Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Great episode of Backstage with Cooper & Matty Johns, featuring Harry Grant & Jack Bostock.

Jack said he's a lifelong Wests Tigers fan and that Benji is his favourite player of all time. But he also said he'll choose a NSW club that gives him the best opportunity to win a premiership.

Worth a listen.

 
Great episode of Backstage with Cooper & Matty Johns, featuring Harry Grant & Jack Bostock.

Jack said he's a lifelong Wests Tigers fan and that Benji is his favourite player of all time. But he also said he'll choose a NSW club that gives him the best opportunity to win a premiership.

Worth a listen.

That sounds like he’s going to the Roosters
 
That sounds like he’s going to the Roosters
I think so, but St George are apparently throwing the kitchen sink at him with a huge contract.

He also mentioned on the podcast that he'd rather take less money and win than take more money and lose.

Hopefully that counts for something. You'd like to think the chance to play for the club he grew up supporting, alongside his favourite player of all time, would carry some weight. But I doubt it.

The whole Cleary and Fowler debacle just shows how out of touch we are when it comes to recruitment.
 
Would be very surprising.

I hope someone out there in fan land is keeping tabs on PNG's salary totals. The way it's going they'll have nothing left for players 21-30.
2028 cap isnt confirmed.... why do I feel like PNG have intel that the cap is going to be a massive upgrade in 2028 and thats why they are locking in players on big money because the cap will increase so much in 2028 comapred to next year? because with there current spending half there squad will take up 90% of the cap... not sustainable
 
I think so, but St George are apparently throwing the kitchen sink at him with a huge contract.

He also mentioned on the podcast that he'd rather take less money and win than take more money and lose.

Hopefully that counts for something. You'd like to think the chance to play for the club he grew up supporting, alongside his favourite player of all time, would carry some weight. But I doubt it.

The whole Cleary and Fowler debacle just shows how out of touch we are when it comes to recruitment.
So it's a no from you to sign Cleary?
 
So it's a no from you to sign Cleary?
Of course we should sign Cleary if we could.

But the reality is, our club is a basket case. So much so that his dad jumped off the bus back in 2018. Since then, we've picked up three wooden spoons.

It's hard to attract elite players when HBG hasn't given anyone any reason to believe things are going to change.
 
Of course we should sign Cleary if we could.

But the reality is, our club is a basket case. So much so that his dad jumped off the bus back in 2018. Since then, we've picked up three wooden spoons.

It's hard to attract elite players when HBG hasn't given anyone any reason to believe things are going to change.
No smart club would sign Cleary until he plays a season to prove he's over the injury, it's a big money gamble.

Those lower leg fractures can be dicky, they heal but can be a weak spot prone to breaking again close to the old spot, knew a team mate only 30, it happened to him and he never played soccer again.
 
No smart club would sign Cleary until he plays a season to prove he's over the injury, it's a big money gamble.

Those lower leg fractures can be dicky, they heal but can be a weak spot prone to breaking again close to the old spot, knew a team mate only 30, it happened to him and he never played soccer again.
That's true, but the shoulder dislocation, along with the ligament and tendon damage in SOS 2021, was also brutal. However he managed to return and play through it, and they went on to win the premiership with him. I wouldn't write Nathan off.

The fact is, our play for Nathan and Mary always seemed like a pie in the sky fantasy. We put forward a strange two for one deal involving Nathan coming to us and Mary going to the Mariners.

Why would Mary want to leave Manchester City at her peak to play for the Mariners. That's crazy.

I honestly don't understand what's going on at our club, what HBG's vision is or where we're heading.

And what exactly has @ShaunMielekamp been brought in to do, given his previous role as CEO of the men's Mariners team and HBG's focus on football?

There are so many questions about the club's direction, and no clear answers.
 
Back
Top