I've been a Brooks defender all the way through.
I've even jumped in and defended Paws when he was being bashed re Brooks.
I'm not a Brooks defender anymore.
I'm now convinced Brooks will never be any better than he is now [and that isn't good enough] as to me it seems he crashes under pressure which results in him making stupid decisions in so many ways which stuffs our attack.
Defensively he is good and doesnt shirk his responsibility as he is a tough little bugger, but I guess it doesn't take much to work out what an effective tackle will be.
I'd love to see him go to the Storm to see if Bellamy can do anything with him, but I doubt it as he has been playing the game his way for too long, and we know what we say about old dogs.