Wests Tigers 2017 Presentation Night
- Thread starter WT2K
- Start date
@ said:
Maybe he will be. My point is, a lot of people talk about him as if he _already is_ a champion and has locked down the hooking role for next year. I see zero evidence that he has done so yet seeing him awarded the rookie of the year gong suggests that the club also feels this way. It is exactly the same way Brooks and Moses were talked about when they came into grade. 5 years on and Brooksy still struggles to control a game whilst Moses was terribly inconsistant until he went to Parra and became a downhill skier. I hope Liddle does work out. Was he the best debutant for the side this year? No. I dont think he was even top 3.
Fade_To_Black
New member
Eisenhuth should of been Rookie OTY. Then Suli (or McIlwrick if he qualified). All of those should of been in front of Liddle, odd decision to pick him IMO. Didn't really do anything this year. Very strange.
LeichhardtTiger
Well-known member
http://www.weststigers.com.au/news/2017/09/06/taylor_reflects_on_k.html
Elijah Taylor - I cried! He is such a wonderful human! Congratulations! 2018 is gonna be awesome!
Elijah Taylor - I cried! He is such a wonderful human! Congratulations! 2018 is gonna be awesome!
@ said:
Think he played more games this year than Lolo, Huth, Twal, Suli and Marsters - that gave him a head start but the choice is subjective. I don't think he has anywhere near the hype that Brooks and Moses had on them.
The point is - is he the best hooker in the club. Imo, Yes. His opposition is McIlwrick (non creative, and basically a non runner and non kicker, but a good defender) - people are suggesting Reynolds for 2018 (probably a better kicking game and a bit more up top, average defender) - there is no one else unless you are scraping the barrel with ET.
Liddle is super quick, a runner from DH, good passing game, good defender - the only thing he needs to work on is his kicking game and building a bit more muscle.
Don't think anyone that will be at the club in 2018 comes anywhere near him Stryker.
supercoach
Well-known member
@ said:
Lot different playing no9 to playing 3 or 4\. Bar one game when everlbddle came on the team looked ten times sharper. If it was my choice I may have gone for Huth, but Iam happy with Liddle
Congrat's ET!
All the players talk so positively about Ivan - even Woods who is leaving.
It's great to finally have a coach that the players respect and want to play for - ET is a classic example.
I'd say with the relationship he has with the coach, ET will be captain. Can't underestimate the captain and coach being so firmly on the same page.
All the players talk so positively about Ivan - even Woods who is leaving.
It's great to finally have a coach that the players respect and want to play for - ET is a classic example.
I'd say with the relationship he has with the coach, ET will be captain. Can't underestimate the captain and coach being so firmly on the same page.
innsaneink
Well-known member
Nice timing.
Presentation night, Coach & CEO Q&A
Usually the week after Rd 26 you dont hear a peep from the club….like a cowering dog in the corner with its tail between its legs
Sweet end to another garbage year
Nice timing
Presentation night, Coach & CEO Q&A
Usually the week after Rd 26 you dont hear a peep from the club….like a cowering dog in the corner with its tail between its legs
Sweet end to another garbage year
Nice timing
Byron_Bay_Fan
New member
@ said:
Jamal, don't take any notice of our Disturbed poster - he thinks that he is Walter Sobchack.
BalmainBoy
New member
Jacob Liddle's girl is outstanding… best on ground
Byron_Bay_Fan
New member
@ said:
The ladies could have their own pageant competition.
Tweed_Tiger
Well-known member
Fulton discusses Wests Tigers Life Membership
http://www.weststigers.com.au/news/2017/09/08/fulton_discusses_wes.html
Liam Fulton talks about what it means to him to be inducted as a Life Member of Wests Tigers after he was awarded with the honour at the Club's Kelly-Barnes Award.
http://www.weststigers.com.au/news/2017/09/08/fulton_discusses_wes.html
Liam Fulton talks about what it means to him to be inducted as a Life Member of Wests Tigers after he was awarded with the honour at the Club's Kelly-Barnes Award.
voice_of_reason
Well-known member
@ said:
Just MHO but I would suggest minutes played would be a more reliable metric. That aside, he won the award so good luck to him. The fact we're discussing it means there were several in the running and that can only be a good thing for the future.
