Wests Tigers duo charged

@ said:
Who'll play Hooker against Warriors
No Liddle,MMK,MCK, ET, BROOKS ??? LAWRENCE???
JLJ if Brooks avaiable if not how about Daniel Peck from NYC livewire player could really test the warriors out.
Click to expand...

Is ET still out as well?
Maybe Dean Halatau, he should be at the ground doing some commentary for ABC radio. Might be worth a call.
 
Peck cannot tackle, he will get killed in 1st grade.

To come up with a side for this game, Cleary will need to channel his inner Sheenius.

It might be something like
Kev
MWZ
Marsters
Milone/Helata
Nofa
Tui
JLJ
Woods
Teddy
Grant
Edwards
Aloiai
Eisenhuth

Twal
Sue
Ava
Siro

lord knows who will fill 18-21
 
Yes it's unfair that he got charged, yes it's unfair he'll get a week, yes there are protected species, yes we're not one of them but at the end of the day made no attempt to tackle, he came in late and he's copped it.

It was a stupid effort on his part, which resulted in the back to back penalties for them to score and get back into the game. If he had have wrapped his arms there's no penalty. Simple as that.
 
@ said:
Yes it's unfair that he got charged, yes it's unfair he'll get a week, yes there are protected species, yes we're not one of them but at the end of the day made no attempt to tackle, he came in late and he's copped it.

It was a stupid effort on his part, which resulted in the back to back penalties for them to score and get back into the game. If he had have wrapped his arms there's no penalty. Simple as that.
Click to expand...

They both need to fight the charge - it is a joke.

Why wasn't Winterstein charged?

Why is Heighington getting off so lightly?

Review committee needs to be charged with incompetence.
 
@ said:
Chee-Kam's actions reminds me of the silly penalties that Ennis used to perform to throw SOO games away - I used to wonder if there was something more behind it than stupidity. How Ennis can now be a commentator after letting NSW down so stupidly I don't know.
Click to expand...

Ennis or Pierce?

Ennis could kind of fire up a pack till he got thumped. He would then try his "grub/niggle" tricks and get kicked for it.

I just wish they picked Ennis in 2008(I think) instead of Farah with the Broken ribs. Farah has been the only NSW hooker to stand up to Smith, maybe he is better, maybe worse but he is the only person to really go Toe to Toe with him. Had Farah gotten more team play earlier in his game he may have developed differently and been a little more useful.
 
@ said:
Who'll play Hooker against Warriors
No Liddle,MMK,MCK, ET, BROOKS ??? LAWRENCE???
JLJ if Brooks avaiable if not how about Daniel Peck from NYC livewire player could really test the warriors out.
Click to expand...

Maybe Lolohea can go hooker…. Not sure who go into the halves... Jack LJ and maybe young Sirro off the bench again... It's a problem fo sho
 
@ said:
So you can deliberately elbow someone in the face after they kick a ball….........

And Chee Kam gets a week for that?

Seriously
Click to expand...

Yep that was a joke, but MCK deserves what he got, turned the game against us, Ivan should have dropped him if he wasn't suspended.
 
I don't even remember McIlwrick's incident. The MRP is as much a lottery as the bunker is, it's ridiculous really. Chee-Kam's was penalty sufficient, and to be fair he's only missing a week from his record, but it's absurd that he's even on report.
 
Fair dinkum if he gets a suspension for that I'm out of here. There's bigger collisions in afl these days. Rugby league has lost me!!!
 
It was a DUMB DUMB play.

He gave away the penalty and from that moment onwards the Cowboys blew us away.

I just don't understand how a player who should know better does something like that.

Just DUMB DUMB DUMB
 
The whole shoulder charge law has to be looked at honestly….all MCK was trying to do was put pressure on the kicker. It was more front on then side on non tackle. Probably see a dozen of those per game. They can't suspend everyone that does it or there won't be a comp. RIDICULOUS!!!!!
 
I've no issue with MCK getting a week for what he did - more issue with others avoiding suspension for similar or worse offences. JWH surviving his elbow was particularly egregious.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 540 (members: 33, guests: 507)
Back
Top