Blake93
New member
Does anyone know or is it just to rest him? VERY dumb move if that's the case
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Why is farah out?
- Thread starter Blake93
- Start date
cnx_tigers
New member
- Joined
- Jul 19, 2009
- Messages
- 903
@Blakeeeeeee said:
Mate, he was KNOCKED OUT in the game…......and played 80 minutes semi concussed.
And you want him to play 2 days later?
innsaneink
Well-known member
Im guessing OP didnt see him in ga -ga land last night, Im surprised he stayed on…thought he was gone
cnx_tigers
New member
- Joined
- Jul 19, 2009
- Messages
- 903
side note: this is why you MUST win your games against teams like Newcastle and the Roosters.
because you never know when injuries will hit. No Robbie and Ellis makes this a very, very tough game to win.
If we hadn't lost the Knights game, this one wouldn't be so crucial. We've never really had that desperation under Sheens to win the "easy" ones. That's why we've missed the finals so often under him. If Benji was to get hurt, we'd miss out again this season. Conversely, Bellamy teams can afford key guys out as they always accumulate points early. Slater will return in a few weeks fresh and keen and they'll still be in a good position. It's frustrating watching Sheens teams continually do this.
because you never know when injuries will hit. No Robbie and Ellis makes this a very, very tough game to win.
If we hadn't lost the Knights game, this one wouldn't be so crucial. We've never really had that desperation under Sheens to win the "easy" ones. That's why we've missed the finals so often under him. If Benji was to get hurt, we'd miss out again this season. Conversely, Bellamy teams can afford key guys out as they always accumulate points early. Slater will return in a few weeks fresh and keen and they'll still be in a good position. It's frustrating watching Sheens teams continually do this.
tig_prmz
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 1, 1970
- Messages
- 11,838
i guess combination of exhaustion and the fact that he got concussed.. if this was origin I.. he would've played imo, but it was Origin III, players start to burn out now. how many games has he missed this season? need him firing ASAP
G
Guest
Guest
@Blakeeeeeee said:
Concussion protcols.
G
Guest
Guest
@tig_prmz said:
He wouldn't have played either way, it's the Doctors call in these situations.
@Golden said:
Yep. This bugs me too. Robbie should've been taken off the field on Wednesday night, at least to be given a proper check on his condition. Can't learn much in 20 seconds i'd have thought. It seems almost hypocritical of the game to say that he was okay on Wednesday night and not so two days later. They got that very wrong imo. Ultimately though in regards to this game tonight the decision is the correct one.
G
Guest
Guest
@Golden said:
It was Sheens argument that there is one set of rules for the regular competition, and what appears to be another set of rules when it comes to rep football.
tig_prmz
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 1, 1970
- Messages
- 11,838
@Golden said:
yes, it's a load of crap. concussion is not soremess or something which gets worse after the game, concussion heals with time.
simonthetiger
New member
- Joined
- Jul 10, 2009
- Messages
- 3,705
He is out cos that dirty big headed QLD APE KEPT HEADBUTTING HIM!!!!
I cant believe you can use ur head on another head and get away with it.
Arm,shoulder foot…and ur gone.
Head is apparently ok,as well as shepherds
I remember the furore after Villisanti got Fittler,but this hasnt even caused a ripple.
I cant believe you can use ur head on another head and get away with it.
Arm,shoulder foot…and ur gone.
Head is apparently ok,as well as shepherds
I remember the furore after Villisanti got Fittler,but this hasnt even caused a ripple.
Frank_the_tank
New member
Queensland are he chosen team, they can do what they like. And don't even question them you'll just be labelled a whinger.
Farah got concussed by a head but in a tackle, that's why he is out.
If he had of been smashed by a fist forearm elbow knee foot. Then they may have called the tackle dangerous or even reckless. But he copped Nate miles enormous forehead so it's play on.
Farah got concussed by a head but in a tackle, that's why he is out.
If he had of been smashed by a fist forearm elbow knee foot. Then they may have called the tackle dangerous or even reckless. But he copped Nate miles enormous forehead so it's play on.
