Tallyn Da Silva #270

the loan deal allows him solid first grade minutes at another club for a year or two. Great for his development great for his potential to show he should start in 27. It makes a tonne of sense for both the club and the player. The real question is why would another club do this. Literally develop a player for another team like we did for Melbourne.
I guess there are too many unknowns but logically Tallan should back himself to take the starting 9 off Api come 2027.

That doesn't seem to be what is playing out here though. Tallan's management have said if Api re-signs Tallan will go, imlpying that Tallan a) doesn't think he can get the starting jersey off Api b) thinks he deserves it out of hand it 2027.

The loan deal doesn't make sense because Tallan's management indicated he will sign elsewhere if Api is resigned.
 
Last edited:
Seriously? Which players is TDS attracting?

You know, the near future. 2/3/4 years time when he’s hopefully starting to hit his straps.

When we are a fairdinkum football team, with a future.

Wasn’t it the idea of the Tigers and CEO to start the build from their catchment areas?
 
I don't really understand this though? Unless it is a loan deal for 3 years.

The whole reason TDS wants out is because he sees himself at a starting hooker come 2027 and Api is blocking his pathway. Unless the club have sold him the vision I think a loan deal does not make any sense.
Could be a 2 year loan . The issue is his contract is due for renewal end of 2026 , so how you get a team to buy into that is weird . So he resigns with the tigers say for 2027-2030, but spends at least 2026 and 2027 with whichever club .
I can see it working if a club has a young kid on the way up who they need to give a few years / they don’t value anything in the market , and need the 2 years to reset / buy some time .
Someone like the cowboys wouldn’t be a bad shout. They are up shit creek next year , and Townsville like Darwin and anywhere tropical is attractive on the long term to a particular type of person.
A lot of people only stay a few years .
 
the loan deal allows him solid first grade minutes at another club for a year or two. Great for his development great for his potential to show he should start in 27. It makes a tonne of sense for both the club and the player. The real question is why would another club do this. Literally develop a player for another team like we did for Melbourne.
Like I said if you don’t value Reed Mahoney , where are you getting a decent dummy half from . The Braileys ? I’d say at least one if not both of Mahoney and Brailey are going to the bears. . Most clubs are tying up thier best players into 2028 to screw up the expansion teams so it’s slim pickings this offseason and next .
Even Manly are looking Simpkin and Chan Kam Tong as thier dummy halves . Yuck !🤮
 
Could be a 2 year loan . The issue is his contract is due for renewal end of 2026 , so how you get a team to buy into that is weird . So he resigns with the tigers say for 2027-2030, but spends at least 2026 and 2027 with whichever club .
I can see it working if a club has a young kid on the way up who they need to give a few years / they don’t value anything in the market , and need the 2 years to reset / buy some time .
Someone like the cowboys wouldn’t be a bad shout. They are up shit creek next year , and Townsville like Darwin and anywhere tropical is attractive on the long term to a particular type of person.
A lot of people only stay a few years .
I'm still struggling to get my head around it though. Yes in theory it makes sense for Tallan and for us, but the information we have is that Tallan is looking elsewhere because we are going to re-sign Api (who's contract expires at the end of 2026). Him going to a club to develop for 18 months doesn't solve the problem of why he wants to leave in the first place - us re-signing Api to be our no.1 hooker.

If the information we have is incorrect and that Tallan simple wants to start now and would be happy to share with Api come 2027 then it makes sense. But I don't think that's what is happening?
 
Rumour of the week: Rising Wests Tigers star Tallyn Da Silva to follow his great mate Lachlan Galvin to the Bulldogs as a starting hooker from next season with Bailey Hayward the regular 14. Stand by for the denials.

I don't think the tigers are willing to release him before the end of 2026.. he might sign with the dogs but I think he'll be seeing out his contract here first
 
I'm still struggling to get my head around it though. Yes in theory it makes sense for Tallan and for us, but the information we have is that Tallan is looking elsewhere because we are going to re-sign Api (who's contract expires at the end of 2026). Him going to a club to develop for 18 months doesn't solve the problem of why he wants to leave in the first place - us re-signing Api to be our no.1 hooker.

If the information we have is incorrect and that Tallan simple wants to start now and would be happy to share with Api come 2027 then it makes sense. But I don't think that's what is happening?
I dunno . I guess it depends on the 2 narratives out there about his relationship with the club .
1. TDS hates the club because Galvin — it makes zero sense this loan stuff , and all the sense in the world that he ends up next week at the dogs .
2. He loves the club , but wants to get his nrl career going , so his manger and him are doing whatever they need to do to get the party started . But ultimately his 1st love is the tigers and this is where his long term future is.
I dunno what’s true tbh . I’m just pointing out that if you’re the cowboys or even manly or even the bears tbh , you don’t have a dummy half right now that you think can play 1st grade to a reasonable standard . So if you simply need a player right now to fill the 9 for your club right now as in 2025-2026 , which means you’ve now bought yourself 18 months to sort this out , is that not a good enough reason to want a prodigious kid to wear the 9 for you ?
I mean it’s how a lot of European football clubs see it in soccer/football. Get the talent in now to win footy matches , whilst you sort out your future long term in the background .
 
Signing des would be a disaster and push back our rebuild another 5 years.

He is well passed his used by date.
His win % is almost double that of Benjis.

I dont think he would institute a total rebuild but make tweaks. Hopefully leave Foran up there!
 
Rumour of the week: Rising Wests Tigers star Tallyn Da Silva to follow his great mate Lachlan Galvin to the Bulldogs as a starting hooker from next season with Bailey Hayward the regular 14. Stand by for the denials.

The only thing I will say with this is his manager Tartak has a really strong relationship with the club . This would do serious damage to his relationship with the club moving forward .
I mean he’s from out your way , do you have any whispers out there ? I always thought him and his dad bled black white and orange ? Seems strange to me .
 
WHen interpreting data , sample size is pretty important mate.
I’m sticking to facts.

At his current rate of progress, Benji won’t hit 54% for another 4 or 5 years.

Des was doing a lot better than Benji is at the same stage of his career.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: BZN
His win % is almost double that of Benjis.

I dont think he would institute a total rebuild but make tweaks. Hopefully leave Foran up there!
Think a lot of us here don't want the dinosaur coaching styles of Des, Madge and approaching that status Flanno anywhere near our club again, leave those fossils in the sandstone layers in peace where they belong.
 
Think a lot of us here don't want the dinosaur coaching styles of Des, Madge and approaching that status Flanno anywhere near our club again, leave those fossils in the sandstone layers in peace where they belong.
Each to their own, that’s fine by me.

Benji is the worst coach in the NRL.

We shouldn’t be afraid of recognising and thinking about that.

Some people might argue that anyone is better than the undisputed worst

Some think he is getting closer to turning things around.

I just wonder at what point we form the view that the club would be better served with someone else in the role?

Or whether he needs more help and assistance. Even if it’s on the quiet so as not to humiliate him.
 
Last edited:
I’m sticking to facts.

At his current rate of progress, Benji won’t hit 54% for another 4 or 5 years.
Nah you're spitting out numbers to shape the narrative that Benji is shit.. context is important.

Des started coaching NRL in 2004 at manly.. They lost 6 of their first 7 games and came 3rd last. This is with players like Michael monaghan, Menzies, hoppa, watmough, Brett stewart and Glenn stewart.

In 2005 he had 3 more wins and came 8th. But they had signed ben Kennedy and matai among others.

In 2006 he had 2 more wins and moved up to 5th . They had signed Matt Orford this year.

Benji walked into a team who had the spoon and a dogsh1t roster.

Chalk and cheese
 
Nah you're spitting out numbers to shape the narrative that Benji is shit.. context is important.

Des started coaching NRL in 2004 at manly.. They lost 6 of their first 7 games and came 3rd last. This is with players like Michael monaghan, Menzies, hoppa, watmough, Brett stewart and Glenn stewart.

In 2005 he had 3 more wins and came 8th. But they had signed ben Kennedy and matai among others.

In 2006 he had 2 more wins and moved up to 5th . They had signed Matt Orford this year.

Benji walked into a team who had the spoon and a dogsh1t roster.

Chalk and cheese
You have to laugh at the narrative that Benji had to deal with a squad with a dogshit roster.
It is not true.
The club underachieved in 2023. Backing that up with another spoon in 2024 was a fking disgrace. If they get another one this year, he should be marched out of concorde naked as we all line the streets and throw buckets of poo on him.
That wont happen though due to the embarrassing level of sychophancy that he benefits from due to his abilities as a player.
 
Rumour of the week: Rising Wests Tigers star Tallyn Da Silva to follow his great mate Lachlan Galvin to the Bulldogs as a starting hooker from next season with Bailey Hayward the regular 14. Stand by for the denials.

That would be a bitter pill to swallow.
Makes you wonder if it wasn't a sweetner to get Galvin initially. It all seems to have progressed with the Bulldogs moving on Sexton and Mahoney and now Da Silva not content to be transitioned into what everyone assumed was a natural progression.
 
Nah you're spitting out numbers to shape the narrative that Benji is shit.. context is important.

Des started coaching NRL in 2004 at manly.. They lost 6 of their first 7 games and came 3rd last. This is with players like Michael monaghan, Menzies, hoppa, watmough, Brett stewart and Glenn stewart.

In 2005 he had 3 more wins and came 8th. But they had signed ben Kennedy and matai among others.

In 2006 he had 2 more wins and moved up to 5th . They had signed Matt Orford this year.

Benji walked into a team who had the spoon and a dogsh1t roster.

Chalk and cheese
not only a spoon but a club on its knees really , 3 spoons 2 clowns in Lee & Pascoe , shitty board . thing is people want to bag benji and some is fair but no one else put their hand up to coach this club . he’s breathing life back into it
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Back
Top