If he had any sense, he'd realise how stale he is at the Tigers and try to make something on his fading career.
It's the best for him, professionally to just find a new club.
Financially ? Yeah keep robbing us.... 🤣
Luke Brooks - Mega Thread
- Thread starter The_Patriot
- Start date
It's the best for him, professionally to just find a new club.
Financially ? Yeah keep robbing us.... 🤣
pawsandclaws1
Well-known member
Brooks transfer to Hull KR or was it Hull FC?
"Swap" deal between Brooks/Klemmer
Mmm the shrill whining of desperation.
Trust in the process, let Sheens, Marshall and Farah resolve it. I am comfortable with this outcome. Why aren't you?
I don't know...
Seems like any talks of Brooks leaving gives the fans some hope and excitement for the future.
pawsandclaws1
Well-known member
Let Sheens, Marshall and Farah resolve it. They are the coaches and know their football.
There's still hope Shifty Sheens has something in the mix.
I love the off season...
Always eventful.
pawsandclaws1
Well-known member
I trust in Sheens and will be okay with what he decides. That is a fair position and all this aggravation directed at those who stand by that process is unnecessary.
earl
Well-known member
It's been boring for a long time. Every freaken topic is about Brooks.
The SHADOW
Well-known member
Newcastle will regret 2023 if they don’t sign Luke Brooks.
If the coach of Newcastle can’t make it happen he is gone.
Klemmer swap deal or not.
Klemmer is definitely not in their plans.
Adam O big decision. Good luck.
Just put it to Bedsy.
If the coach of Newcastle can’t make it happen he is gone.
Klemmer swap deal or not.
Klemmer is definitely not in their plans.
Adam O big decision. Good luck.
Just put it to Bedsy.
trentrunciman
Well-known member
I can’t see Brooks’ career taking off anywhere to be honest.
I’ve always said his temperament isn’t what I’d want from a half back. The leader of the team. Not that introverts can’t be leaders but it doesn’t seem like he communicates on or off the pitch at all.
I listen and analyse a lot of his interviews etc and he seems aloof / unassertive.
He can thrive I think with a 6 I think like Mitch Moses / Munster who talk a lot more and lead
I’ve always said his temperament isn’t what I’d want from a half back. The leader of the team. Not that introverts can’t be leaders but it doesn’t seem like he communicates on or off the pitch at all.
I listen and analyse a lot of his interviews etc and he seems aloof / unassertive.
He can thrive I think with a 6 I think like Mitch Moses / Munster who talk a lot more and lead
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
Amazing. The same people complaining about not supporting Sheens are the very same people who spent three and a half years with their head up their ass, blaming the coach for all the teams problems, making up lies and pretending the club hadn't been shit for 11 years.
I think most people do support Sheens and Benji but that doesn't mean you can't criticise the club and have to act like a pathetic sycophant.
I think most people do support Sheens and Benji but that doesn't mean you can't criticise the club and have to act like a pathetic sycophant.
Last edited:
C
Cobarcats
Guest
I've always said that if Brooks was a hooker from juniors all the way through to the NRL he would be as good as Cook.
Brooks is quick and can tackle and is fit enough to follow the ruck around for 80min.
Also gives you another kicking option from dummy half just like Robbie provided.
innsaneink
Well-known member
Yeh this is what gets me
What a remarkable dedication the West's Tigers, as an employer have shown to such an underperforming employee.
The amount of time you spend bagging him on here, I'm surprised you have much time time to talk to anyone about anything...
Your "Play finals footy" Is really all you've got isn't it?
The club and the squad have been the problem,
Not the just halfback.... He's a decent player - in a less than decent side...
It's all good though bro - Surely there's a few kids in juniors you follow on instagram that will automatically solve all the problems?
pawsandclaws1
Well-known member
So what is the news about the Dogs wanting Klemmer? I read on here he was already spoken for in the Klemmer/Brooks swap?😀
The SHADOW
Well-known member
Natural home coming is on the cards and Parramatta want him to. The dogs are stuck with both the salary cap and coaching role dilemmas , Parramatta are looking to replace IPaps
Defensive bunch, arent yas?
I could argue he's the worst player in a less than decent side.
It's all opinion.
You are fighting a losing battle.
And perhaps so am I...
But the results speak for themselves.
The SHADOW
Well-known member
Parramatta can’t get Marty or Klemmer . The coach is also under heat to break their premiership drought from now till GF day. Window is shut after that , very bleak future. Now or never for the whole lot of them. No wonder M Moses is holding out to commit, he wants to see how the season pans out and possibly who could be the new coach.You can never say never with Parramatta.
When’s the Parramatta AGM held does any one know ? Lucky them they get to vote.
When’s the Parramatta AGM held does any one know ? Lucky them they get to vote.
My observations are same. You can tell from any media interviews that he is not a talker,a bit reserved and seems a bit dopey,lacks confidence.
People acting like Sheens is infallible too... some of the teams he used to pick were ridiculous. Danny Galea and Bronson Harrison as our props? Fitzhenry ... Shannon McDonnell ... Matt Groat. Ruined Moltzen's career by turning a great young Aus schoolboy half into a failed fullback.
Sheens has a load of footy knowledge, but he's not perfect and is wrong as often as he is right.
In any case, Brooks has been a proven failure for 9 years. He's not going to magically come good in his 10th at 28-29 years old.
Sheens has a load of footy knowledge, but he's not perfect and is wrong as often as he is right.
In any case, Brooks has been a proven failure for 9 years. He's not going to magically come good in his 10th at 28-29 years old.
