Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[hank37w]

Josh McGuire. Watch him this weekend. Just carting it up the middle and whacking blokes in defence. Off contract at the end of this year. Sign him for 1 + CO

Haven't watched him play for a while (probably because he always seems to be suspended)

Is he still a dopey grub?

 

[Camel2281]

Haven't watched him play for a while (probably because he always seems to be suspended)

Is he still a dopey grub?

Most definitely still is. I can't stand the bloke

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Exactly. Munster is still at Melbourne on $1mill in 2023. He's not available until after Brooks's contract is finished

so is Douhie by end of 2023 isn't he

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

I don’t think anyone sits here and thinks Brooks is a million dollar player.
Just coz he is earning that in his final year doesn’t mean it’s his target salary.
The back pay has inflated things, but the tigers have not signed him on a mill dollar contract like a Tamaulolo or Tedesco.

Brooks was on 550k I think first year of contract

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

so is Douhie by end of 2023 isn't he

both gone, cmon down Munster

 

[Camel2281]

Brooks was on 550k I think first year of contract

That was the contract prior to the one he is currently on. He got a massive increase

 

[Camel2281]

both gone, cmon down Munster

I'd keep AD as a centre. Bloke is also the sort of personality you want in the footy club

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

That was the contract prior to the one he is currently on. He got a massive increase

certainly not 1 million a year though

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

expensive as a centre though
but good personality
just hope he nails a position otherwise he becomes a Mmbye utility value
good at a number of positions but not worth the $ as a utility

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

That was the contract prior to the one he is currently on. He got a massive increase

Over the course of his contract it's about 600k-650k from what was reported initially.

It's because it was backloaded due to the dodge contracts of Mbye, Reynolds, Packer, Mats etc that people now arc up at him being $1mil, when it's actually not what he is on year to year for his contract.

AD based on media reports is on 650k this year, considering we signed him from basically reserve grade & he hasn't cemented a position + missed a heap of games - I would say he is on way overs currently as well.

 

[Camel2281]

Over the course of his contract it's about 600k-650k from what was reported initially.

It's because it was backloaded due to the dodge contracts of Mbye, Reynolds, Packer, Mats etc that people now arc up at him being $1mil, when it's actually not what he is on year to year for his contract.

AD based on media reports is on 650k this year, considering we signed him from basically reserve grade & he hasn't cemented a position + missed a heap of games - I would say he is on way overs currently as well.

AD was our best player last year. Had double the try involvements that Brooks did in less games played.

He also played plenty of first grade for Souths prior to coming to us. He was first choice fullback for them prior to the signing of Latrell

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Over the course of his contract it's about 600k-650k from what was reported initially.

It's because it was backloaded due to the dodge contracts of Mbye, Reynolds, Packer, Mats etc that people now arc up at him being $1mil, when it's actually not what he is on year to year for his contract.

AD based on media reports is on 650k this year, considering we signed him from basically reserve grade & he hasn't cemented a position + missed a heap of games - I would say he is on way overs currently as well.

if AD doesn't cement a spot he ends up in Mmbye utility class and overs
for 650k or more at centre would rather Katoni Staggs

 

[sparci]

Forget about dillon, he is gone, won’t play many games here again, I’m hearing mr Mac has been ringing around player managers telling them there players should look elsewhere, he’s one, Simpkin and talau are others along with the back rower Simpkins. There is more to come. Don’t shoot the messenger.

thats poor treatment of a couple of the younger players particularly dillon and simpkin. dude seems to have it in for certain players

 

[Viking Warrior]

if AD doesn't cement a spot he ends up in Mmbye utility class and overs
for 650k or more at centre would rather Katoni Staggs

Ad is class mate he is always one of our best wherever he plays but he has the potential to be a great 6

 

[Camel2281]

Ad is class mate he is always one of our best wherever he plays but he has the potential to be a great 6

Plus he's still a pup. Only 23

 

[old_man_tiger]

Tommy Turbo would be my "anyone, in any position at any price"

Munster looks like a better barber, key to attracting other players to WT

 

[cktiger]

Over the course of his contract it's about 600k-650k from what was reported initially.

It's because it was backloaded due to the dodge contracts of Mbye, Reynolds, Packer, Mats etc that people now arc up at him being $1mil, when it's actually not what he is on year to year for his contract.

AD based on media reports is on 650k this year, considering we signed him from basically reserve grade & he hasn't cemented a position + missed a heap of games - I would say he is on way overs currently as well.

Seeing he was our best player by a country mile last year he’s ok compared to what we were paying Mbye and Brooks.

 

[BAGNF05]

Seeing he was our best player by a country mile last year he’s ok compared to what we were paying Mbye and Brooks.

I think his point is he’s actually only on marginally more money than Douehi on a per year basis. Say what you like about Brooksy (thousands do) but you can’t dispute that he’s durable and he tries hard. By those metrics he’s been a far more valuable player than AD simply because AD is watching from the sideline.

 

[Blake]

Doueihi is a guy you want in the team, he cares and competes for everything, he makes others try harder.
He was safe at fullback but did not offer much in attack. He wasn't great at 5/8 but might be a fantastic 5/8 in a year or 2 with more experience playing at centre. At centre he also gives us a kick target on the right side.
He also offers a lot of versatility. If he starts at centre and you have a centre/2nd row type of player on the bench like Garner, the 2 of them cover an injury to 2nd row, centre, 6, 7 and 1

 

[izotope]

I love AD as much as the next bloke, but hypothetically if its Brooks/AD out and Munster in for 23 surely you take it.