OFFICIAL Starford To’a #253

[Demps]

I would be giving the knights a call and ask is James Schiller available wing and centre solid player he's stuck behind some great players up there

Yeah, he's been playing cup.
Always liked him.

Have seen some shocking performances from him this year though.
Still, better than Starford.

 

[BirchgroveTiger]

Herbert in for Toa. Herbert can tackle, Toa can’t tackle . Herbert was best player in the Cup game vs Parra on Easter Monday. He won’t let us down, Toa didn’t even try to tackle, not acceptable!
I’d have Skelton and Turuva on the wing

 

[orange&black]

Before Toa was back in the side we had 17 guys who were trying their guts out in every aspect of the game. Sorry but he just doesn’t fit that ethic. Give me Herbert any day ahead of Toa, at least Herbert looks like he wants to be there. He might make a mistake but he’s giving it everything.
Toa on the other hand is a soft and lazy player.

 

[upthetigers]

Nofoaluma 2.0

Noffa was a better player then Toa

 

[upthetigers]

Herbert in for Toa. Herbert can tackle, Toa can’t tackle . Herbert was best player in the Cup game vs Parra on Easter Monday. He won’t let us down, Toa didn’t even try to tackle, not acceptable!
I’d have Skelton and Turuva on the wing

And who at fullback?

 

[Tom Shines]

Difference is not ONCE this year has Makasini dodged contact or deliberately taken the soft option, he is also a rookie .. I’d much rather a player miss a tackle while putting his body on the line like maka might or even Tavama did yesterday than a player that just dogged it like toa did on several occasions yesterday and previously.. tavana had a shocker but he kept trying his heart out .. I’ll take that over a Toa every day of the week

I’m actually saying to pick Herbert out of the three this week ..give Makasini a chance to get a confidence booster in NSW Cup,,,

I will bet Benji sees it different and keeps his boy Toa