WESTS Tigers Team V Roosters...

[Coastie_Tiger]

Dead set Liddle must be made of tissue paper, MM should be getting a run.

 

[NT_Tiger]

The hooker position has become a real problem. I actually prefer Godinet there than ET. Other than that, pretty much as expected.

x2 Godinet / ET. But I don't get why Mckilwrick isn't there. Et shouldn't be near dummy half. This is the only one of Cleary's decisions I just don't get.

 

[Russell]

Dead set Liddle must be made of tissue paper, MM should be getting a run.

Obviously you haven't been watching ISP.

 

[tigerbalm]

Lolo at 1 and et at 9 with godinet on the bench. ?

Ivans using up all the goodwill he earnt at the start of the season with these selections. Fully expect a “kick cleary” thread soon if these guys don’t show us whatever it is he sees

Really? Kick Cleary? Really? He’s good goodwill from me for as long as he wants it.

Time will tell I guess.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

Dead set Liddle must be made of tissue paper, MM should be getting a run.

Obviously you haven't been watching ISP.

I've seen a few games and if Liddles out MM should play, just my opinion

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Dead set Liddle must be made of tissue paper, MM should be getting a run.

Obviously you haven't been watching ISP.

I've seen a few games and if Liddles out MM should play, just my opinion

I think he kicked Cleary’s dog. He’s not a fan.

 

[Tigerdave]

yeah prefer Godinet at 9\. The lack of an uninjured and decent 9 is really holding us back, more so than any other position at the moment.

 

[magpiecol]

no specialist no9…massive risk, surely MM for about 50 minutes would have been the way to go

I don’t understand why MM has fallen out of favour, the service ET gives from dummy half is terrible. If we are not getting good service from dummy half it stunts the whole attack.

Watch a few reserve grade games and you will understand.

 

[Tweed_Tiger]

no specialist no9…massive risk, surely MM for about 50 minutes would have been the way to go

I don’t understand why MM has fallen out of favour, the service ET gives from dummy half is terrible. If we are not getting good service from dummy half it stunts the whole attack.

Watch a few reserve grade games and you will understand.

I haven't seen many games this year but in the ones I watched the one thing he was consistent at was giving away penalties. He looked decent in the last game but nothing like how he was going last year before he signed a contract extension.

 

[Demps]

no specialist no9…massive risk, surely MM for about 50 minutes would have been the way to go

I don’t understand why MM has fallen out of favour, the service ET gives from dummy half is terrible. If we are not getting good service from dummy half it stunts the whole attack.

Watch a few reserve grade games and you will understand.

I haven't seen many games this year but in the ones I watched the one thing he was consistent at was giving away penalties. He looked decent in the last game but nothing like how he was going last year before he signed a contract extension.

Agreed.
He wouldn't let us down.
Coach ain't down for whatever reason, I would like to know why.

 

[happy_tiger]

Big fan of Liddle and not too worried about where he's at. Ivan has played him very limited minutes, so he has hardly been thrown in the deep end. When he's on our attack is so much better.

It's hard to go out in the market for a hooker to play a bit-part while we develop Liddle. You're not going to get anyone much better than MM or Godinet willing to play second fiddle.

Agree Moh.
We're just going to have to tough it out while Liddle gets back on track.
Personally think Eiso is an improvement on ET at lock too.

We got on the front foot with Reynolds , not sure if he is a long term answer though

Must admit it's getting annoying with players neither listed as injured or dropped ….. Liddle not on casualty list .....

 

[Geo]

Jacob rested…sternum still troubling but could have played through..

Dunno what's happened to Rochow tho..but we have Chee-Kam..lucky..

 

[TIGER]

Mitch Rein

 

[Balmainbred]

Robson to hooker

 

[Tigerdon]

Jacob rested…sternum still troubling but could have played through..

Dunno what's happened to Rochow tho..but we have Chee-Kam..lucky..

President and Vice President are taken in the fan club. Secretary is still available.

 

[Newtown]

Who was Wests Tigers' hooker when they defeated Roosters earlier in the season? Wasn't it Godinet? If so I think he will start and CheeKam goes to the bench.

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Jacob rested…sternum still troubling but could have played through..

Dunno what's happened to Rochow tho..but we have Chee-Kam..lucky..

President and Vice President are taken in the fan club. Secretary is still available.

I'll put my hand up for Secretary or Treasurer or whatever - Geo will only mess it all up and cause divisions :mrgreen:

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Who was Wests Tigers' hooker when they defeated Roosters earlier in the season? Wasn't it Godinet? If so I think he will start and CheeKam goes to the bench.

Killa

 

[Oggy]

Why can't Grub play hook in the future?? I am sure he would go great there. look at guys like Wallace

 

[earl]

Why can't Grub play hook in the future?? I am sure he would go great there. look at guys like Wallace

I think that this is what Clearly is hoping occurs but we don't know if he can perform there or not.