Tigers board to undertake post-season review

[pawsandclaws1]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

Yes.

 

[cochise]

***Roach hinted*** that the problems are just not the coach,and i would like to know if it's the whole management. Seriously, we have gone backwards since our premiership shock win. Losing key players Teddy, Moses, and Woods was massive, but we show no sign of an upward trend.
Does Managment overule Hartigan and or the coach owing to being gun shy after previous bad signings?
Why does a club with close to 2 mil dollars,miss out on TPJ, Burton, Critchton and at least 5 other players, to sides who finished behind us last year? Who signed the crap second raters and reject Souths players? The whole club needs a cleanout, but who sacks the commitee ?

You lost me at "Roach hinted". If you are basing an argument or question on what Steve Roach "thinks", it has limited merit.

Knows footy 100 times more than the pretenders making decisions at WT. Lee says we have a good roster ??‍♂️

Lee is a lawyer, that’s says it all.

I have no gripes with lawyers but him holding up Tommy’s #7 was it for me.

It means he knows little about what makes a good Rugby League roster. Spent all his time going up the Lawyer ranks, which doesn’t leave much time for understanding Rugby League. He’s a fan who gives us money, that’s all.

That is a generalisation. I don't think he knows much about the game but that has very little to do with him being a lawyer.

To get where he is in the lawyers ranks means he wouldn’t have much time for anything else, let alone understanding Rugby League, other than from a fan perspective.

You just don't know that mate.

Experience tells me so.

Are you saying that is why you know so little about the game? 😛

Hahahahaha. That’s just me being a nuffie, but no my experience working with lawyers tells me Lee wouldn’t have the time to know anything else to get where he is.

Yeah we should be like the big boys at the top end of the NRL and appoint Chairmen with massive Rugba League experience:

Storm - Matt Tripp - Betting Company
Panthers - Dave O'Neill - Licensed Clubs
Souffs - Nick Pappas - Lawyer
Manly - Scott Penn - Health products
Roosters - Nick Politis - Car Salesman
Parra - Sean McElduff - Nanker (not rhyming slang)
Knights - Brian McGuigan - Winemaker
Titans - Dennis Watt - New Ltd Executive

But yeah, our Chairman should have more Rugba League in him despite the fact he has been one of the largest sponsors of Rugba League for over 10 years.

Seriously a lot of people here have a weird idea of what Lee's role is.

Tell me about it but people keep questioning his Rugba League creds. Go figure. He’s the head of a very successful law firm and has been on a few committees and so forth but people want him to have Rugba League nous, I don’t.

@Tiger_Steve is my nomination!

That's how it is..

I'm sure @Tiger_Steve will give you a job @geo

 

[cochise]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

I think he played his best playing halfback for Scone High School in 1997. Though many good judges would say the 5/8th in that side carried him.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

I think he played his best playing halfback for Scone High School in 1997. Though many good judges would say the 5/8th in that side carried him.

Was that Cochise?

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

I think he played his best playing halfback for Scone High School in 1997. Though many good judges would say the 5/8th in that side carried him.

Was that Cochise?

 

[cochise]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

I think he played his best playing halfback for Scone High School in 1997. Though many good judges would say the 5/8th in that side carried him.

Was that Cochise?

Yes it was lol

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

I think he played his best playing halfback for Scone High School in 1997. Though many good judges would say the 5/8th in that side carried him.

Was that Cochise?

Yes it was lol

Well done. I have my fingers crossed he will be selected as our new coach.

 

[cochise]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

I think he played his best playing halfback for Scone High School in 1997. Though many good judges would say the 5/8th in that side carried him.

Was that Cochise?

Yes it was lol

Well done. I have my fingers crossed he will be selected as our new coach.

I wouldn't say no to a sheens-morris transition.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

Morris is bog average so can confirm he has the WT DNA.

 

[supercoach]

This makes me sick done with this pathetic club

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/lee-hagipantelis-on-why-the-tigers-arent-conducting/id1536354910?i=1000534629285

hahahahahahahahahaha.......hahahaha ..my sides...stop it..

Lee must think we are all stupid. What a load of rubbish, a independent review was the only way to go. Can’t see Pascoe giving himself a poor report

It is a review of the football department. Pascoe is not part of the football department

He is CEO….he is part of every department

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

Morris is bog average so can confirm he has the WT DNA.

The sun has gone down over the yard arm and it's time for a glass of port. I looked in the cupboard and there is a very nice Morris of Rutherglen Tawny Port. I hope it is a good omen.

 

[gallagher]

This makes me sick done with this pathetic club

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/lee-hagipantelis-on-why-the-tigers-arent-conducting/id1536354910?i=1000534629285

hahahahahahahahahaha.......hahahaha ..my sides...stop it..

Lee must think we are all stupid. What a load of rubbish, a independent review was the only way to go. Can’t see Pascoe giving himself a poor report

It is a review of the football department. Pascoe is not part of the football department

He is CEO….he is part of every department

In charge of every dept.

 

[cktiger]

I think we should give the players an option.
Stick with Madge or they will appoint Robbie Farah as coach... and they can deal with him when they don't put in any effort.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

Morris is bog average so can confirm he has the WT DNA.

The sun has gone down over the yard arm and it's time for a glass of port. I looked in the cupboard and there is a very nice Morris of Rutherglen Tawny Port. I hope it is a good omen.

Good suggestion. Might pick some tawny this week.

 

[balmain boy]

How on earth can anyone want Sheens as Coach? He was hired with a job to do and we still need him to do that job off the field.

Sheens had a pretty awful record overall while here. And went nuts, hasn't coached in a while and when he has he's largely failed.

He's there to help guide the organisation into the future, not coach it.

 

[since 57]

Here here..well said

 

[old_man_tiger]

How on earth can anyone want Sheens as Coach? He was hired with a job to do and we still need him to do that job off the field.

Sheens had a pretty awful record overall while here. And went nuts, hasn't coached in a while and when he has he's largely failed.

He's there to help guide the organisation into the future, not coach it.

If the forum was a real place and Sheens had showed up in 2012 he would have been hung.

Happy for him to mentor a young coach, still not impressed by any options, including the incumbent.

 

[Tiger5150]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

Morris is bog average so can confirm he has the WT DNA.

The sun has gone down over the yard arm and it's time for a glass of port. I looked in the cupboard and there is a very nice Morris of Rutherglen Tawny Port. I hope it is a good omen.

Wow....this got downvoted. Some tough judges of a Port on here

 

[weststigerman]

I hear it’s 50/50. Maguire has his supporters and detractors on the board. The detractors are looking at a Sheens-led recovery with either Wolff or our old mate Johnny Cronk working the witch’s hats.

It would be great to have bomber back at WTs with Sheens providing guidance as necessary. IMO he did well at the Sharks under difficult circumstances and has WT DNA.

He was born in Scone P&C?

His career below:

Years Team Pld T G FG P
2001–02 Newcastle Knights 31 11 0 0 44
2003–06 Parramatta Eels 92 18 10 3 95
2007–09 Wests Tigers 72 11 0 1 45
2010–14 Cronulla Sharks 105 9 0 1 37
Total 300 49 10 5 221
Representative
Years Team Pld T G FG P
2002–03 NSW Country 2 0 0 0 0

I think he played his best playing halfback for Scone High School in 1997. Though many good judges would say the 5/8th in that side carried him.

Was that Cochise?

Yes it was lol

And to think some said Johnny was not a natural halfback. Where were they in 1997?

 

[jirskyr]

This makes me sick done with this pathetic club

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/lee-hagipantelis-on-why-the-tigers-arent-conducting/id1536354910?i=1000534629285

Before you get yourself more in a twist, the true points are that:

(a) An independent review will take a long time to award, conduct and present - too long to result in an effective head coach decision for 2022

(b) Clubs do internal reviews all the time and there's no reason why this one has to be any different - any other clubs having external independent appointments to review season 2021?

(c) The club isn't mandated to do an independent review by any stakeholder or charter, it's their own decision

(d) Even if there is an independent review, the review goes confidentially back to 100% non-independent assessors (the board). If they are being accused of sweeping things under the carpet with an internal-only review, they wouldn't do any different with the findings of an independent review.

(e) If Tim Sheens is involved, you can argue he is independent as a brand new employee with no recent history at the club. Same as Phil Gould did review work for Panthers, Warriors and now Bulldogs, whilst under their employment.

That's nice my point is the board Pascoe or hartigan aren't being reviewed so what will change

Who said Pascoe and Hartigan aren't being reviewed? Lee only said it would be internal staff doing the review. The Board may be reviewing Pascoe themselves, in fact I would bet they already do that ever year.