Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Mighty_Tiger said:
Out of the list of kids Simpkin was wanted up in QLD, it was us or Brisbane from memory.
Madge convinced him to come to us after his interstate trip.
As to the rest we don't have much at all to get excited about junior talent wise for a while at best.
Unless we buy our dry spell is going to last for a while. Papa & Api won't save us themseleves.
Click to expand...
I agree we need to go and spend money to get us some wins and leadership.. Look at Dogs and Sharks for example.. I don't even care if its overs for the right players
 
Needaname said:
No mate not at all.
Click to expand...
Mighty_Tiger said:
Out of the list of kids Simpkin was wanted up in QLD, it was us or Brisbane from memory.
Madge convinced him to come to us after his interstate trip.
As to the rest we don't have much at all to get excited about junior talent wise for a while at best.
Unless we buy our dry spell is going to last for a while. Papa & Api won't save us themseleves.
Click to expand...
I’d love for you to be right, but they chose to retain his mate Cory Paix who is slightly older but playing half back at the time and had the plan to turn him into a hooker. If they wanted to keep him they wouldn’t of retained Paix first.
 
Needaname said:
I’d love for you to be right, but they chose to retain his mate Cory Paix who is slightly older but playing half back at the time and had the plan to turn him into a hooker. If they wanted to keep him they wouldn’t of retained Paix first.
Click to expand...

Needaname said:
I think you’ll find that the talent is not as great as people want to believe it is. We got the Compton brothers unwanted by dogs. Ogden unwanted by warriors. Dillon unwanted by Bulldogs. Cini unwanted by panthers and dogs. Hoffman and Simpkin unwanted by Brisbane. Simpkins unwanted by North Queensland.
There’s plenty more I could go on even our First graders we’ve signed were unwanted by their former clubs.
It’s a hadge padge mix of misfits and outcasts and Madge is out there trying to be Craig Bellamy turning all these rocks into Diamonds because quite simply
No one worthy wants to play for the tigers.
Well at least until one of our recent two signings in Papali’i.
Before him when did you ever hear we outbid a club for a talented youngster? Or picked up a first grader even by way of choice?
Click to expand...

AJ Kepoa and Shawn Blore were two other discards that we signed.

However, not all our youngsters were unwanted by their former club eg Utoikamanu, Madden, Fonua Pole and Josh Feledy.
 
TieDye said:
Arguably Finucane would’ve been a must get. Yet nobody listened, but he wasn’t coming?
Click to expand...

My personal opinion is that Finucane is massively overrated and I like him as a player. He is a middle forward and should be judged on his ability in that role.
 
finnzo said:
Yeah

Yeah sharkies are really regretting signing him
Click to expand...

Let's wait and see. I reckon it's a dud signing. Time will tell but I'm making the call now he is a dud signing.

They are paying him as a premium middle forward for 4 years. He ain't that good now and he isn't going to improve.

Lastly he is a good player. At the moment I view him as being on Brooks salary and he ain't the guy to win you the game when it's on the line.
 
Mighty_Tiger said:
This 100%. We apparently went a junior path what 4yrs ago?
Our reserve grade team is terrible and well we have zero options to promote for a rookie year this season currently. That says it all.

Think Seyfarth and maybe Simpkin I guess are the only ones that have come through the reggie rank into NRL so far.
Click to expand...
Tuilagi looks a first grader and he’s gone. Seriously the club would ruin a chook raffle.
 
Earl said:
Let's wait and see. I reckon it's a dud signing. Time will tell but I'm making the call now he is a dud signing.

They are paying him as a premium middle forward for 4 years. He ain't that good now and he isn't going to improve.

Lastly he is a good player. At the moment I view him as being on Brooks salary and he ain't the guy to win you the game when it's on the line.
Click to expand...
I understand what your saying but I think most his work is done from Monday to Friday teaching the young blokes what it takes to be a first grade nrl player at the elite level making sure no 1 is taking short cuts at training and been a great leader in general some we are desperate for
 
isaaktigers said:
I think reading half the crap people put in here shows how crap Wests Tigers and some of their supporters are.

People wanting to sign Andrew Fifita, Sean Keppie and Jack sloth Gosiewski…

Just shows how out of touch half of you are on here, wanting to get rid of crap… for crap?

Crazzzzzy
Click to expand...

Flanno was saying had a recruitment policy wouldn't recruit unless they had potential to be a rep player.

We definitely not doing that
 
finnzo said:
I understand what your saying but I think most his work is done from Monday to Friday teaching the young blokes what it takes to be a first grade nrl player at the elite level making sure no 1 is taking short cuts at training and been a great leader in general some we are desperate for
Click to expand...

This doesn't cut it to me. You pay for on field performances. I don't think professional sportsman need guidance like that or better put guidance like that on your cap. That is a coaching issue if it isn't a personal issue.

I really like Finucane as a player as well. He is good. I'd love him here.
 
Last edited:
Earl said:
This doesn't cut it to me. You pay for on field performances. I don't think professional sportsman need guidance like that or better put guidance like that on your cap. That is a coaching issue if it isn't a personal issue.

I really like Finucane as a player as well. He is good. I've love him here.
Click to expand...
I’m not sure I feel like it’s different when people who are actually on the field with you and training with you are teaching you things your more likely to listen to them then a coach since there actually there going through it all with them. Stefano said when he went to origin camp he got so much out of seeing how dale prepares for a game then came back and killed it for the rest of the year players like dale influence players around them for the better and no he won’t be the player he is now in 3 years but he will still be there leader he’s is
 
jadtiger said:
For 2 years he would have been a good signing for 4 years i feel he will probably be a poor signing and he signed for 4
Click to expand...
He’ll go out injured and insured…
It’s a smart signing - sign him for 4 years knowing he won’t see them out.
It’s cheating - but they’ll get away with it.

Same as Parra signing Watmough for 4 years with 300 games behind him… was never going to see the end of it. On the back of Watmough - they signed Foran and a bunch of others…
Went from wooden spooners to something with more upside.
 
Earl said:
Let's wait and see. I reckon it's a dud signing. Time will tell but I'm making the call now he is a dud signing.

They are paying him as a premium middle forward for 4 years. He ain't that good now and he isn't going to improve.

Lastly he is a good player. At the moment I view him as being on Brooks salary and he ain't the guy to win you the game when it's on the line.
Click to expand...
Happy to swap Twal with him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

... and 11 more.
Total: 547 (members: 61, guests: 486)
Back
Top