Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Merlot said:
he had all the inside knowledge on the opposition
Click to expand...
There is a great interview of him talking about it and tells how Smith absolutely gave it to him before and after origin Smith was nasty and along the lines of do you think your better then me try to find the interview it's great
 
JC99 said:
Eh, Liddle does try to run but he normally picks bad times to do it. Too often does he run straight into the marker for a gain of about one metre.

A lot of young dummy halves realise once they get to the NRL they can't just run up the guts all the time and have to adjust accordingly. We can see Jake Simpkin going through the same thing at the moment
Click to expand...

100% his natural playing style has changed under Madge. People focus on the last few years.
Liddle was getting us excited about his potential because of his speed & darts out of dummy half not because he could make 30-40 tackles or pass the ball.

It's all about timing and using the natural instincts. Grant, Smith, Cook, Api and a few others still do it very well. They know when to target the A/B defenders at the ruck whilst having support plays ready to attack. The playing style for those guys hasn't changed since coming into grade. Step up is a component but coaching is a bigger impact just like halves & fullbacks.

If they are told to follow structured plays all the time rather than a coach use the strength of the players the players will follow what they are told and then won't use the instincts that got them into NRL in the 1st place which happens to alot of kids these days.
 
Mighty_Tiger said:
100% his natural playing style has changed under Madge. People focus on the last few years.
Liddle was getting us excited about his potential because of his speed & darts out of dummy half not because he could make 30-40 tackles or pass the ball.

It's all about timing and using the natural instincts. Grant, Smith, Cook, Api and a few others still do it very well. They know when to target the A/B defenders at the ruck whilst having support plays ready to attack. The playing style for those guys hasn't changed since coming into grade. Step up is a component but coaching is a bigger impact just like halves & fullbacks.

If they are told to follow structured plays all the time rather than a coach use the strength of the players the players will follow what they are told and then won't use the instincts that got them into NRL in the 1st place which happens to alot of kids these days.
Click to expand...
Running from dummy half is well and good but the most important thing is getting good service to your forward and halves, particularly in the attacking zone, and that's where he struggles

His style has changed since he was a rookie for sure but that's because you can't just run all the time once you make it to the NRL. All the hookers you mention focus on good passing first and foremost. Same will happen with Simpkin, good young players adjust.

I also just think he's not a standout NRL player, quite simply just isn't good enough to look good. Bunch of injuries don't help either plus it's hard to run out of hooker in a team that's often well beaten
 
supercoach said:
That’s why we don’t play finals football. Lack of real quality in the backrow has been a major issue for a long time and I guess since Lawrence got injured you could say the same about the centre position
Click to expand...

It's certainly why we leak a gazillion points and our halves have no space....
Both are the most important defensive positions on the field.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Lui had superb hands, spatial awareness and also a tremendous pass. He was very strong and quick over the first few metres. There is a highlights reel putting I believe Eillis into space on the right hand side of the field. It was an amazing ball. He was a special talent and it is very sad how his career ended in the NRL.

Click to expand...
I liked Lui as well. Had all the skills and could have been anything… shame he f’d it all up.
gee, I miss Gareth though…..
 
Tiger Tarl said:
I honestly never saw the worship around Cam Smith. Spent his while career under Bellyache surrounded by some of the best players in the game (Cronk, Slater, plus all their monster forwards) and Robbie's stats per game consistently beat Smith's.

Longevity and leadership is definitely a factor and I think a healthy dose of media and NRL bias (diamond ring for the missus), but just watching him play for over a decade I would not put him up there with the Immortals. Hall of fame, sure, but Immortal, no way.

If he had played in a team with an average coach and the average players around him, I think he would have still been good but not as lauded as he is. Plus there's plenty of dodgy stuff he's been involved with that his supporters seem to turn a blind eye on. He's like the Trump, who is a convicted Rapist and Felon of the NRL. 😉

Anyway, just wanted to get that off my chest. Rant over.
Click to expand...
He won’t just be an immortal, he is the top of the tree.
 
dazza65 said:
I liked Lui as well. Had all the skills and could have been anything… shame he f’d it all up.
gee, I miss Gareth though…..
Click to expand...
That video is depressing wow the skill and speed using the full field with passing and stripping numbers in attack Sheen's style is amazing reminder of Ricky Stuart's passing at the Raiders when they use to strip numbers and use the full field to attack

Sheens can coach
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 520 (members: 37, guests: 483)
Back
Top