WESTS Tigers Team V St George

That's the best balanced side we have named this season. Happy to see Aloiai start and Sue revert back to the bench. I think Chee-Kam can count himself a little unlucky. I would rather see him start in the centres and give Frozone the flick because he has offered nothing this season so far. Still think the Dragons will beat us, but I think it will be close.
 
@ said:
That's the best balanced side we have named this season. Happy to see Aloiai start and Sue revert back to the bench. I think Chee-Kam can count himself a little unlucky. I would rather see him start in the centres and give Frozone the flick because he has offered nothing this season so far. Still think the Dragons will beat us, but I think it will be close.
Click to expand...

His saving grace last year was that he was good with ball in hand. Hasn't looked threatening at all this season. He's on his last legs at this club. Def won't be here next season.
 
Reasonable side.

Idris needs to lift, JLJ needs to steady the ship and Moses will need to lift also as history has shown he performs better without Brooks.
 
Heaps better team and a massive step in the right direction in the post JT era.

Would love to see Tatola and Felise there somewhere though.
 
I agree with Willow wish we'd drop Naiqama. Getting real sick of him trying to knock the ball out instead of tackling. Did anyone see on Sunday when addo Carr made a half break and Naiqama could have easily tackled from behind instead he leaped and tried to punch the ball out from behind, pretty much mounted his back clean missed the ball and thudded into the ground…he was nearly away after that too luckily teddy cleaned him up
 
@ said:
I agree with Willow wish we'd drop Naiqama. Getting real sick of him trying to knock the ball out instead of tackling. Did anyone see on Sunday when addo Carr made a half break and Naiqama could have easily tackled from behind instead he leaped and tried to punch the ball out from behind, pretty much mounted his back clean missed the ball and thudded into the ground…he was nearly away after that too luckily teddy cleaned him up
Click to expand...

Yep Naqama is done. I doubt any other NRL team would have him in their 17\. Every time we're defending and the ball goes anywhere near him I cringe.
 
The truth is we haven't been able to score points so adding idris makes sense. He also can't be any weaker defensively then what's been happening
 
@ said:
That's the best balanced side we have named this season. Happy to see Aloiai start and Sue revert back to the bench. I think Chee-Kam can count himself a little unlucky. I would rather see him start in the centres and give Frozone the flick because he has offered nothing this season so far. Still think the Dragons will beat us, but I think it will be close.
Click to expand...

Funny you should mention that - I believe Chee Kam was considered a right side Centre by Manly Coaching staff….
 
@ said:
I agree with Willow wish we'd drop Naiqama. Getting real sick of him trying to knock the ball out instead of tackling. Did anyone see on Sunday when addo Carr made a half break and Naiqama could have easily tackled from behind instead he leaped and tried to punch the ball out from behind, pretty much mounted his back clean missed the ball and thudded into the ground…he was nearly away after that too luckily teddy cleaned him up
Click to expand...

Yeah commented on that in the live game thread

I think Woods got him though

Naiqama needs to be replaced asap but I'm not sure Chee Kam is the answer either , he has missed his fair share of tackles this season
 
@ said:
@ said:
I agree with Willow wish we'd drop Naiqama. Getting real sick of him trying to knock the ball out instead of tackling. Did anyone see on Sunday when addo Carr made a half break and Naiqama could have easily tackled from behind instead he leaped and tried to punch the ball out from behind, pretty much mounted his back clean missed the ball and thudded into the ground…he was nearly away after that too luckily teddy cleaned him up

Yeah commented on that in the live game thread

I think Woods got him though

Naiqama needs to be replaced asap but I'm not sure Chee Kam is the answer either , he has missed his fair share of tackles this season
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Why not Suli? We have guys like Justin hunt that can do a decent job on the wing for us
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
I agree with Willow wish we'd drop Naiqama. Getting real sick of him trying to knock the ball out instead of tackling. Did anyone see on Sunday when addo Carr made a half break and Naiqama could have easily tackled from behind instead he leaped and tried to punch the ball out from behind, pretty much mounted his back clean missed the ball and thudded into the ground…he was nearly away after that too luckily teddy cleaned him up

Yeah commented on that in the live game thread

I think Woods got him though

Naiqama needs to be replaced asap but I'm not sure Chee Kam is the answer either , he has missed his fair share of tackles this season

Why not Suli? We have guys like Justin hunt that can do a decent job on the wing for us
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

I agree , its his favoured position
 
I think maybe some of our depth players that dont seem to get a chance in NRL may have a better opportunity once Cleary comes in….just an opinion but Hunt and some of the others could go better with the help of Ivan,I dont really know just a thought because in rugby league some players dont go well under some coaches but thrive under others...
 
A shame Naiqama is still selected.He really is not up to standard. Bench looks a bit better this week
 
@ said:
@ said:
Who's gonna stop Vaughan?

Good question. He's done a bloody good job of going through decent forward packs this season.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Remember when there was a thread about whether we should sign Vaughan and the majority said nah pass hahaha

Classic
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 341 (members: 32, guests: 309)
Back
Top