Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Jedi_Tiger]

Don't have to worry about limiting it to those 2 Players...
The Club has 5 seasons (Out of 22) Where we've won 50% or more of our games in a season.
FIVE!!
With players like Benji and Robbie - Woods and Tedesco

#sackbrooks #that'llfixit

5 seasons that is worse than first thought
geez

 

[GNR4LIFE]

And outside of Prince and Lui, we we’ve never had a game changing halfback

Craig Field
Ben Black
Ben Jeffries
Lincoln Withers
John Morris

 

[Speed2burn]

We just need to find a halfback who can score us 31 points a game. Simple.

We actually ranked 8th in attack last year but I can't remember how many times we were chasing points (Cowboys and Titans game spring to mind) because of our crappy defence.

For as long as I can remember our D has been a shambles, with last year being our worst on record. I don't know how some people can't identify this as our #1 problem

 

[GNR4LIFE]

We actually ranked 8th in attack last year but I can't remember how many times we were chasing points (Cowboys and Titans game spring to mind) because of our crappy defence.

For as long as I can remember our D has been a shambles, with last year being our worst on record. I don't know how some people can't identify this as our #1 problem

I can only remember one period where our defence was rock solid and that was the start of 2018 when we were only conceding 10-12 points a game. Didn’t last.

 

[Tiger-ferret]

A change in 7 isn’t going to change much. We’ll still be an ordinary side who show little to no heart.

I’m optimistic we’ll show more heart this year

 

[craigtob]

I just don’t understand why we always have players wanting out or being shopped around.
To me it seems this happens more often than any other club?

 

[KH1988]

I’m optimistic we’ll show more heart this year

**Rothfield Warning** - Along those lines

On NRL360 on Monday Rothfield said Sheens told him something along the lines of - he realises we won't win the comp this year he just doesn't want to see us getting flogged

 

[batboy]

Single H

We just need to find a halfback who can score us 31 points a game. Simple.

......... Single handedly!!

 

[tony soprano]

Bit random, but is Tommy Talau still alive? Has not been mentioned once by the club in 6 months. Yet, we seem to get updated whenever Doueihi uses the bathroom.

Seen him in media content on WT website. Just rehab with the injury happening so late into last season. Doubt we see him this year.

 

[tony soprano]

**Rothfield Warning** - Along those lines

On NRL360 on Monday Rothfield said Sheens told him something along the lines of - he realises we won't win the comp this year he just doesn't want to see us getting flogged

Probably just deflecting pressure on madge

 

[batboy]

And outside of Prince and Lui, we we’ve never had a game changing halfback

Craig Field
Ben Black
Ben Jeffries
Lincoln Withers
John Morris

Lui was a solid talent - Never really changed a game.

 

[batboy]

5 seasons that is worse than first thought
geez

No Mate... That's the bare bones of it...
Even out of that, Twice - we still didn't make the finals.
That's why I won't single out players for our teams form...

We've had much better players in the club over it's history than we have now, And despite their brilliance - We lost more games than we won - Most of the time...

Now all of a Sudden it's the halfback - Or the injury prone Hookers fault...
Benji and Robbie (Obviously better players) couldn't do it most of the time, with arguably better squads - Why?

 

[KH1988]

Probably just deflecting pressure on madge

Just speaking hypothetically - I wonder if the Dogs and the Tigers get off to a bad start - will both sides want to be the first to punt their coach if it means signing Ciraldo (for fear the other club will get him)

 

[batboy]

You always miss the point, its not about winning the comp with madden, its about realising the current general isn't up to it. If you can't see that Im so sorry las.

I didn't miss any point...
You certainly could use some work on your sarcasm detector however

 

[Devon Head]

Our defence must be our primary kpi for this season, Nofoaluma we are looking at you.

If defence concedes 20points a game instead of 30 without the attack even being any better or worse the team prob makes the 8. It's that simple.

 

[batboy]

We actually ranked 8th in attack last year but I can't remember how many times we were chasing points (Cowboys and Titans game spring to mind) because of our crappy defence.

For as long as I can remember our D has been a shambles, with last year being our worst on record. I don't know how some people can't identify this as our #1 problem

Imagine the Tigers had back rowers like Tallis and Carrol....
Or centres like Matai.
Crippling blokes that tried to take our edges.

Imagine we had an edge player like Luke Lewis the night he just terrorised Thurston....

..... Imagine!!

 

[Kelce68]

I just don’t understand why we always have players wanting out or being shopped around.
To me it seems this happens more often than any other club?

It's confirmation bias. We constantly think we're the victims of things in this league, myself included.

But the truth is this stuff happens everywhere, at every club, all the time.

 

[Garrry]

Just speaking hypothetically - I wonder if the Dogs and the Tigers get off to a bad start - will both sides want to be the first to punt their coach if it means signing Ciraldo (for fear the other club will get him)

If Ciraldo leaves Panthers, Gus will get him to the bulldog's.

 

[rihannafan1]

Just speaking hypothetically - I wonder if the Dogs and the Tigers get off to a bad start - will both sides want to be the first to punt their coach if it means signing Ciraldo (for fear the other club will get him)

Interesting. Probably not us because if we wanted Ciraldo we'd have sacked Maguire in the off-season. I understood that Ciraldo has been offered the position and then the board backflipped.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

No Mate... That's the bare bones of it...
Even out of that, Twice - we still didn't make the finals.
That's why I won't single out players for our teams form...

We've had much better players in the club over it's history than we have now, And despite their brilliance - We lost more games than we won - Most of the time...

Now all of a Sudden it's the halfback - Or the injury prone Hookers fault...
Benji and Robbie (Obviously better players) couldn't do it most of the time, with arguably better squads - Why?

Holiday culture .same as the titans . Even during our glory years , turning up on D was a choice it wasn’t compulsory , or always going to make a difference whether we won or lost , because of The skilled list .

Our culture sucked/sux , and the more we tried to fix that by implementing cultures that work in places like Melbourne , the worse our culture got . Because then it was confusion mixed in with a soft underbelly .
And too many guys here to play nrl , like Robbie said not here to play for the tigers .
We have to create/ foster a love of the club , which should lead to more wins .
Luke gives a toss . He’s there every time a team makes a break . Every time one of ours does .
But he’s not putting up back page articles or having his mates on 360 talk about how amazing he is , so eventually the narrative around him has skewed to what he doesn’t do so much , that no one ever notices the 90% of the time he does what he’s supposed to do . All of us sitting waiting for him to mess up .
We have all been manipulated by the fox media , even the guys who support him , like me .
To what agenda ? Honestly I think its either deflection from the heinous stuff teams like south’s and Cronulla get up to on the weekend , or , they want to take him away because he’s one of the rare 6 guys in the comp right now wio can actually play halfback .