Starting team 2021

@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

I’m not sure Madge would have signed BJ and Roberts if he thought Momo was the answer.
 
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287353) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

I’m not sure Madge would have signed BJ and Roberts if he thought Momo was the answer.

He's our 'go to' man. He can go to the bulldogs.
 
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

If we consider players 'potential' and their success in the past, we have Packer (international, great hits, aggressive), Raynolds ('Origin' player), Mbye ('Origin' player) but all of them, regardless of their 'potential' are of no value to the WT, and it seems we have a hard time selling them to anyone.:angry:
So, as we have no goal kicker (with AD out), Momirovski is actually a must, and better value (as a package) then BJ or Roberts.
 
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287353) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

I’m not sure Madge would have signed BJ and Roberts if he thought Momo was the answer.

That’s like owning an Aston Martin and a Lamborghini then conceding the AM is a bad car just because you own a Lamborghini. Competition for spots is fine
 
@InBenjiWeTrust said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287355) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

If we consider players 'potential' and their success in the past, we have Packer (international, great hits, aggressive), Raynolds ('Origin' player), Mbye ('Origin' player) but all of them, regardless of their 'potential' are of no value to the WT, and it seems we have a hard time selling them to anyone.:angry:
So, as we have no goal kicker (with AD out), Momirovski is actually a must, and better value (as a package) then BJ or Roberts.

I don’t know how it’s so hard to understand lol. Momo is great value
 
@twentyforty said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287242) said:
@Swordy said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287239) said:
Needed a laugh.......Roberts fullback, Momo 5/8......

Its been a long off season....

Heres a bombshell. I dont think there is any guarantee that Roberts will play a single game for us. Its 50/50 as to whether he could even stay straight for the season start. I hope he does, but im not putting any money on it.

As for momo....lucky to be first grade at all.


“Lucky to be first grade at all” ??
So he can start with the premiers but Tigers, who haven’t made the playoffs in a decade can’t fit him in? He may not have a clutch moment which sticks in people’s minds but he has nailed the reliable part of his play. I think he is the best centre we have at this time. I’m waiting for the other centres to prove me wrong?

If only all of our players could score 14 try's in 19 games and kick at 75%
I would say we would have won a few more games
Momirovski has the ability to score a try just when it seems impossible
We have seen a few of those in 2019
If there is one area he his lacking it is his tackling efficiency
If we can get close enough to the line, paul is capable of getting it over better then most in our team IMO
I think if Paul could pack on a little more weight (muscle) it would help with his tackling
But that needs to be done without loosing any speed
 
@gallagher said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287354) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287353) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

I’m not sure Madge would have signed BJ and Roberts if he thought Momo was the answer.

He's our 'go to' man. He can go to the bulldogs.

Unfortunately BJ is contracted to us in 2021
 
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287357) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287353) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

I’m not sure Madge would have signed BJ and Roberts if he thought Momo was the answer.

That’s like owning an Aston Martin and a Lamborghini then conceding the AM is a bad car just because you own a Lamborghini. Competition for spots is fine

Who is the Aston and the Lambo in this?
 
All players in WTs backline without a contract for 2022 will have to perform big time,with some promising juniors and money to spend the club has shown the direction it will take.
 
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287362) said:
@gallagher said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287354) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287353) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

I’m not sure Madge would have signed BJ and Roberts if he thought Momo was the answer.

He's our 'go to' man. He can go to the bulldogs.

Unfortunately BJ is contracted to us in 2021

Do you mean next year ,thats obvious,but if you mean 2022 i think its the clubs option to keep or release.
 
@sleeve said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287366) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287362) said:
@gallagher said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287354) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287353) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

I’m not sure Madge would have signed BJ and Roberts if he thought Momo was the answer.

He's our 'go to' man. He can go to the bulldogs.

Unfortunately BJ is contracted to us in 2021

Do you mean next year ,thats obvious,but if you mean 2022 i think its the clubs option to keep or release.

Yeah club option for 2022 I believe
 
Just looked at the site again ,and it said JL had contract for 2022,with no options mentioned,but im sure only a couple of weeks ago it mentioned club option.Its either a typo ,or been changed.Momo has a player option for 2022. So both players under contract for 2022,depending on your viewpoint either good or bad news.Myself i would like a cleanout.
 
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

He has only played 21 games because he isn't very good.
 
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287358) said:
@InBenjiWeTrust said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287355) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

If we consider players 'potential' and their success in the past, we have Packer (international, great hits, aggressive), Raynolds ('Origin' player), Mbye ('Origin' player) but all of them, regardless of their 'potential' are of no value to the WT, and it seems we have a hard time selling them to anyone.:angry:
So, as we have no goal kicker (with AD out), Momirovski is actually a must, and better value (as a package) then BJ or Roberts.

I don’t know how it’s so hard to understand lol. Momo is great value

If you get him on a low value contract and you stack the rest of the team and let him just slot in as a role player. The problem for Momo is we have BJ, Roberts, Kepaoa and Talau who all look heaps better than him.
 
@Earl said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287375) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287358) said:
@InBenjiWeTrust said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287355) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

If we consider players 'potential' and their success in the past, we have Packer (international, great hits, aggressive), Raynolds ('Origin' player), Mbye ('Origin' player) but all of them, regardless of their 'potential' are of no value to the WT, and it seems we have a hard time selling them to anyone.:angry:
So, as we have no goal kicker (with AD out), Momirovski is actually a must, and better value (as a package) then BJ or Roberts.

I don’t know how it’s so hard to understand lol. Momo is great value

If you get him on a low value contract and you stack the rest of the team and let him just slot in as a role player. The problem for Momo is we have BJ, Roberts, Kepaoa and Talau who all look heaps better than him.

On West’s Tigers form BJ was one of our worst players last year. That’s what I’m going off

I couldn’t give a rats if he won 3 dally ms prior. For us he was terrible
 
@Earl said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287374) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287352) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287351) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287350) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287349) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287347) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287346) said:
@Speed2burn said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287344) said:
@TigerLouis said in [Starting team 2021](/post/1287339) said:
Are you serious about Momo how can you compare him to Roberts & Leilua who are both strike players & Momo is not he is only there for depth.

Are you happy with the way BJ played this year?

BJ was horrible this year but he still offers much more than Momo. Momo’s a plodder imo

I’d argue Momo’s stint with WT has been much more impressive than BJ’s

I think they’ve both been very underwhelming. But when BJ is in form he’s one of the most damaging centres in the game.

Keyword “when”

It remains to be seen if he can bring that form to the tigers, problem is he’ll either get sin binned twice, make 5 errors or score 3 tries and win you the game. No inbetween

And if that’s the case we go to market and go hard for someone like Staggs. Momo isn’t the answer.

Staggs would be a no brainer but I don’t think Momo deserves to be written off. He’s only played 21 games

He has only played 21 games because he isn't very good.

So when he didn’t play this year it was because he wasn’t very good, not because he was injured? Got it


The original comparison was who played better in the WT jersey. I believe Momo schooled BJ when it came to playing for WT
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top