Who was good and who sucked

M

MacDougall

New member
Another edition of who was good and who sucked.

Tedesco - Good
Nofoaluma - Good
Ayshford - Good
Simona - Good
Tuqiri - Good
Marshall - Sucked
Anasta - Sucked
Galloway - Good
Luani - Sucked
Blair - Sucked
Fulton - Sucked
Murdoch-Masila - Good
Sue - Sucked

Seumanufagai - Good
Sironen - Good
Iosefa - Sucked
Bell - Good

Most good award goes to Teddy
Old prick who was surprisingly good award goes to Lote
Biggest suck award goes to Marshall again
 
BMM was the highlight for me tonight. Makes me wonder why it has taken so long for him to see some decent game time.
 
Bell ran for nearly 100m in a well beaten side and didn't stop trying. Luani did nothing at all. He sucked less than Iosefa but is that really good enough to qualify him as good? I think not. Bell made one bad miss, but Tedesco made a huge blooper too. You can have a good game with one bad spot. Aside from the one bad miss Bell was among our best.
 
Seeing Sironen injected makes you wonder why he's on the bench. Carrying an injury or not he's still better than both Marshall and Anasta.
 
@MacDougall said:
Another edition of who was good and who sucked.

Tedesco - Good
Nofoaluma - Good
Ayshford - Good
Simona - Good
Tuqiri - Good
Marshall - Sucked
Anasta - Sucked
Galloway - Good
Luani - Sucked
Blair - Sucked
Fulton - Sucked
Murdoch-Masila - Good
Sue - Sucked

Seumanufagai - Good
Sironen - Good
Iosefa - Sucked
Bell - Good

Most good award goes to Teddy
Old prick who was surprisingly good award goes to Lote
Biggest suck award goes to Marshall again
Click to expand...

I thought they all played great !!! I thought they would put 70 on us

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
@phil1986 said:
Being a bit hard on Blair!

And Matt bell had a few costly errors.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Click to expand...

Blair
9 hitups for 63 metres, 15 tackles, 2 offloads, 1 penalty conceded

Bell
9 hitups for 88 metres, 24 tackles, 0 offloads, 0 penalties conceded

Bell made a bad missed tackle but I bet if you rewatch that Blair was guilty of arm grabbing a lot that led to tries from long range line breaks.
 
@Fraze23 said:
Seeing Sironen injected makes you wonder why he's on the bench. Carrying an injury or not he's still better than both Marshall and Anasta.
Click to expand...

Anything has to be better than Anasta and Marshall I bet the Auckland Blues are worried!!
 
@MacDougall said:
Bell ran for nearly 100m in a well beaten side and didn't stop trying. Luani did nothing at all. He sucked less than Iosefa but is that really good enough to qualify him as good? I think not. Bell made one bad miss, but Tedesco made a huge blooper too. You can have a good game with one bad spot. Aside from the one bad miss Bell was among our best.
Click to expand...

I agree with Bell.
Teddy was more than likely out on his feet from being the man everywhere all night. He was by far our best. By a long shot.

Bradley - can't access account.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
@tiger-stripes said:
@Blake93 said:
Saying bell was good and luani sucked takes away all your credibility.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

Took the words right from my mouth

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Luani sucked. He sucked last week as well. I'm not going to go easy on him just because he's a rookie. Our rookies have been our best players this season and his suckness stands out. He's got nothing. He's certainly better than Iosefa but he has shown nothing, missed a lot of tackles and has poor service. Better than Iosefa though. Cherrington and Luff are both miles better than him.

Bell did not suck. You all have your eyes painted on. One missed tackle does not equal a bad game. He was our best forward behind BMM and Galloway.
 
@Blake93 said:
Bell single handedly let in at least 2 tries….he wasn't "good"

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Click to expand...

Are you just making up facts to back yourself up or can you show me the second try? He is responsible for the Tupou try off the scrum. That's all I noticed.
 
See Happy knows Bell didn't suck. Happy doesn't have his eyes painted on.

I think Simona and Lote were both at least good as well though. Galloway, Ava and Sironen would be classed as "not bad" if that were a scoring factor but they were more good than bad so it's good. It's not the "good, not bad and sucked" thread it's good or sucked.
 
blair looked good i thought.
bell didnt.
luani was OK. needs time.

stats for bell/blair are interesting though.

anasta was much better today as well. ayshford had gotten a kick up his arse for sure.

teddy is improving with each game.. soon he'll be a star this kid. bmm WOOOWWWW !!!! took a gamble couple of weeks ago in picking him in my DT- he's going good.

idc what potter's reason is anymore- benji MUST be dropped. nothing else. he has to be dropped.
 
@Blake93 said:
Bell single handedly let in at least 2 tries….he wasn't "good"

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Click to expand...

Pretty sure Bell has had over 3 months off with a hand injury and check out the reply an he has fell off 2 tackles when using his right hand and was not alone in the tackle attempts
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

No members online now.
Total: 267 (members: 0, guests: 267)
Back
Top