WT v Eels live game thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guest
  • Start date Start date
@Geo said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240070) said:
I didn't realise you can be penalised fro a shoulder charge when your shoulder doesn't even touch the player..

It was a ridiculous call.
 
@Speed2burn said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240057) said:
If there is one positive out of last night it’s that Catterson will be watching from the sidelines. That was as deliberate of a crusher I’ve seen

Dont underestimate the power of the MRC committee to either ignore it or the judiciary to exonarate him.
 
@jadtiger said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240083) said:
@Speed2burn said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240057) said:
If there is one positive out of last night it’s that Catterson will be watching from the sidelines. That was as deliberate of a crusher I’ve seen

Dont underestimate the power of the MRC committee to either ignore it or the judiciary to exonarate him.

Well I just watched the footy show in regards to injury’s and suspensions and Catterson didn’t get a mention
 
@jadtiger said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240083) said:
@Speed2burn said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240057) said:
If there is one positive out of last night it’s that Catterson will be watching from the sidelines. That was as deliberate of a crusher I’ve seen

Dont underestimate the power of the MRC committee to either ignore it or the judiciary to exonarate him.

Yep fully aware unfortunately....finals series seems to always give a bit of leniency
 
@Speed2burn said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240085) said:
@jadtiger said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240083) said:
@Speed2burn said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240057) said:
If there is one positive out of last night it’s that Catterson will be watching from the sidelines. That was as deliberate of a crusher I’ve seen

Dont underestimate the power of the MRC committee to either ignore it or the judiciary to exonarate him.

Yep fully aware unfortunately....finals series seems to always give a bit of leniency

I doubt if Blocker would agree after 1988
 
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19
 
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

Doueihi will miss a game with early plea for shoulder charge
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029560340078592?s=19
 
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240091) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

Doueihi will miss a game with early plea for shoulder charge
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029560340078592?s=19

Does that mean he’s out for round 1 next year?
 
If anything i would describe ADs tackle as a bodycheck to charge him with a "shoulder charge" id completely wrong as his shoulder makes no contact.As usual Annesleys MRC do whatever they can to hit the lesser clubs(in their minds)
 
@avocadoontoast said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240100) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240091) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

Doueihi will miss a game with early plea for shoulder charge
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029560340078592?s=19

Does that mean he’s out for round 1 next year?

Yea will miss round one
 
@avocadoontoast said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240100) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240091) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

Doueihi will miss a game with early plea for shoulder charge
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029560340078592?s=19

Does that mean he’s out for round 1 next year?

He'll be out next week dam we're not playing next week if I was AD I would challenge it was more a body check I think his side and hip made the conract not the shoulder next time take an axe handle or a piece of 4 x 2
 
@jadtiger said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240086) said:
@Speed2burn said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240085) said:
@jadtiger said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240083) said:
@Speed2burn said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240057) said:
If there is one positive out of last night it’s that Catterson will be watching from the sidelines. That was as deliberate of a crusher I’ve seen

Dont underestimate the power of the MRC committee to either ignore it or the judiciary to exonarate him.

Yep fully aware unfortunately....finals series seems to always give a bit of leniency

I doubt if Blocker would agree after 1988

Not old enough to know that at all haha
 
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

If that’s a grade 1 crusher what’s a grade 3? decapitation?
 
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240110) said:
@avocadoontoast said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240100) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240091) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

Doueihi will miss a game with early plea for shoulder charge
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029560340078592?s=19

Does that mean he’s out for round 1 next year?

Yea will miss round one

That sucks
 
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

I thought the new rule was even if grade1 guilty you get a week
 
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240091) said:
@WT2K said in [WT v Eels live game thread](/post/1240090) said:
Shatterson won't miss a game if takes early plea
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029375438372865?s=19

Doueihi will miss a game with early plea for shoulder charge
https://twitter.com/LeagueUnlimited/status/1310029560340078592?s=19

Need to fight the charge - it was a ridiculous charge in the first place.

Where are you Brydens?
 
I’m a bit slow but just noticed the only difference scoring wise was the goal kicking 1/5 vs 4/5. Both teams scored 5 tries. I think Adam will be a fine goal kicker and consistency will come with an off season of practice.
 
Back
Top