Wests Tigers sign Robbie Farah for 2018 Official

  • Thread starter Thread starter joelw2002
  • Start date Start date
@ said:
@ said:
Now that theres no chance of making the 8 I cant see any reason to sign him. No logical reason anyway.
You just don't hand out contracts for the feel good factor.

There's no logic in your contention

Farah is a first rate 9 with great game management skills and outstanding defence around the ruck. He has brilliant awareness, maturity and can work under pressure

Apart from the obvious need for a 9 of his calibre, he deserves to go out in a style befitting a Club legend, the departure that the paranoid and immature Taylor denied him

People who regurgitate the DTs rubbish about devisiveness need to buy an original thought or two. Doesn't say much about your state of mind when you let Danny Weidler of Phil Rothfield do your thinking for you

He is a first rate 9, but no point signing him when we have no chance of making the 8\. This year is over.
 
@ said:
@ said:
Now that theres no chance of making the 8 I cant see any reason to sign him. No logical reason anyway.
You just don't hand out contracts for the feel good factor.

There's no logic in your contention

Farah is a first rate 9 with great game management skills and outstanding defence around the ruck. He has brilliant awareness, maturity and can work under pressure

Apart from the obvious need for a 9 of his calibre, he deserves to go out in a style befitting a Club legend, the departure that the paranoid and immature Taylor denied him

People who regurgitate the DTs rubbish about devisiveness need to buy an original thought or two. Doesn't say much about your state of mind when you let Danny Weidler of Phil Rothfield do your thinking for you

100 percent agree with your second paragraph.
 
I’m saying YES after today, Farah provides so many options close to the line and we know he can tackle.
There is too much pressure on Brooks to come up with the money shot plays
 
142 for
120 against
Either way it seems Ivan is screwed
There will always be disagreements on who we should sign and who makes the team
Circumstances often choose for us
And
It is impossible to please all
Who wants to coach
 
Sign him till end 2019\. He phases out as Liddle slowly takes over. Succession planning - should have been thought through before now.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Can't understand the animosity towards Farah….most of which is based on hearsay.
Here are some facts
1\. He is the most passionate player we have ever had.
2\. He is one of the best to ever play for us (only behind Benji).
3\. Even now he is better than anyone we've got in his position.
4\. We have a better chance of winning games with him in the team.

It's a yes from me.

Congratulations for the most ironic post of the year.

"Forget hearsay, here are some FACTS:
1\. Opinion
2\. Opinion
3\. Opinion
4\. Prediction"

Or is my sarcasm detector malfunctioning?

Your sarcasm detector isn't malfunctioning but your sense of reason is.
You don't think he is the most passionate player we've fielded, is one our best ever players and is a better hooker than anyone we've currently got?
Pretty sure the 'prediction' of having a better chance of winning will prove true also …if he signs.

I didn't say I disagreed with you, I just found it funny that you criticised people for repeating things they've heard, then proposed to talk facts, before running out a list of opinions.

It's all the same - opinions, hearsay, guesses, assumptions, ideas, feelings.

Your opinion they’re not facts?
My opinion is they are - and seeing you say you don’t disagree with them you haven’t put up much of a case that they aren’t .
Feel free to disagree all you like… it is a forum after all.
 
@ said:
I hate Robbie Farah and even I want him back after today

I could only see parts of the game but I have never witnessed poorer passing from DH as I seen today. My schoolboy team had a better DH than they had today. And that was in spite of the Catholic nuns only being our footie coaches.
 
Will be a brave move if he comes back now
There will be those who have nothing better to do than to dearh ride him if we continue on a downhill spiral.
If he is as selfish as he has been accused of then he is better off staying put. He is on a hiding to nothing here.
 
@ said:
@ said:
I hate Robbie Farah and even I want him back after today

I could only see parts of the game but I have never witnessed poorer passing from DH as I seen today. My schoolboy team had a better DH than they had today. And that was in spite of the Catholic nuns only being our footie coaches.

Exactly right, it's up there with the worst ive seen.
 
I’d say so, and given the loss, I’d say South Sydney would be more for it as we are almost completely out of the running for the final. We need a quality hooker to finish the year so our young quality hooker doesn’t have to get rushed back into first grade out of desperation. Robbie plays 80 minutes that solves a lot of issues in itself. Hopefully Liddle can continue to get consecutive games for 80 minutes in ISP as well.
Sign Robbie / Don’t rush the Kid!
 
Bring him back Canberra showed what an experienced hooker can do yesterday it will only be 18 month deal if that, by that time Liddle should be mature enough for first grade ET IS NOT A HOOKER
 
Does anyone else notice the correlation between Wests/Farah media circuses and poor performances on the field.

He is not even here yet and doing damage.
 
@ said:
@ said:
I hate Robbie Farah and even I want him back after today

I could only see parts of the game but I have never witnessed poorer passing from DH as I seen today. My schoolboy team had a better DH than they had today. And that was in spite of the Catholic nuns only being our footie coaches.

Maybe get the Nuns to visit IC and our no.9s!
 
@ said:
Does anyone else notice the correlation between Wests/Farah media circuses and poor performances on the field.

He is not even here yet and doing damage.

You have to be kidding :roll
There was an earthquake in Indonesia yesterday
, and I have it from a reliable source that Robbie Farah is implicated in that too
 

Latest posts

Back
Top