Tallyn Da Silva #270

St George just lost Finau Latu to the Bulldogs much to Flanagan's frustration. Parra. have lost multiple juniors to other clubs and so have Penrith because they couldn't keep them all - Katao and Ilongi both doing great things at their new clubs. Their are lots of things this club has screwed up but it is not unique to lose juniors when all clubs are prepared take risks with young talent.
Great post.
 
St George just lost Finau Latu to the Bulldogs much to Flanagan's frustration. Parra. have lost multiple juniors to other clubs and so have Penrith because they couldn't keep them all - Katao and Ilongi both doing great things at their new clubs. Their are lots of things this club has screwed up but it is not unique to lose juniors when all clubs are prepared take risks with young talent.
We are losing juniors that WE are telling the world will form the nucleus of our squad moving forward indefinitely. These kids were going to have the roster built around them.
It’s not the same thing as the examples you have given.
 
In the bulk of the games Ive seen Latu play, he makes the players around him look better. Friday night we saw his impact on Luai and his brother Samuela...

Galvin and TDS haven't made other players better, it's all individual brilliance... I'd also argue that Latu's better in this department too whilst being the best defender of the 3..
You are correct. Very good players make other players look good. Also it is apparent Luai and Fainu work together well as a team.
 
St George just lost Finau Latu to the Bulldogs much to Flanagan's frustration. Parra. have lost multiple juniors to other clubs and so have Penrith because they couldn't keep them all - Katao and Ilongi both doing great things at their new clubs. Their are lots of things this club has screwed up but it is not unique to lose juniors when all clubs are prepared take risks with young talent.
Katoa and Iongi are not good comparisons because they had their path blocked by Australian representatives in their 20s.

The saying “Can’t keep them all” only works if a couple slip through the net.

We’ve lost Galvin, Large x 2, and now very likely TDS in the space of 6 months. These 4 along with Makasini formed our top 5 juniors. That is not good enough.
 
We are losing juniors that WE are telling the world will form the nucleus of our squad moving forward indefinitely. These kids were going to have the roster built around them.
It’s not the same thing as the examples you have given.

It's not close....
We're coming last - 3 years Running
and not looking real good this year.

Talking about the Panthers losing juniors while winning absolutely everything is not remotely close.
 
It's not close....
We're coming last - 3 years Running
and not looking real good this year.

Talking about the Panthers losing juniors while winning absolutely everything is not remotely close.
Remove the 64-0 drubbing and our F/A is -2. We are tracking better than a 15th placed team but need to start converting some of the close losses. It's not good enough and Richo on down all look incompetent.
 
Remove the 64-0 drubbing and our F/A is -2. We are tracking better than a 15th placed team but need to start converting some of the close losses. It's not good enough and Richo on down all look incompetent.
Spot on.

We aren’t too far away from being edge of the top 4/8.

Vastly improved overall. However being close, isn’t good enough.

6 games this year so far with less then 4 points in the margin. We need to find a way to snag those.
 
Last edited:
So hard this one. I think we should do everything we can to keep them both tbh but if no matter what that isn’t possible, i think we neee to keep Api.

Api has three good years left in him IMO and if he can captain us back to the top 8 and retire a Tiger, he is a proper Tiger legend. He also has a great relationship with Benji and Jarome. Not easy call but that’s the way I’d be going
 
Spot on.

We aren’t too far away from being edge of the top 4/8.

Vastly improved overall. However being close, isn’t good enough.

6 games this year so far with less then 4 points in the margin. W need to find a way to snag those.
We will continue to be close without getting the desired results if we do not recruit sone cutting edge players capable of turning close games in our favour and if Benji doesn’t get sone common sense about his bench selections and interchange decisions.
 
St George just lost Finau Latu to the Bulldogs much to Flanagan's frustration. Parra. have lost multiple juniors to other clubs and so have Penrith because they couldn't keep them all - Katao and Ilongi both doing great things at their new clubs. Their are lots of things this club has screwed up but it is not unique to lose juniors when all clubs are prepared take risks with young talent.
Yes but we were/are suppose to build our future from local talent. You know five year plan blah blah. This looks like our best way out of this mess

And how can we afford to buy players, we have to pay overs, no one of note will come to the joint except for very good money.

TDS is a litmus test, if we lose him, it’s a very bad outcome.
 
We weren’t able to convince TDS to chill and are now resigned to losing him.

It’s not catastrophic, as he will be replaced.

I don’t see a future for Api beyond the next few years and we aren’t performing to a level where we will hit our stride this year and probably next year.
When do you think we will hit our stride ,if ever? Why?
 
So hard this one. I think we should do everything we can to keep them both tbh but if no matter what that isn’t possible, i think we neee to keep Api.

Api has three good years left in him IMO and if he can captain us back to the top 8 and retire a Tiger, he is a proper Tiger legend. He also has a great relationship with Benji and Jarome. Not easy call but that’s the way I’d be going
Wow! Getting us in the top 8 in another 3 yeras. He will be 37. Struggling now to play 50 minutes. i can't believe the low expectations on here for this club. That is why we are where we are and do not look like ever getting out of the cellar any time soon.
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Back
Top