@Cultured Bogan said:
Rd 26 v Raiders 2016..
Worst Wests Tigers Side ever!
- Thread starter Frazer4Wests
- Start date
Rd 26 v Raiders 2016..
Ah of course.
@Frazer4Wests said:
I love the guys who go through the list of players on Wikipedia and pick the players with bugger all games for us and assume they were ordinary…. Whilst some on your list may belong there, There's more than a few that don't!!
I'd consider Saleh and possibly Bajouri better wingers than one we have on our books ATM. Glen Air was a solid player - Certainly no superstar, But his game he had for us was by no means a poor one. Shayne Dunley went on to play over 100 games of first grade - Hardly a terrible player to notch out that career. Ben Duckworth had some fantastic games in our colours, Could have been anything if not for injuries....
Ryan Tandy won a premiership and was at his best in the 08-10 years of his career - A starting prop in better teams than ours...
Robbie Mears was more than a solid player
Mark Flanagan had a fantastic motor, Not a massive guy - But a great utility forward.... Wasn't used real well with us.
TopTiger
Well-known member
Several of the players selected in the list were past their best by the time they played for the Tigers being Jason Cayless (stuffed knee when signed) and Nick Graham (just all round stuffed). I agree with several others that Mark Flanagan went OK (solid player), whilst Mears, Dunley, Tandy and Duckworth all had their moments. I noticed Anasta was not mentioned, he certainly played his fair share of ordinary games for the Tigers!!
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Flanagan was really underrated. Was disappointed he only stayed the two seasons. I agree with Batboy, just because a player only played a couple games should not qualify a player in the worst ever team. It's going the simple route and not a true reflection at all. You pick players who made you have your heart in your mouth every time they touched the ball. Or if a play broke down when it got to that player. They're aren't too many players in the side named that made me feel that way. The two players who made je most feel that way over the years were Fitzhenry and Joel Caine. But you won't see their names in too many worst ever teams. It's easier to point and laugh at guys like Salah and Bajouri because they only played a handful of games.
fergiefurr
New member
BIt harsh on some. Flanagan was always alright when he filled into a pretty strong line up.
As others have said duckworth was also pretty good, he's pretty problem was too many knee injuries.
Who was the guy we signed from Melbourne in 2000 or 2001 mid season? Dane Morgan? He got talked up by the coaching staff big time, played 1 game, was terrible and seemed to dissapear off the face of the earth.
As others have said duckworth was also pretty good, he's pretty problem was too many knee injuries.
Who was the guy we signed from Melbourne in 2000 or 2001 mid season? Dane Morgan? He got talked up by the coaching staff big time, played 1 game, was terrible and seemed to dissapear off the face of the earth.
fergiefurr
New member
I also thought Lolesi was ok, he just got moved around to a different position every week by sheens. Now his fault
Great Odd Season Thread
Wheres
terry Hill
Owen creagie
John Hopoate
Ryan Tandy
Richard Vilasanti
Braith Anasta
and many many more
\
\
Worst Coach EVER - Terry the $^&%&^%&^ Lamb
PLAYERS LIST Below.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Wests_Tigers_players
Wheres
terry Hill
Owen creagie
John Hopoate
Ryan Tandy
Richard Vilasanti
Braith Anasta
and many many more
\
\
Worst Coach EVER - Terry the $^&%&^%&^ Lamb
PLAYERS LIST Below.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Wests_Tigers_players
simonthetigerrrr
New member
Lee Murphy and trent runciman.
Byron_Bay_Fan
New member
After all the sarcasm and bile directed at Robbie Farah I don't how the temptation to include him was avoided? I can't recall such shocking defence as last season - surely some of them deserve to be included.
jirskyr
Well-known member
@batboy said:
re Tandy, I don't think you can count players who did alright elsewhere. We are talking about output whilst at the Tigers. Jason Cayless had a great career before he left for England and then played like a busted for us.
Hassan Saleh, please! I do agree with you re a few of these guys Dunley, Duckworth, Mears, Flanagan were all alright. But Hassan Saleh was a deadset coat, he might have had a fair number of games under his belt, but he was there because we had such poor options otherwise. NBQ was IMO twice the footballer that Saleh Boy was, and that isn't saying much.
I think also the idea is picking the worst player in each position, not necessarily the Top 17 worst players.
Cosimo_Zaretti
New member
No mention of Justin Hunt yet, the only man I've ever seen turn and run the wrong way before he got to the line. Not a back pedal, not a sidestep, he legit got close in the corner then turned to face the other end and ran away.
Bulldogs game this year. Worst performance I've seen in a Tigers jersey.
Bulldogs game this year. Worst performance I've seen in a Tigers jersey.
1\. Shannon McDonnell
2\. Hassan Saleh
3\. Nick Bradley- Qalilawa
4\. Michael Buettner
5\. Ahmad Bajouri
6\. Braith Anasta
7\. Jacob Miller
8\. Chris Paterson
9\. Masada Iosefa
10\. Ryan O'Hara
11\. Sam Harris
12\. Nick Graham
13\. Scott Sattler
14\. Rhys Hanbury
15\. Matt Groat
16\. Trent Runiciman
17\. Hayes Lauder
2\. Hassan Saleh
3\. Nick Bradley- Qalilawa
4\. Michael Buettner
5\. Ahmad Bajouri
6\. Braith Anasta
7\. Jacob Miller
8\. Chris Paterson
9\. Masada Iosefa
10\. Ryan O'Hara
11\. Sam Harris
12\. Nick Graham
13\. Scott Sattler
14\. Rhys Hanbury
15\. Matt Groat
16\. Trent Runiciman
17\. Hayes Lauder
@jirskyr said:
If they were terrible whilst our club was paying them hen they deserve to be on the Shame list.
Tandy
Cayless
Anasta
Adam Blair
and the other losers I mentioned in a prev post….
Perhaps Im cranky and should go to bed...
