I think there are two telling factors, the number of home grounds and the lack of facilities at two of those grounds - Campbelltown and Leichhardt.
I think our membership numbers are on a par or better than any other club that plays out of suburban grounds, bar St George but Kogarah and WIN are now both way ahead of Leichhardt and Campbelltown in terms of undercover seating and overall facilities.
People baulk at forking out good money for a 'seat' on two pieces of timber or a damp grass hill, where you have to walk through urine to take a pee.
All the clubs with memberships around the 20,000 play in far superior stadiums, and as they have more seats to sell can offer better value especially for general admission deals.
ps Bug, i'm Wests and i'm a member. Wests, in 20 odd years never captured the imagine of the Macarthur region - they averaged crowds of less than 8,000 compared to over 13,000 that the Tigers average there.
To suggest that the Macarthur region is our heartland is to view the joint venture through black and white eyes. The clubs that struggle are those that narrowly focus in on one region within Sydney (e.g. Cronulla, Manly, Penrith). Our heartland is Sydney. Our fan base spread far and wide.
**Wests were the laughing stock of the league, no hopers, perennial losers**. I for one am glad they merged. I now have witnessed my win a competition and become a real threat for the last 2 years and, I'm hoping, again this year. The club (Wests Tigers) has bent over backwards to get Wests on board, but the infighting, sniping and bickering and continued loser/victim culture of some involved with Wests stops them embracing the joint venture. Quite frankly, the sooner the old magpie turns it up and dies, probably the better. The 'victims' will likely keep on whingeing and complaining. Some of us, on the other hand, will fondly remember the struggles and the occasional triumph through nostalgic, and possibly teary eyes.