Luke Brooks - Mega Thread

mike said:
AD will outplay Brooks every time. You only have to look at last season. Brooks isn’t even close. Sure he’s going OK this year but AD will go even better when he is back. AD has passion, leadership skills and the desire to win and be the best he can be and Brooks has none of these qualities. Brooks is a mouse by comparison. Brooks would do well at lock, letting others take the lead, playing a sweeping link role, which is really what he does now.
Click to expand...
No point debating it with these folks mate.
They've accepted mediocrity and Brooks is their hero.
 
mike said:
AD will outplay Brooks every time. You only have to look at last season. Brooks isn’t even close. Sure he’s going OK this year but AD will go even better when he is back. AD has passion, leadership skills and the desire to win and be the best he can be and Brooks has none of these qualities. Brooks is a mouse by comparison. Brooks would do well at lock, letting others take the lead, playing a sweeping link role, which is really what he does now.
Click to expand...
So you have a chrystal ball mate...how do you know in advance that he can even survive on the park after his injury...he was great in a very ordinary team last year if you think he is up to the Storm,Panthers level then your dreaming...he is a reasonable footballer,no more no less its up to him to prove himself...Brooks has had excuses and many changes during his career,AD has had it all given to him on a platter,you all knock Madge,but forget Madge bought him over here..so its up to AD that Madge made the right choice...
 
hobbo1 said:
Load of bollocks
Hastings has been directing the team and our pack has improved.
That’s been the difference
Our backline including brooks is still shit …
Brooks is a dumb player !
As for a sense of humour you need new material..
Click to expand...
I dont need anything but my opinion,who do you replace Brooks,Gildart,etc when we have no depth,and do you think constantly bagging Brooks will change Madges or the recruitments mind...Sheens put an end to the Brooks to Newcastle theory in one hit...he must know more than you or the other knockers or Brooks would be in Knights territory by now...
 
TrueTiger said:
So you have a chrystal ball mate...how do you know in advance that he can even survive on the park after his injury...he was great in a very ordinary team last year if you think he is up to the Storm,Panthers level then your dreaming...he is a reasonable footballer,no more no less its up to him to prove himself...Brooks has had excuses and many changes during his career,AD has had it all given to him on a platter,you all knock Madge,but forget Madge bought him over here..so its up to AD that Madge made the right choice...
Click to expand...
No crystal ball needed. You go on performance and every time AD plays he out performs Brooks. History tells us this.
 
TrueTiger said:
I dont need anything but my opinion,who do you replace Brooks,Gildart,etc when we have no depth,and do you think constantly bagging Brooks will change Madges or the recruitments mind...Sheens put an end to the Brooks to Newcastle theory in one hit...he must know more than you or the other knockers or Brooks would be in Knights territory by now...
Click to expand...
Surely you should know by now that with certain people only their opinions count.
 
TrueTiger said:
I dont need anything but my opinion,who do you replace Brooks,Gildart,etc when we have no depth,and do you think constantly bagging Brooks will change Madges or the recruitments mind...Sheens put an end to the Brooks to Newcastle theory in one hit...he must know more than you or the other knockers or Brooks would be in Knights territory by now...
Click to expand...
Sheens lol
He still can’t lower his office chair.

You just love seeing the team drown in mediocrity by supporting a player who’s so bad even after 180 games .. it really is that simple!

And as I said the other day … give Madden 50 games and he’d be ahead of where Brooks is now and he’d be on 1/3 the coin as well .
 
batboy said:
Love you Bro, But that's just not true....
He's about the only one that looks likely in forever.
Our forwards, Second Rowers and Centres (The position we fail to acknowledge to even exist)
Have had nothing for years...

Yeah - It might be seen to be his job to put a boot in their arse,
- There's only so long you can bark at sticks.
I remember him giving Adam Blair a spray at LO as an 18-19 year old...

He's playing well atm, As good if not better than any 5/8 we've had in the last 10 years....
Happy to roll with it.

AD will get a spot somewhere... Could really do a job at centre,
Even with the ball heading out to Peachey on the weekend looked likely at times on the WE.
Click to expand...
There’s only so long you can bark at Sticks 😂 love it! Not even good for firewood this lot.
 
BAGNF05 said:
He puts plenty of kicks in the right areas. Just a shame we have lazy and miniature outside backs who couldn’t catch the delta strain.
Click to expand...
A few good plays every few games don’t cut it ..
he’s diabolically inconsistent.
Punt 🥾
 
BAGNF05 said:
Hard to soar like an eagle when flying with turkeys
Click to expand...
Makes me laugh … when our pack don’t perform our million dollar marquee player can’t lift the team and when our pack does perform he’s still shit .. Don’t get sucked into the Luke Brooks Mickey Mouse fan club mate .. you’re better than that .
 
hobbo1 said:
Makes me laugh … when our pack don’t perform our million dollar marquee player can’t lift the team and when our pack does perform he’s still shit .. Don’t get sucked into the Luke Brooks Mickey Mouse fan club mate .. you’re better than that .
Click to expand...
As I’ve said numerous times, he’s got a lot of deficiencies in his game. Hastings has come in and proved that. But imo our problems don’t start with Luke Brooks. He’s a way more talented player than 90% of the wood ducks Pascoe brought to this club.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 335 (members: 16, guests: 319)
Back
Top