Todd Carney

[jadtiger]

I dont see a need for him at the Tigers, but I'm not opposed to seeing him back in the NRL.

He is a good player and did nothing wrong when the Sharks punted him.

Agree 100%, it was a joke he got punted just for being an idiot ( and, no, he didn't piss in his mouth)- there are a lot worse than him still running around.
The Tigers don't need him but it seems the NRL have put the kibosh on him coming back to any team.

He had a very long history of bringing the game into disrepute by his idiotic, drunken antics which included numerous criminal offences. I think they were well within their rights to punt him from the game.

Completely agree Nelson the raiders protected him for years but he ended up being barred from Goulburn for drunken stupidity.He can play but is probably the 2nd last player i would want at the tigers(Packer wins that dubious honour)

 

[newtiger]

Remember the damage that John Hopoate caused to our brand with his finger, we don't need to go with another grub that will tarnish our brand.
He can go to the Roosters with the rest of the grubs.

 

[Telltails]

Have no problem with Carney if he has curbed the drinking.
He acted up as a young kid and was punished for doing so.
If he is older and wiser now - like others in and associated with game - don't see why clubs wouldn't make a play for him.
If Moses goes and he was available I certainly think he would be worth approaching.

 

[TCL]

Remember the damage that John Hopoate caused to our brand with his finger, we don't need to go with another grub that will tarnish our brand.
He can go to the Roosters with the rest of the grubs.

I thought that was Lamb that encouraged him to do that?

Never understood the signing of lamb as a coach, not just cause of the infamous head high tackle.

 

[Spartan117]

Carney Career = Flush

No thanks

Some people need to just go away

 

[Guest]

Todd Carney = Stupid idea. End of story.

 

[Geo]

Caralan's let him go with no off-field indiscretion….that says a lot...

Long time out of the NRL...Money better spent elsewhere..

 

[WestsBenTigers]

Have no problem with Carney if he has curbed the drinking.
He acted up as a young kid and was punished for doing so.
If he is older and wiser now - like others in and associated with game - don't see why clubs wouldn't make a play for him.
If Moses goes and he was available I certainly think he would be worth approaching.

Would'y be getting rid of Moses anytime soon

 

[Harvey]

Todd has been a goose over the years, but we have drug dealers, wife beaters and blokes who have kicked another bloke in the head when he is laid out. No sure why he gets banned, but other get to sit out a year or so for much worse and then are welcomed back.