Taylor asked Farah to give up test jumper..

@gallagher said:
@oldmate said:
That's different, because in cricket, you aren't as liable to suffer a season ending injury every time you play.

If Farah gets injured in the 4 Nations, that's the WT season down the dunny. There's no one to replace his role at rake, or his leadership.

So none of our players should ever represent? Thats AFL.

Didn't say that. I said given the choice in his circumstance, where he's clearly not 100% fit, club should come before test. Don't twist what I said, I clearly outlined that if he's got an issue/injury, his club priorities should come first.
 
@softlaw said:
This article was only released because the whole thing had been sorted out between the two of them. It's been done to show that they are getting on well together.

& I don;t suppose there's a chance of someone changing the name of this thread to **spell our Captain's name correctly?**

Done and dusted…by a nose....

Representing your country is an honour ...I'm sure if the injury was more serious he would have backed out...nothing to see here...
 
@oldmate said:
@gallagher said:
@oldmate said:
That's different, because in cricket, you aren't as liable to suffer a season ending injury every time you play.

If Farah gets injured in the 4 Nations, that's the WT season down the dunny. There's no one to replace his role at rake, or his leadership.

So none of our players should ever represent? Thats AFL.

Didn't say that. I said given the choice in his circumstance, where he's clearly not 100% fit, club should come before test. Don't twist what I said, I clearly outlined that if he's got an issue/injury, his club priorities should come first.

I didnt twist anything.You didnt clearly outline that at all. And its a nose job.
 
@oldmate said:
That's different, because in cricket, you aren't as liable to suffer a season ending injury every time you play.

If Farah gets injured in the 4 Nations, that's the WT season down the dunny. There's no one to replace his role at rake, or his leadership.

Same as Warner for his lpl team. There's a hierarchy and that's country-state-club. Others may put state before club or club before country or vice versa and it's up to the individual player. Robbie deserves to play for his country and he will.

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.1.5_
 
[

@gallagher said:
@oldmate said:
@gallagher said:
@oldmate said:
That's different, because in cricket, you aren't as liable to suffer a season ending injury every time you play.

If Farah gets injured in the 4 Nations, that's the WT season down the dunny. There's no one to replace his role at rake, or his leadership.

So none of our players should ever represent? Thats AFL.

Didn't say that. I said given the choice in his circumstance, where he's clearly not 100% fit, club should come before test. Don't twist what I said, I clearly outlined that if he's got an issue/injury, his club priorities should come first.

I didnt twist anything.You didnt clearly outline that at all. And its a nose job.

I think this line from my original post makes it pretty damn clear sunshine.

@oldmate said:
_Playing off-season tests should be a bonus *if he's fit and able*_, and should not compromise his pre-season training with Wests.
 
@oldmate said:
I think this line from my original post makes it pretty damn clear sunshine.

@oldmate said:
_Playing off-season tests should be a bonus *if he's fit and able*_, and should not compromise his pre-season training with Wests.

oh, your original post. Well next time I reply to one of your posts I'll pour over all your other posts to make make sure I have a clear picture of what you mean. :unamused:
 
@gallagher said:
@oldmate said:
I think this line from my original post makes it pretty damn clear sunshine.

@oldmate said:
_Playing off-season tests should be a bonus *if he's fit and able*_, and should not compromise his pre-season training with Wests.

oh, your original post. Well next time I reply to one of your posts I'll pour over all your other posts to make make sure I have a clear picture of what you mean. :unamused:

It isn't my fault you aren't following the thread tiger. Don't go saying I didn't outline my message clearly when I have champ.

This is clutching at straws anyway, so just leave it would you?

@snapper said:
In my eyes it's a personal decision there is no right or wrong.

Well said. We can speculate what could/should/would happen, but it's his call.
 
@oldmate said:
It isn't my fault you aren't following the thread tiger. Don't go saying I didn't outline my message clearly when I have champ.

This is clutching at straws anyway, so just leave it would you?

LOL, your gonna love it here.. And so far you've called me Champ,Tiger and Sunshine, can you give one nickname and stick to it? I'm easily confused.
 
@Snapper said:
In my eyes it's a personal decision there is no right or wrong.

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.1.5_

Absolutely.As a Wests Tigers fan you are selfishly hoping he pulls out so he is rested but Robbie Farah has every right to Play for his country as he said it will be one of the last times he does it due to his age.
 
@oldmate said:
@gallagher said:
@oldmate said:
I think this line from my original post makes it pretty damn clear sunshine.

@oldmate said:
_Playing off-season tests should be a bonus *if he's fit and able*_, and should not compromise his pre-season training with Wests.

oh, your original post. Well next time I reply to one of your posts I'll pour over all your other posts to make make sure I have a clear picture of what you mean. :unamused:

It isn't my fault you aren't following the thread tiger. Don't go saying I didn't outline my message clearly when I have champ.

This is clutching at straws anyway, so just leave it would you?

@snapper said:
In my eyes it's a personal decision there is no right or wrong.

Well said. We can speculate what could/should/would happen, but it's his call.

A wise old man once told me if you speculate you masturbate. :laughing: :laughing:
 
gallagher and oldmate - both of you cut it out now or you can both have a 2 week holiday from here.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top