable.

 

[Airport05]

Maybe at least equal with the Eels? Dont forget when we were going well our backs out of yardage were great.

Bula - 7/10
Iongi 6/10

Turuva 7/10
Simmonson 7/10

May 8/10
Russell 6/10

Makasini 5/10
Penisini 7/10

Laulili 6/10
Fox 7.5/10

Tigers 33
Eels 33.5

Might be being a bit harsh on Makasini. Eels backs also have the benefit of playing with an elite half in Moses

I like Simmonson, but no way he is on par with Turuva. Tito is very, very good.