Tallyn Da Silva #270

Yes but we were/are suppose to build our future from local talent. You know five year plan blah blah. This looks like our best way out of this mess

And how can we afford to buy players, we have to pay overs, no one of note will come to the joint except for very good money.

TDS is a litmus test, if we lose him, it’s a very bad outcome.
When your coach admits to not knowing if you will be at the club in two weeks, you might as well start packing your bags. He’s definitely gone. If not in the next week, next year for sure.
 
We need to look at all the juniors that have left within the last 2 years and work out why they left.

Cancer boy is the exception. Yes before anyone says not all of them will make it i understand that i just want to understand the why part of them leaving.
 
I remember reading a post from BWG which resonated -

Comments like this from Tartak must make it hard for TDS to look his captain in the eye at training atm.

This was in response to the following appearing in an article from the Mole -

"Tallyn loves the Tigers - this isn't a Lachlan Galvin-type situation," Tartak emphasised.

"It's up to the Tigers to decide what they want to do but if Api stays, chances are Tallyn will have to go."


I also re-read back in 2023 where Koroisau had offered to switch to 7 to assist the club with its halfback issue well-knowing this may impact his SOO selection. Ask yourself who really loves the club and spare a thought for Koroisau who I'm sure is uncomfortable in having been placed in this position.
 
Gould wanted the Fainu bros and didn't get them. You could sense buyer's remorse during commentary when he spoke about Latu Fainu; he got Galvin but missed the prize. Our much maligned recruitment team bettered him.
Personally I reckon he had an each way bet to shake one free. If Galvin stayed Latu would of been a target
 
I remember reading a post from BWG which resonated -

Comments like this from Tartak must make it hard for TDS to look his captain in the eye at training atm.

This was in response to the following appearing in an article from the Mole -

"Tallyn loves the Tigers - this isn't a Lachlan Galvin-type situation," Tartak emphasised.

"It's up to the Tigers to decide what they want to do but if Api stays, chances are Tallyn will have to go."


I also re-read back in 2023 where Koroisau had offered to switch to 7 to assist the club with its halfback issue well-knowing this may impact his SOO selection. Ask yourself who really loves the club and spare a thought for Koroisau who I'm sure is uncomfortable in having been placed in this position.
It’s pretty slack painting a 20 year old as a villain for wanting the best possible path to first grade. As much as you want to try to make it that way, it’s nothing like Galvin.
 
When your coach admits to not knowing if you will be at the club in two weeks, you might as well start packing your bags. He’s definitely gone. If not in the next week, next year for sure.

Especially when you compare it to the response he gave on Api for 2027.
"He's going nowhere"
 
Especially when you compare it to the response he gave on Api for 2027.
"He's going nowhere"
Has Benji expressed the same conviction at any point to retain TDS? Haven’t even heard him say he wants to retain TDS and then to have some kind of transition plan. To Benji, it’s just “Api Api Api”. And the moral of that story is that TDS is the bad guy for wanting to explore his options? Come on.
 
It’s pretty slack painting a 20 year old as a villain for wanting the best possible path to first grade. As much as you want to try to make it that way, it’s nothing like Galvin.
His management came out with its him or me spiel and attempted to distance themselves from Galvin. He is also under contract until end of 26 well knowing at the time he had one of the best hookers in the NRL in front of him. It is his management team who also mentioned Galvin, not me. Koroisau is not blocking his pathway to the NRL because at this time Da Silva is a good young player but cannot displace Koroisau.
 
Wow! Getting us in the top 8 in another 3 yeras. He will be 37. Struggling now to play 50 minutes. i can't believe the low expectations on here for this club. That is why we are where we are and do not look like ever getting out of the cellar any time soon.
He is currently 32. I think we should be making the 8 next year fwiw.
 
Refer to my last post.
It isn't an ego stroking contest where all players need to receive the public admiration from the coach.... He said API will be here.. woopty doo... Tallyn wants to leave if API is here . The choice is out of Benji's hands if he wants API to stay in any shape or form..

Tartak didn't mix his words. He said if API is here Tallyn wont be.. pretty aggressive thing to say to kick the captain out of the club as a 20 year old (via his manager)
 
Yes but we were/are suppose to build our future from local talent. You know five year plan blah blah. This looks like our best way out of this mess

And how can we afford to buy players, we have to pay overs, no one of note will come to the joint except for very good money.

TDS is a litmus test, if we lose him, it’s a very bad outcome.
The aim of all clubs that invest in juniors is to build future sides around them that goes without saying - we are no different and the challenge is always in keeping them.
The difference for us is the focus on it in the media because of the consistent failure of the FG side.
The profile of any of our juniors appears to be far more elevated than other clubs - sometimes to their advantage sometimes not - and losing them generates news. A lost junior in a lower club is far more concerning for its fans - and every one knows that any story from this club is news.
 
Has Benji expressed the same conviction at any point to retain TDS? Haven’t even heard him say he wants to retain TDS and then to have some kind of transition plan. To Benji, it’s just “Api Api Api”. And the moral of that story is that TDS is the bad guy for wanting to explore his options? Come on.
Benji's love for Api is for a reason.

That guy is a soldier, and he has single handedly won us games on many occasions. We're slowly building a team to support him, and I'm sure Benji thinks he deserves and should be a big part of that team.

If, and it's a big if, no one has had discussions with TDS about the plan around him and Api - only then it's a big mistake from Benji or the club.

To me, it seems mad that neither him or Richo would have been very clear with the long term plan for him. I have no doubt those conversations have taken place.

TDS just isn't happy with it - and that's fine. But don't blame it on Benji/the club.

Api is our starter for the rest of this season, and IMO the next depending on how he's traveling. No one will be starting TDS ahead of Api right now, and not many would be starting TDS ahead of Api next season - increased minutes for sure; and if he has a deal better than that, I can see why he might want to take it - though disappointed he doesn't want to be part of our future.
 
"chances are Tallyn will have to go", hardly an ultimatum.

Obviously there are other things playing out in the background as alluded to by another poster. If my memory serves me correctly, I think it was Wayne Bennett, used to to have the philosophy of it's better to let a player go a year early then keep them a year too long. Hope this doesn't end up being the case with Api.
 
"chances are Tallyn will have to go", hardly an ultimatum.

Obviously there are other things playing out in the background as alluded to by another poster. If my memory serves me correctly, I think it was Wayne Bennett, used to to have the philosophy of it's better to let a player go a year early then keep them a year too long. Hope this doesn't end up being the case with Api.
if Api stays
 
It isn't an ego stroking contest where all players need to receive the public admiration from the coach.... He said API will be here.. woopty doo... Tallyn wants to leave if API is here . The choice is out of Benji's hands if he wants API to stay in any shape or form..
It’s not about public admiration and ego stroking. You’re going out on a limb defending Benji when you don’t even know if Benji rates him. It’s been said that Richo wants him but Benji doesn’t. And given how quiet Benji has been about TDS, how could you argue that isn’t true. If a coach truly values a player, do you really think his response to a question regarding if the player will be at the club in another week would be “I don’t know”?
Tartak didn't mix his words. He said if API is here Tallyn wont be.. pretty aggressive thing to say to kick the captain out of the club as a 20 year old (via his manager)
It’s only aggressive if you perceive it that way. Iongi left the Panthers because he had Edwards in front of him. Was he wrong for doing that? Players leave clubs for better opportunities all the time. And if Benji isn’t a fan, what’s TDS supposed to do?
His management came out with its him or me spiel and attempted to distance themselves from Galvin. He is also under contract until end of 26 well knowing at the time he had one of the best hookers in the NRL in front of him. It is his management team who also mentioned Galvin, not me. Koroisau is not blocking his pathway to the NRL because at this time Da Silva is a good young player but cannot displace Koroisau.
What I said above pretty much covers this as well. My only question, before his management alerted the club, did Benji express ANY desire to keep him? All he has done is lather Api. That’s his prerogative, but it’s also the players prerogative to leave if he’s obviously not wanted. All of this defence of Benji and there isn’t even any evidence he wants him.
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Back
Top