Tigers board to undertake post-season review

[Demps]

Paul Kent got it right last night, “ changing the coach is not the answer”… “there is a core group of players that need to go….” As they are bringing the club down with their attitude….In my view they are:

Brooks
Mbye (gone)
BJ ( gone)
Packer ( gone)
Nofo

Get rid of the above would be the first thing that should happen

Unfortunately Kent is spot on but just can't bring himself to name names

Don't need to name names.
It's extremely obvious.

Egg shells.
Clubs been too concerned with not upsetting players instead of making the hard calls.

Just saying if we wants to champion Madge he needs to name the names that are bringing him down other wise shut up about how good Madge us

Show gives me a headache eh.
Too much yelling over each other.

Barely watched since Ikin left.

 

[The_Patriot]

Paul Kent got it right last night, “ changing the coach is not the answer”… “there is a core group of players that need to go….” As they are bringing the club down with their attitude….In my view they are:

Brooks
Mbye (gone)
BJ ( gone)
Packer ( gone)
Nofo

Get rid of the above would be the first thing that should happen

Unfortunately Kent is spot on but just can't bring himself to name names

Don't need to name names.
It's extremely obvious.

Egg shells.
Clubs been too concerned with not upsetting players instead of making the hard calls.

Just saying if we wants to champion Madge he needs to name the names that are bringing him down other wise shut up about how good Madge us

Show gives me a headache eh.
Too much yelling over each other.

Barely watched since Ikin left.

Ikin would put him on the spot to name names lol

 

[Telltails]

So I wonder where Douehi Laurie ,Blore, Stef Simpkin, sit with this - they are the players who are young enough to still mould into winners if they want it.

 

[Demps]

So I wonder where Douehi Laurie ,Blore, Stef Simpkin, sit with this - they are the players who are young enough to still mould into winners if they want it.

They're the key.

We should be building a team around their strengths.

But instead we spent the last 10 years trying to build a halves pairing around Brooks wants. Not team focused.

We got it wrong.
Time to move on from the mistakes.

 

[hank37w]

***Roach hinted*** that the problems are just not the coach,and i would like to know if it's the whole management. Seriously, we have gone backwards since our premiership shock win. Losing key players Teddy, Moses, and Woods was massive, but we show no sign of an upward trend.
Does Managment overule Hartigan and or the coach owing to being gun shy after previous bad signings?
Why does a club with close to 2 mil dollars,miss out on TPJ, Burton, Critchton and at least 5 other players, to sides who finished behind us last year? Who signed the crap second raters and reject Souths players? The whole club needs a cleanout, but who sacks the commitee ?

You lost me at "Roach hinted". If you are basing an argument or question on what Steve Roach "thinks", it has limited merit.

Knows footy 100 times more than the pretenders making decisions at WT. Lee says we have a good roster ??‍♂️

Lee is a lawyer, that’s says it all.

Could be worse, he could be an engineer.

 

[Demps]

So I wonder where Douehi Laurie ,Blore, Stef Simpkin, sit with this - they are the players who are young enough to still mould into winners if they want it.

They're the key.

We should be building a team around their strengths.

But instead we spent the last 10 years trying to build a halves pairing around Brooks wants. Not team focused.

We got it wrong.
Time to move on from the mistakes.

AD said openly he's a 6 and he sees his future at 6 so the coach moves him to the centre to appease Brooks.

This has been an ongoing thing throughout Brooks career.
Re arrange to suit him so he can play his best game.

Which we've yet to ever actually see.
The guy just isn't it.

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

***Roach hinted*** that the problems are just not the coach,and i would like to know if it's the whole management. Seriously, we have gone backwards since our premiership shock win. Losing key players Teddy, Moses, and Woods was massive, but we show no sign of an upward trend.
Does Managment overule Hartigan and or the coach owing to being gun shy after previous bad signings?
Why does a club with close to 2 mil dollars,miss out on TPJ, Burton, Critchton and at least 5 other players, to sides who finished behind us last year? Who signed the crap second raters and reject Souths players? The whole club needs a cleanout, but who sacks the commitee ?

You lost me at "Roach hinted". If you are basing an argument or question on what Steve Roach "thinks", it has limited merit.

Knows footy 100 times more than the pretenders making decisions at WT. Lee says we have a good roster ??‍♂️

Lee is a lawyer, that’s says it all.

Could be worse, he could be an engineer.

Or lollipop man

 

[Geo]

Here I thought NRL Finals were about to start..

 

[hank37w]

This is much more interesting.

 

[gallagher]

Here I thought NRL Finals were about to start..

What's the relevance to a tigers forum?

 

[Geo]

Here I thought NRL Finals were about to start..

What's the relevance to a tigers forum?

None… but what relevance do the Tigers have to the NRL media

 

[BAGNF05]

Its painfully obvious there is no long term plan, never has been.

Knee jerk reactions everywhere

WT “we won’t pay overs for rubbish anymore”

Also WT “oh look Joe Offahengaue”

 

[tony soprano]

Is it possible to sack board members who has the power?

 

[tony soprano]

Its painfully obvious there is no long term plan, never has been.

Knee jerk reactions everywhere

WT “we won’t pay overs for rubbish anymore”

Also WT “oh look Joe Offahengaue”

Talk about rubbish. Brandy didn't miss with his comments about Joe last game.

 

[tony soprano]

Here I thought NRL Finals were about to start..

What's the relevance to a tigers forum?

Finals are overrated

 

[BAGNF05]

Its painfully obvious there is no long term plan, never has been.

Knee jerk reactions everywhere

WT “we won’t pay overs for rubbish anymore”

Also WT “oh look Joe Offahengaue”

Talk about rubbish. Brandy didn't miss with his comments about Joe last game.

Plays like a Wests Tiger.

 

[TrueTiger]

Paul Kent got it right last night, “ changing the coach is not the answer”… “there is a core group of players that need to go….” As they are bringing the club down with their attitude….In my view they are:

Brooks
Mbye (gone)
BJ ( gone)
Packer ( gone)
Nofo

Get rid of the above would be the first thing that should happen

Unfortunately Kent is spot on but just can't bring himself to name names

Don't need to name names.
It's extremely obvious.

Egg shells.
Clubs been too concerned with not upsetting players instead of making the hard calls.

Just saying if we wants to champion Madge he needs to name the names that are bringing him down other wise shut up about how good Madge is

No need to name names ...its always been known as the boys club,the ones who have been here the longest and think they run the club...if you cant see that then you need to critique everyone not just Madge...for eg..Noffa extended for 4 years,Brooks given 170 NRL games because he is a timid junior,but obviously cant see eye to eye with Madge alledgedlly,..the place needs a cleanout and I do like Madge and if the review gives him the arse sobeit...but there are more that need the arse as well...

 

[Needaname]

Wrong. Mbye was Madge, Packer and Reynolds was Cleary and you might have noticed he Reynolds didnt play this year you half wit. Sorry quarter wit.


M'Bye was Clearys signing,Madge only inherited the overpaid anchor


Really then why did he give him the captaincy last year. Just shows How disconnected Madge is to select Moses to lead us from the front..end of story

In defence of that decision, when Madge walked out in the Storm game, Mbye was the main one to try and rally the side, was very cringy but he tried.

I’m pretty sure on the doco it exposed him expressing some unfavourable thoughts once Madge left the room and pulled the remaining staff from the room.
Mostly expletives but along the lines of;
“Those . out there don’t want to back us, let’s do this for us boys, who gives a . what those . out there think, they don’t want to support us let’s do it ourselves.”

 

[tony soprano]

Paul Kent got it right last night, “ changing the coach is not the answer”… “there is a core group of players that need to go….” As they are bringing the club down with their attitude….In my view they are:

Brooks
Mbye (gone)
BJ ( gone)
Packer ( gone)
Nofo

Get rid of the above would be the first thing that should happen

Unfortunately Kent is spot on but just can't bring himself to name names

Don't need to name names.
It's extremely obvious.

Egg shells.
Clubs been too concerned with not upsetting players instead of making the hard calls.

Just saying if we wants to champion Madge he needs to name the names that are bringing him down other wise shut up about how good Madge is

No need to name names ...its always been known as the boys club,the ones who have been here the longest and think they run the club...if you cant see that then you need to critique everyone not just Madge...for eg..Noffa extended for 4 years,Brooks given 170 NRL games because he is a timid junior,but obviously cant see eye to eye with Madge alledgedlly,..the place needs a cleanout and I do like Madge and if the review gives him the arse sobeit...but there are more that need the arse as well...

It's not necessarily they're all tanking. Your more senior guys Brooks, Chee, could be considered but he has a young team out there and they just don't have the skill I yet to match it in nrl.

He'll need a more fundamentals Bennett sheens style coaching offseason with them and a lot need a lot more size and fitness. But if they have a huge off season and can snag some experience and x factors could come good.

 

[Pascoes_barber]

Is it possible to sack board members who has the power?

The board members themselves.

What could possibly go wrong.