Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

TrueTiger said:
Cool it a bit guys both your input have valid points,its a discussion,no need to make it personal name calling....
Lui was very good for us and may not have been the standout he should have been because of Farah and Marshall ruling the roost...
The same can be said about Luke Brooks,a halfback sensation with hype,but maybe should have been given the opportunity earlier on to explore how well he could have been as a running 5/8,however Benji had that position tied up...
I still think Jacko/Luke combo as it is will get better,dont forget Hastings missed 3 games,thats 3 games he and Brooks didnt get to gel and get used to each other....
Click to expand...
Sorry old mate history doesnt agree with you. Brooks was given the "keys" without Farah & whoever else Jason Taylor told you to blame . While I genuinely like Luke brooks at 6 he cant run a chook raffle let alone direct a team. Thats not a criticism of him ,he has other skills but doesnt have that ability. BTW The Im really sick of the Farah bashing/scape goat crap. Look at his carreer stats, he beats Cameron Smith in most of them. If Farah had played for Melbourne , he would be crowned as the best hooker ever to play the game. Stop listening to fools like Talyor . The way he sabotaged the talent we had coming through & set our club back a generation ,no true tiger fan should ever be believing any crap from his mouth. He was & is a stain on our game.
 
Champ1 said:
Sorry old mate history doesnt agree with you. Brooks was given the "keys" without Farah & whoever else Jason Taylor told you to blame . While I genuinely like Luke brooks at 6 he cant run a chook raffle let alone direct a team. Thats not a criticism of him ,he has other skills but doesnt have that ability. BTW The Im really sick of the Farah bashing/scape goat crap. Look at his carreer stats, he beats Cameron Smith in most of them. If Farah had played for Melbourne , he would be crowned as the best hooker ever to play the game. Stop listening to fools like Talyor . The way he sabotaged the talent we had coming through & set our club back a generation ,no true tiger fan should ever be believing any crap from his mouth. He was & is a stain on our game.
Click to expand...
Not a fan of Taylors....Farah and Benji dominated the WTs teams for years and Brooks was a kid coming up...if he was left to do a job and with some guidence he may have been able to be a very good running 5/8...but he was marked as a 7 and that was the future,funny how Moses was the 5/8 now at EEls he is a great 7...there are many fors and against ,in my opinion Brooks should have been given the opportunity to play 6 and Moses 7 when they both were in grade together,but everyone settled on the other way......and where has that got us....
 
TrueTiger said:
Not a fan of Taylors....Farah and Benji dominated the WTs teams for years and Brooks was a kid coming up...if he was left to do a job and with some guidence he may have been able to be a very good running 5/8...but he was marked as a 7 and that was the future,funny how Moses was the 5/8 now at EEls he is a great 7...there are many fors and against ,in my opinion Brooks should have been given the opportunity to play 6 and Moses 7 when they both were in grade together,but everyone settled on the other way......and where has that got us....
Click to expand...
Do you remember Moses game at fullback when big Keith got his 4 tries I always thought that if Tedesco left Moses might end up there
 
Odessa said:
Do you remember Moses game at fullback when big Keith got his 4 tries I always thought that if Tedesco left Moses might end up there
Click to expand...
Yeah I do recall it but I always thought that Moses and Brooks would be the halves pairing,and that did happen but they should have been given the chance to swap roles and see how it went,but then the crap hit the fan,Ted,Moses went and Brooks ended up having to be the main man at halfback with the club legend dominating that role,,,,
 
Hoping for some good news about Chrichton and Dykes this week. Tigers seriously need some positivity after tonight.

Also unless you are Tim Sheens or Madge why are you posting signing info and rumours on a fan forum - that's just weird?

From now on only those two people can post signing info otherwise people will just be cringe and repost paper articles for us zoomers who aren't engaged with media who care about the team and like seeing updates.
 
TrueTiger said:
Not a fan of Taylors....Farah and Benji dominated the WTs teams for years and Brooks was a kid coming up...if he was left to do a job and with some guidence he may have been able to be a very good running 5/8...but he was marked as a 7 and that was the future,funny how Moses was the 5/8 now at EEls he is a great 7...there are many fors and against ,in my opinion Brooks should have been given the opportunity to play 6 and Moses 7 when they both were in grade together,but everyone settled on the other way......and where has that got us....
Click to expand...
Brooks is a good running 5/8. Moses always was a good organizing 7. Both forced to play roles that was better suited to the other by a coach that didnt know his #ss from his elbow. I could not agree with you more on that point. But not Farahs or Benjis fault.
 
Wokk_ said:
Hoping for some good news about Chrichton and Dykes this week. Tigers seriously need some positivity after tonight.

Also unless you are Tim Sheens or Madge why are you posting signing info and rumours on a fan forum - that's just weird?

From now on only those two people can post signing info otherwise people will just be cringe and repost paper articles for us zoomers who aren't engaged with media who care about the team and like seeing updates.
Click to expand...
Tapine probably played himself back into rickys good books today too 😩
 
Pretty slim pickings out there, we need quality depth signings for next season as well as 1 or 2 guns. Picking through the carcas of the Bulldogs is about as good as it seems it will get for us 😢
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 867 (members: 32, guests: 835)
Back
Top