Who would you prefer at 5/8, Reynolds at 750K or Moses at 850K?

@ said:
Reynolds needs a controlling halfback
Brooks needs a running 5/8

They complement each other so well.

Moses is garbage.
Click to expand...

Not only that he will add experience to our young side.
Match winner that is all heart and passion.
 
I think the combination of Brooks and Renyolds is much better as they compliment each other. Brooks & Moses playing style is similar and I haven't really observed them playing well together, they play better when they are apart.
 
What is the point of this thread?????

We have Reynolds.
Moses is going - thank God (from a Moses fan).
TMM is going to the warriors.

There is no preference - it has been made by Cleary.
 
What Ivan wants I want he would be a better judge than most of us but he also would already know what He is going to get each player we sign to do / play
 
@ said:
My 2 cents.

At the moment with the state of the team and the position we are going to be in Reynolds hands down.
He is an out and out five eight. A runner first, reacting to the defence, doesn't throw a slick ball in a sweeping play but he does get his arms free to link up with his centre or backrower (Jackson). In addition to this, Brooks is an out and out halfback, he will not is yet but he will be a great organiser / game manager half and already has good kicking skill. (In game application needs work).
Reynolds will help mild our team into a consistent finals side.
However.
Once that time comes. The player you want once you become a consistent contender is actually someone like Mitchell Moses. I truely believe that he has more X factor in him and will be a key to a team winning a comp.
As I said at this stage we need a Reynolds type more.
Click to expand...

I understand what your trying to say but I have to disagree with you. When I think of Reynolds going into a GF/finals game I would want him over Moses (even considering X factor) for two reasons.

1\. The passion he plays with each and every week would only be heightened coming so close to realising his dream of winning a GF.

2\. Losing two GFs with Canterbury, I can't help but think he would want to win one not only to be remembered for winning a GF but also to show his former club they bet on the wrong horse by letting him go.

That's why I would want Reynolds leading out my WTs; Finals and Grand Finals included.
 
I am wondering why Parra have not announced if Moses HAS signed for next year he is going over? Could it be now the Tiger's have shut that door by signing Reynolds before he actually signed they are rethinking their offer & Moses and his dodgy manager are crapping their pants as they are not going to get their original "handshake" fee?
 
@ said:
I am wondering why Parra have not announced if Moses HAS signed for next year he is going over? Could it be now the Tiger's have shut that door by signing Reynolds before he actually signed they are rethinking their offer & Moses and his dodgy manager are crapping their pants as they are not going to get their original "handshake" fee?
Click to expand...

Yeah it's a little odd why there's been nothing official
 
I wish we could have Reynolds NOW,and Parra can have all ego and lack of ability Moses NOW.

A question: Who will be our goal kicker next year?
 
A: Whoever can kick it through the posts…Maybe if this question was posted after we complete our recruitment for 2018 we'd be able to better answer it.
 
@ said:
@ said:
I am wondering why Parra have not announced if Moses HAS signed for next year he is going over? Could it be now the Tiger's have shut that door by signing Reynolds before he actually signed they are rethinking their offer & Moses and his dodgy manager are crapping their pants as they are not going to get their original "handshake" fee?

Yeah it's a little odd why there's been nothing official
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

maybe they have realised they made a mistake and are embarrassed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 269 (members: 40, guests: 229)
Back
Top