Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Leck said:
He’s 6 ft and 84 kg, and he’s only 24, so he’ll probably fill out a bit more.

However, the NRL has changed. It’s about speed and smarts, not just brute strength. We’ll see leaner, faster and much more athletic backs in the coming years.

You just have to look at the amazing season Keano Kini had this year. He’s 5'8" and 82 kg.
Click to expand...
Yeah but Keano Kini has elite evasion in the mould of Matt Bowen, Paps, Fa'alogo.
 
mtd#2 said:
One horrible game and they were knocked out of the finals. Drinky was fully fit. Bula has been injured all season (except the start when he was in fine form).

I wonder if you'd be so kind to bula if he was soley responsible for us being knocked out of finals?

You get upset if someone brings up richo and say they are "living in the past" but here you are talking about Herbie who signed for the Dolphins in 2023.. stay on topic.

Drinkwater is a liability a club like us dont need. His flaws would be exposed 10 fold here.
Click to expand...
Let’s hope you are correct as it will not be good if we finish behind the Dragons in 2027
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Maybe they are & doing this as well to cast the net as wide as possible and for transparency. I don’t mind this approach. Most high performance sports in Australia do this except most clubs in NRL & AFL.
Click to expand...
And Perth Bears, Souths, Dragons, Dogs all have various roles up on the site. My guess is that its a requirement of a professional organisations approach. In corporate jobs I will often know who I am going to hire but am still required to advertise for a certain amount of time for transparency. Id imagine this would be the same
 
No one was talking about bula and $1m in 2023
Vicious said:
What about when I was suggesting Herbie Farnworth as our million dollar player a couple of years back instead of focusing on Bula as our marquee player,
Was you one of the many who tried to argue that spending 1 million on Bula instead of head hunting a player like Farnworth who was earning nowhere near 1 million per season for the Broncos back then.
Click to expand...
If only we listened to you back in 2023 when no one whatsoever mentioned Bula and $1m in his first year while we were collecting spoons...and no one was talking about Herbie ar brisbane
You re-writing history hmmm? 🤔
 
Yes we need depth and we need a solution to the halves but for mine, go all out for Leota to have a solid, big motored, partner for May. I think this would give us a huge forward platform with KPP and Samuela. But we seem to be going in other directions
 
innsaneink said:
No one was talking about bula and $1m in 2023

If only we listened to you back in 2023 when no one whatsoever mentioned Bula and $1m in his first year while we were collecting spoons...and no one was talking about Herbie ar brisbane
You re-writing history hmmm? 🤔
Click to expand...
You were one of the many who thought Luai was the equal of Nathan Cleary and Bula was a superstar in the making.
Bad decision making on recruitment and retention is our biggest downfall, but there are some signs that Benji is starting to see the light.
 
Vicious said:
You were one of the many who thought Luai was the equal of Nathan Cleary and Bula was a superstar in the making.
Bad decision making on recruitment and retention is our biggest downfall, but there are some signs that Benji is starting to see the light.
Click to expand...
Gallant would not be head of recruitment at any other club
 
Tucker said:
Lots of people were talking about Herbie at Broncs. He was a gun there.
Click to expand...
Were also talking about him wanting to play Fullback.
He signed an extension at the Broncos on the promise he'd get the off season to take the Fullback Jersey.

It didn't eventuate and he left, if he left because he didn't get a shot at #1, I don't know.

Talk is he'll take Tedescos Jumper, He'd be lethal there - I'm a big fan.
Total Pro.
 
wstigers11 said:
Gallant would not be head of recruitment at any other club
Click to expand...
Not many about that know SW Sydney as well as Gallant.
Weather he's liked or not, I don't know - He give plenty of lip while playing out there.
But he's got the lay of the Land.

I can't think of anyone he's missed outside the Clarke boys
- Even then, We didn't really miss them - They were with Wests.

What he shouldn't be, Is the only bloke in the gig...
Most (if not all) Clubs would have at least 3-4 Staff in Pathways Recruitment.
 
batboy said:
Not many about that know SW Sydney as well as Gallant.
Weather he's liked or not, I don't know - He give plenty of lip while playing out there.
But he's got the lay of the Land.

I can't think of anyone he's missed outside the Clarke boys
- Even then, We didn't really miss them - They were with Wests.

What he shouldn't be, Is the only bloke in the gig...
Most (if not all) Clubs would have at least 3-4 Staff in Pathways Recruitment.
Click to expand...
Should also not solely focus on SW Sydney.
 
innsaneink said:
No one was talking about bula and $1m in 2023

If only we listened to you back in 2023 when no one whatsoever mentioned Bula and $1m in his first year while we were collecting spoons...and no one was talking about Herbie ar brisbane
You re-writing history hmmm? 🤔
Click to expand...
It’s his specialty. @Vicious is a habitual liar and thinks his time being the water boy in his 30s for an under 7s team makes him more qualified than anyone else on here
 
mtd#2 said:
One horrible game and they were knocked out of the finals. Drinky was fully fit. Bula has been injured all season (except the start when he was in fine form).

I wonder if you'd be so kind to bula if he was soley responsible for us being knocked out of finals?

You get upset if someone brings up richo and say they are "living in the past" but here you are talking about Herbie who signed for the Dolphins in 2023.. stay on topic.

Drinkwater is a liability a club like us dont need. His flaws would be exposed 10 fold here.
Click to expand...
He loves to shit all over Bula but then cries and runs to mods if you point out that Heath Mason is a smear on the underpants of rugby league.
 
Chunk said:
Yeah, I was just asking the question about where he could play 13 in defence.

I see clearly you don't think he should be afforded any 'leway' even when considering he was our best player before he was injured? And arguably one of the competitions best players?

Or are you judging him on the games after he came back from injury when the team was rat sh*t?
Click to expand...
I'm judging him on his entire career at the WTs
He did have some good games ....his best the Warriors ......when he ran STRAIGHT and HARD , didn't OVERPLAe Y his hand like he does virtually every game h

So exactly how many games has he played like that in his 7 years here ....let alone this season

His defence has been dusty throughout his entire career .....he consistently has been lazy working after opposition make a break and been very injury prone

Add in the fact he has told two coaches at our club to stick it when he doesn't get picked where he wants to play

I would keep his goalkicking and his kicking for touch from penalties

His cons outweigh his pros

Bye Bye Adam
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 4,619 (members: 20, guests: 4,599)
Back
Top