Stefano Utoikamanu #241

Who on earth put or agreed to put these weird clauses in his contract saying
- if WT don't make the top 8 in 2024 he can get out of his contract
- if he "doesnt "make S.O.O he can get out of his contract ? Or is it "does "?
So Penrith lose JFH so what .We are not "Repco" the spare parts store !
A very weak, submissive club.
 
He deserves to. But Madge showed with us he's got no clue on how to pick a side or use interchanges. Plus I could almost see Madge not picking him to spite the Tigers knowing the clause
You’re talking about a man who after he got shafted by our club, took time while on holiday in Europe to make a video for the club to congratulate James Tamou on his 300th game. I don’t think he’s the petty type.
 
He will pick Stef he feels he deserves it.
Who partners Clearly in the halves is the interesting one ? With few suitors fit or in form...
 
Yeah - I reckon he personally drafted these extraordinary clauses....

Get a grip!

Heard of player managers??

This was evidently the handiwork of Mario Tartak - who arguably is meeting his professional obligations to best look after the interest of his client in this case! But - most clubs would not have agreed to these clauses & it demonstrates what his bargaining position was at the time and the spinelessness of our former admin team!

Tartak has been playing silly games since he got the Tigers front office to sign up his boy Fulton on the sly!

That does not mean Stef will exercise the clauses - or was personally angling for an easy escape.

The character of the player will determine the result - NOT the clauses!
Utoikamanu is with Daniel O'Loughlin, not Tartak.
 
You’re talking about a man who after he got shafted by our club, took time while on holiday in Europe to make a video for the club to congratulate James Tamou on his 300th game. I don’t think he’s the petty type.
Same bloke who wouldn't hire competent assistants because he was paranoid about getting shown up and losing his job like when Siebold got his Souths job
 
There's no way Stefano is a million dollar player. Richo specifically said Haas is not a 'game-breaker' late in 2023 and that you don't pay forwards that sort of money. Neither did he sign AFB on a million as he rejected him. So how much more Stefano? He will only get better, but will he be the top prop in the game in the future? If not, he's definitely not worth it. If penrith want to take him on unders and he wants success, he can go. As well as another bottom team overpaying for him. It would be nice to keep him given a lack of quality props in the NRL on the market, but we shouldn't think of overpaying. We still need to lock down Lachie
 
There's no way Stefano is a million dollar player. Richo specifically said Haas is not a 'game-breaker' late in 2023 and that you don't pay forwards that sort of money. Neither did he sign AFB on a million as he rejected him. So how much more Stefano? He will only get better, but will he be the top prop in the game in the future? If not, he's definitely not worth it. If penrith want to take him on unders and he wants success, he can go. As well as another bottom team overpaying for him. It would be nice to keep him given a lack of quality props in the NRL on the market, but we shouldn't think of overpaying. We still need to lock down Lachie
It's all good & well saying he can go but who do you get to replace him? He's probably the best middle on the market atm & if we let him go our options are a declining Klemmer, Pole who still has a bit to go to be a consistent first grader, Sam Fainu, Seyfarth, Twal, Jordan Miller.... not looking too good.
 
It's all good & well saying he can go but who do you get to replace him? He's probably the best middle on the market atm & if we let him go our options are a declining Klemmer, Pole who still has a bit to go to be a consistent first grader, Sam Fainu, Seyfarth, Twal, Jordan Miller.... not looking too good.
💯 correct.
Supply and demand says Stefano will get more than most think as there is absolutely nobody who can adequately replace him.
 
It's all good & well saying he can go but who do you get to replace him? He's probably the best middle on the market atm & if we let him go our options are a declining Klemmer, Pole who still has a bit to go to be a consistent first grader, Sam Fainu, Seyfarth, Twal, Jordan Miller.... not looking too good.
I don't think we should pay him a million to keep him. Highest I'd go is 850K and maybe 900K if he continues to improve. While he's been good this year, he has had periods in his career where he's been below average imo
 
Tigers have to do everything to stop Penrith and or the roosters from poaching Stefano.. too strong clubs with cash for a young fella is very tempting . It goes without saying we need a big year and possibly a pay increase to keep him keen to stay a Tiger..He can't get on Cleary bus .
Imo he is a really decent and sensible bloke H101.
I reckon the most important things to him...are he and the rest of the team good mates, is Benji the rite coach, does he believe WTs are a team on the up, up, and away now that Richo is with us bringing stability to our club.
I believe he will stay with Us.
 
800k for 4 years with salary cap ratchet clauses should get the job done.

Probably overs for where he is. Probably slight unders for what he could become, but juicy enough to allow him to stay.

I can't imagine too many of the big clubs will be forking out a great deal more for a prop.

If someone is ludicrous enough to offer 1 - 1.2 for Stef, then so be it.
 
I don't ALWAYS blame the officials. I just responded to the game that crazycat quoted. The one thing you can be sure of in the NRL today is that 50/50 calls don't go 50/50. Cameron Ciraldo is now finding out the same, now he is not associated with Penrith. Remember the North Qld game a couple of years ago. That had nothing to do with our cattle but a lot to do with officials. He is supposedly our no 1 referee these days.
I remember that game.
We were something like 12/12 at half time. Then got ambushed 36/12

Heck 1 player on report and sharks lead the penalty count. The sharks moved the ball and turned up in the second half.

I won't blame the referees when were Piss poor.
 
800k for 4 years with salary cap ratchet clauses should get the job done.

Probably overs for where he is. Probably slight unders for what he could become, but juicy enough to allow him to stay.

I can't imagine too many of the big clubs will be forking out a great deal more for a prop.

If someone is ludicrous enough to offer 1 - 1.2 for Stef, then so be it.
The Dragons forked out 900k for Luciano!

Props and second rowers are earning the money and a good Lock is considered a "spine" player now.

We should either try to hold onto Stef or really have someone lined up. ... I don't see many props in the line, but happy to replace Stef ... just has to be someone at or better then his level.


Also notice Stef's improvement as a player. I am putting that down to us signing Bateman/Klemmer. Tough players improve tough players.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top