Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tony soprano]

There's a lot of pros to Brooks leaving both for him and the club.

It's been spoken in depth on the forum and by everyone in the media.

Cons? There isn't as many, imo.

But Newcastle have a shit coach and team.

I'd be aiming higher potential walking into another WT

 

[Tito Santana]

Gildart gone - how good! Getting rid of Maguires mundane shit. The more I think about it, the happier I am he is gone.

For too long we kept signing depth players to be reserves for our starting team - also depth players.

Not genius - Sheenius!

 

[tony soprano]

Gildart gone - how good! Getting rid of Maguires mundane shit. The more I think about it, the happier I am he is gone.

For too long we kept signing depth players to be reserves for our starting team - also depth players.

Not genius - Sheenius!

But everyone too happy to bag him

 

[240z]

Both of those excellent tackles were achievable due to his superior speed, thus proving the other guys point.

I think it shows both speed and tackling ability. Not much point getting there if you can't make the tackle

 

[Stevec]

Gildardt if you release a player who has a 2 year contract 2022/2023 don't you have to pay him out unless he asks for release or lands a new contract of equal or higher value ?

 

[KingRobbie]

How far off FG you reckon? One season? Two?

Matamua turned 19 this year and played a bit of first grade.

Feledy turns 19 in 2023, so maybe he’ll be the same?

If not, he’ll debut in 2024.

 

[KingRobbie]

Do you remember was Chris Lawrence 17 or 18 when he started in first grade?

He was 17 when he made his debut and turned 18 later that year.

Feledy would be one year older if he debuted in 2023.

 

[tigerman 0]

Is he ready?

 

[cktiger]

Do you know why the reserves are magpies. Its because wests tigers was setup as a joint venture between 2 foundation clubs, It was not a merger as some on here seem to think. One of the stipulations of the joint venture was that both foundation clubs would keep a presence in the next tier down from NRL in order to keep their heritage and to avoid either club dying off and they would also keep and fund their own juniors. Balmain also had a presence in the NSW cup as Balmain Ryde Eastwood until they went belly up.

Where’s the Balmain reserve grade side then?

 

[tony soprano]

Matamua turned 19 this year and played a bit of first grade.

Feledy turns 19 in 2023, so maybe he’ll be the same?

If not, he’ll debut in 2024.

Only seen the highlights of feledy but seems a tad in the small side. Will probably need a season or two to develop.

 

[Tito Santana]

But everyone too happy to bag him

People that don’t like Sheensy are #$$%heads

 

[cktiger]

lol Also forgot to mention sign a player from souths to play fullback, who it turns out can't play fullback and has to play 6

How about our most expensive player who turns out he can’t play 7… 🤣

 

[tony soprano]

People that don’t like Sheensy are dickheads

Agreed

 

[diedpretty]

Where’s the Balmain reserve grade side then?

They went broke and could no longer field a side. The only reason Balmain juniors still exist is because Wests Ashfield prop them up. Had they been financial they would still have had the option to field a team in NSWcup.

 

[Camel2281]

Odd considering the minimum wage is more than that....
And probably going up

It'd be a typo

 

[the_third]

Is minimum wage $120,000?

think it went to 200 under the new cap.

 

[KingRobbie]

Is he ready?

Not sure.

He’ll definitely train with first grade in the pre-season and like I said, I’d be surprised if he’s not one of our Development players.

He’ll get every chance to impress the coaching staff.

Not every kid is ready that young though, so we’ll see.

 

[supercoach]

Granted a release by the Tigers, Gildart will begin negotiations immediately with the Dolphins with a view to inking a $100,000 deal to be part of history at the NRL’s 17th franchise.

The Dolphins expect to finalise the deal in the coming days ahead of a formal announcement next week. (Courier Mail)

If he is inking in a 100,000 deal with the Dolphins we are obviously topping that figure up. No one plays for 100g. Anyway vacant roster spots are like gold for us in the big rebuild

 

[diedpretty]

Imagine the feeling of disengagement when Wests Tigers sign a promising junior and he is shipped off to play with Western Suburbs Magpies? Or Balmain?
I could be wrong, but I’m convinced a pathway, or any succession plan, would become more established if it were seamless.

Imagine if he signed with Melbourne - he be sent to Qld 🙄

 

[Balmainian]

Any word on Bateman?