Whats happened to big red?
- Thread starter bp_tiger
- Start date
happy_tiger
Well-known member
Shoulder BP
foreveratiger
New member
No big loss
happy_tiger
Well-known member
Keefy has played many times injured over the years for the Tigers
I think he deserves some respect for that , despite him not being anywhere near his best this season
Unless you can possibly understand what its like to have to get needled up to play and train weeks on end , some should probably give the guy a break to be honest
Knock his form most certainly , don't knock his heart or bravery
He has proven the latter points in spades in my opinion over the years
I think he deserves some respect for that , despite him not being anywhere near his best this season
Unless you can possibly understand what its like to have to get needled up to play and train weeks on end , some should probably give the guy a break to be honest
Knock his form most certainly , don't knock his heart or bravery
He has proven the latter points in spades in my opinion over the years
foreveratiger
New member
I respect his bravery and commitment for the club, but for me the red sauce will go down as someone who underachieved in my opinion, so much potential but never lived up to this rep player year in year out.
2010 and 2011 were his best years but now seems to struggle to stay out on the field.
Hope he kills it next year
2010 and 2011 were his best years but now seems to struggle to stay out on the field.
Hope he kills it next year
Dropped for poor form
Tim Sheens
Well-known member
Some of those replying should get off Keefy's back, he carries half the side in the middle as it is, let alone continuing to of late with a needled up busted shoulder.
We are all entitled to an opinion, thus I have no problem with anyone bagging players when they have even a little substance to back it up with. Apart from the fact he is no Usain Bolt, please point out some examples where we are better, particularly defensively up the guts, without him. A couple of games should be easy to point out for those that believe he is poor.
We are all entitled to an opinion, thus I have no problem with anyone bagging players when they have even a little substance to back it up with. Apart from the fact he is no Usain Bolt, please point out some examples where we are better, particularly defensively up the guts, without him. A couple of games should be easy to point out for those that believe he is poor.
We understand he is struggling wit injuries But at end of day. We want our club competing with the top. He is not in the top 10% of props anymore. We know that. But he is our starting prop ?? He is a experienced bench player for a top side these days Again. He has been good first grader but time is catching up
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@galea#11 said:
And I can see similar cases at many other clubs
Hannant at the Broncos ,Bailey at the Titans, FPN at the Roosters , Mason at the Knights are just a few examples
If Keefy does have to move to the bench there are other clubs that have experience coming off the bench and it can't hurt one little bit
Wacko_Jacko
New member
injured AC joint in shoulder in Dragons game, played 15th week after with needle but maybe late inclusion this week fitness test later in week
Masterton
Well-known member
@galea#11 said:
Simple maths indicate you don't have to be in the top 10% of props to be in the starting line-up, even at really good clubs.
It's not a popular opinion around here, but I think he's fine. Obviously not at his best this year, but his good lateral defence and 100m average with the ball have been decent for playing injured.
fibrodreaming
Well-known member
@underdog said:
That's a pretty despicable thing to say underdog.
You'r the coward, hiding behind anonymity to slime a good club man like Galloway.
cqtiger
Well-known member
So fibrodreaming is your real name then?
_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
