Worth noting that of all the players WT used across both games, only 5 aren't eligible for NYC this season! 2 very, very young squads.
**In NYC:**
This was about our 4th string side and it showed. Forwards were completely dominated and there looked to be no communication or cohesion in defence. The standout was definitely Mapesone, a big boy from Keebra. Ran very hard and one of the few forwards to bend the line.
They were basically outgunned by a more experienced and cohesive team. Parra looked like they had players who've played together a fair bit, and were often bigger than us physically too. They would make it down to our tryline off almost every set they had, whereas we could barely make 30-40m then kick.
Fullback was a huge problem, a few players tried out there and in the end it was the 5/8 who did the best job. One of the centres was there and must have let 4-5 kicks bounce a metre in front of him, nearly all of which led to tries to the opposition.
However, apart from the 13 players who played NSW Cup we were also without about another 10 regular nyc players. So these were a lot of our 25-40 squad members. You add the wheelhouse boys, sirronen, woods, cerruto, satterthwaite, marshall king etc and there's a very decent squad there!
Karhwin's stats on the WT website are definitely wrong. He looks athletic but not as big as his stats suggest. Probably about 190cm and 90 something kgs. We never made a break through the backs all game so its impossible to tell how fast anyone is.
Also Hala Masila went to hospital at the end of the first half. Was hard to tell what was wrong, but he was done for a while. Maybe just a concussion.
**NSW Cup:**
Considering 5 of the 18 players named were fresh out of school and had never even played nyc before it showed how raw the team really was. A solid effort but were again outgunned by a more developed team.
Tatola is certainly a man mountain, he'll destroy NYC and was the yongest player on the field (and the biggest). Felise worked hard. Liddle looked very sharp out of dummy half. Murray never really saw any ball but did look fast. McCormack is tall but needs to fill out more for that level.
Again our forwards were heavily dominated by a more experienced pack and so our halves and backs never had any space all match. Heleta looked good in patches. Martin set up 2 tries but never had much space to work with. Seve never got the ball but played both centre and wing. Graham was pretty solid.
We also dropped a lot of ball. Parra/Wenty must have had 65% possession on both NYC and NSW Cup. Territory was also firmly in their favor. In the 3rd and fourth quarters even more NYCboys got a go. At one point there were 5 teenagers in a scrum Once again add Cherrington, Lovett, Drinkwater, Luani, Fine, Rowe and a couple more forwards and the team should be fine!
All things considered it was a good effort by the NSW Cup boys, and some promising signs for the future. Hopefully getting a taste of the speed of a higher level will help them when they drop back to NYC and a number of these boys might play half a season or more in nsw cup in any case..!