The Halftime Spray - Tallis is a lair

madunit

New member
This is an opinion article I write for League Unlimited. This week I decide to weigh into the battle and did what no one else in the media seems interested in doing, support Farah and attack Tallis (I know I'm just a tiny voice with an audience of about 3, including myself). But here it is if you want a read: (It was a rush job, so it's very poorly written and I apologise for that)

Call me old-fashioned, but if someone told me something in confidence and in private, that's where I'd leave it.

People calling Gorden Tallis ‘honest' for claiming Robbie Farah said Wests Tigers coach Mick Potter can't coach, some 15 months ago, are deluded beyond belief. It's not honest to breach a person's trust or reveal something they said in private.

On Monday night, Tallis revealed that he felt compelled to stick up for his mate Potter when news reports began surfacing some weeks ago that Potter's position could be terminated early.

Rumours about Potter's future were coupled with allegations that there was a player revolt against him. This revolution has been reported as being just one man to as many as ‘the senior playing group' (also known as a wild guess).

‘Honest' Tallis criticised Farah for being quiet while rumours of player unrest towards Potter were fuelling speculation Potter would be sacked. However the week before Tallis made this claim, Farah was reported as saying in the Sydney Morning Herald "There is no player discontent."

Potter backed this up by saying "I have not had one issue about the players."

He also spoke of the uncertainty about his career at the Tigers as being "a little distracting."

Hardly the words of a man who needs any PR assistance.

Tallis decided to reveal his big story anyway, despite it being over a year old and quite very possibly entirely irrelevant.

Did ‘honest' Tallis bother to confirm if Farah's alleged beliefs were still true? No.

After the drama on Sunday at the Tiger's post-match press conference, Farah clearly stated that "Mick has the support of the playing group and will continue to have the support of the playing group, that has never been an issue." Shortly after, the Tigers board agreed to not sack Potter, but to let him see the season out.

Given that Tallis suggested his interest was in defending Potter, one has to wonder how ‘honest' that statement is, given that 24 hours after Potter was saved from the sack, Tallis continued pushing his agenda.

Surely if Tallis was trying to look after Potter, then shutting his gob would help to take the pressure off Potter. His courageous crusade to try and help a bloke (who never asked for his assistance) should have ended when it was announced that Potter would get to see out his contract.

Instead Tallis ironically decided to carry the story on. The ‘honest' Tallis said to Farah after a recent game "Robbie you can have your say, it doesn't worry me."

Yet Tallis is the only one of the two constantly bringing this story up and dragging it out. Clearly it worries Tallis.

‘Honest.'

http://leagueunlimited.com/news/the-halftime-spray-round-20/
 
Good read MU…I agree I feel players will now be very wary of saying much to 'Honest' Gordy in the future..
 
Is this the same honest Tallis that decided to sit out the season rather than play a final year with St George.
 
You haven't been alone in your views Madunit. I have been asking why more anger has not been directed at Gordy Tallis especially on a Wests Tigers supporters forum. His comments completely derailed us last week and yet so many were sucked in by the honest Gordy crap.
 
If there is one person that really to be sacked as a result of this sorry saga it is Tallis. How desperate is he to stick the knife into a captain?
 
However your piece seems to allude that you agree Robbie DID in fact say something to tallis, we all know what - Potter cant coach.
Then Robbie denied saying that, said "Its totally false"….which would make Robbie a liar too wouldnt it?
 
Tallis has always had this obsession with being part of the story. He's taken a personal conversation made at some time ago in different circumstances and misrepresented it. And after painting himself into a corner he's sold out Farah to save himself. He then represents himself as some bastion of honesty which apparently is more important than keeping a confidence or Farah's privacy.

He's always been an over-hyped self important douche. This is just more evidence
 
@Yossarian said:
Tallis has always had this obsession with being part of the story. He's taken a personal conversation made at some time ago in different circumstances and misrepresented it. And after painting himself into a corner he's sold out Farah to save himself. He then represents himself as some bastion of honesty which apparently is more important than keeping a confidence or Farah's privacy.

He's always been an over-hyped self important douche. This is just more evidence

I can't believe Tallis has got off so lightly regarding this matter. Is it not true that Robbie said something like "he is struggling" at the time? If so, this was certainly TRUE! The WHOLE CLUB was struggling!
Tallis speaking up and saying Robbie claimed he was struggling at the time would have been of no interest to anyone. Did he over-hype it to get attention?
 
You lot are loonies - take off your black, orange and white blinkers and youd realise that Tallis did what we would like of all commentators and was honest. He only said it when pushed into a corner by Ayoub and he didn't misrepresent anything.
 
@Boonboon2 said:
You lot are loonies - take off your black, orange and white blinkers and youd realise that Tallis did what we would like of all commentators and was honest. He only said it when pushed into a corner by Ayoub and he didn't misrepresent anything.

How do you know that for sure, Boonboon? Were you there? Do you know what Robbie said in it's entirety? Or are you just taking Gordie's word for it? If Robbie said Potter couldn't coach, whilst also saying that he was struggling, the team was struggling, he personally was struggling, and that it was all said 15 months ago, then maybe it really isn't such a big deal - particularly if Potter and Farah have always been upfront with each other as suggested by Mayer.
Much of a conversation is perspective. You say something and from my perspective it means this and from your perspective it means something else. The words are the same, but the meaning is different.
This may well have been the case in Robbie's confidential conversation with Tallis. At the end of the day, Robbie probably shouldn't have said what he did, but sure as hell, Tallis shouldn't have said what he did.
And there's always choice. Tallis chose to reveal a private conversation. That alone is reason enough for him to be copping his fare share of the flak.
As far as him 'not misrepresenting anything', again I ask … how do you know? Especially as you have no conception of either Tallis' or Farah's **perspective** on the conversation.
 
All Farah has to say is that - Yes, 15 months he had doubts about Potter's coaching ability but since then has changed his mind. Then all the BS would be over.
 
@Boonboon2 said:
You lot are loonies - take off your black, orange and white blinkers and youd realise that Tallis did what we would like of all commentators and was honest. He only said it when pushed into a corner by Ayoub and he didn't misrepresent anything.

How much white is in the blinkers?

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
know someone else has bought this up,but was this said by Farah after the game he was subbed by potter for Luani, with about 20 mins to go? I think it was against the roosters during origin. Would explain a lot!

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
@tig_prmz said:
Good point. That game was vs manly before origin though.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_

sorry tig I knew it was against a quality side, and we were still in it. Farah was not happy walking off that field!

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Unfortunately madunit's spray is totally misdirected as it concentrates on Tallis being honest.
Unless he told Farah he would not repeat what he said to him in a private conversation it has zero to do with honesty or dishonesty.
What it's all about is ethics - to quote from Wikipedia 'moral principles that govern a person's behaviour or the conducting of an activity'.
Not sure if he is an honest or dishonest person but it seems Tallis' moral principles are not set at too high a standard in some instances.
 
Someone has probably raised this already, but the whole 15 months ago thing puts it about the same time Pots benched Robbie in that Manly game…

Things have certainly changed since then.
 
@innsaneink said:
However your piece seems to allude that you agree Robbie DID in fact say something to tallis, we all know what - Potter cant coach.
Then Robbie denied saying that, said "Its totally false"….which would make Robbie a liar too wouldnt it?

or maybe even a lair lol.

I tried to deal with what was known, It seems no one is denying that Farah said something considered critical about Potter to Tallis 15 months ago. No one truly knows as we've heard two versions (one from each side of the argument), so I intentionally avoided getting too involved in that aspect of the story.
 
Back
Top