Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[liltiger]

$1.4m is the figure for Moses (apparently)

1.4 is way too much he's played one origin, hasn't won a comp if we can get Williams for 850 - 900k on a 3 yr deal we would be better served putting the extra money into a back for more depth

 

[coivtny]

I'd say that figure is the Bulldogs offer. (as they're ahead)

In that case I'd offer $1.5m and add a year. We're not going to sign the top guys unless we're the top bidder.

 

[SwervinMervin]

Balmain, Wests and the merger have a pretty good track record with English signings. Ellery, Garry Schofield, Andy Courier, Dave Bolton, Gareth Ellis, Lee Crooks, Brian Lockwood.
I reckon Bateman could be another and even better if Williams were to make the move as well.

 

[coivtny]

Balmain, Wests and the merger have a pretty good track record with English signings. Ellery, Garry Schofield, Andy Courier, Dave Bolton, Gareth Ellis, Lee Crooks, Brian Lockwood.
I reckon Bateman could be another and even better if Williams were to make the move as well.

Balmain particularly got great value from their English players. Who could forget the Lockwood / Pringle combination. Wests didn't do as well. Lee Crooks was probably their best, excluding Ellery who Balmain had first. I was a Wests fan BTW.

 

[SwervinMervin]

Balmain particularly got great value from their English players. Who could forget the Lockwood / Pringle combination. Wests didn't do as well. Lee Crooks was probably their best, excluding Ellery who Balmain had first. I was a Wests fan BTW.

I was a Balmain fan so wasn’t thrilled when Hanley and Schofield had a run at Wests. Both great players. Schofield was so pale white he was almost blue. I remember a cracking intercept he took at Leichhardt one Sunday arvo against Parra. Mick Cronin was about to put his winger away with a draw and short pass and next thing you see is Schofield haring off downfield and scoring. It took everyone a while to work out what had happened. Like a thief in the night. Perfectly read and timed.
Lee Crooks was your old school typical Pommy prop forward. Looked like he lived on pies and pints but tough and skillful.

 

[Hmm]

Everybody’s favourite player and future immortal Jordan Hill has returned from Cutters Colts team and is on a train and trial with the club

 

[gallagher]

Balmain particularly got great value from their English players. Who could forget the Lockwood / Pringle combination. Wests didn't do as well. Lee Crooks was probably their best, excluding Ellery who Balmain had first. I was a Wests fan BTW.

Harvey Howard went good too

 

[Le Tiger]

With salary cap increase top tier players will all be asking for 1 mil or more ,. DCE signed years ago for over a mil. It's a fact of life today, Williams is not top tier, Moses is.

1.4m in a proposed 12m cap is about 11-12% of your cap. A little overs but it checks out that your number 1 marquee player can take up at least 10% of your cap.

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

In that case I'd offer $1.5m and add a year. We're not going to sign the top guys unless we're the top bidder.

I reckon lay low for now, keep rumours in house, while still negotiating, keep clearing the decks, free up more room, accumulate the salaries. Once we’re comfortable then WT can make genuine offers to the players they believe need to fill a gap and be more approachable.

 

[AdelaideTiger]

$1.4m would be the upper limit for Munster, way too much for Moses. I wouldn't want to commit more than $1.1m for Moses, if that

 

[The Fresh Oil]

Can you imagine the scenes if someone told posters here 3 years ago that in 2023 we would be debating if Wests should offer Moses $1.1m or $1.4m a year to play at Wests. Crazy times.

 

[Devon Head]

If Williams is 750K and Moses is 1.4M, I'd be saving the 650K. That's another very good 2RF, when you upgrade from minimum wage 120K -> 770K.

(edit) If we can only have one

That 650k towards and elite FB and you suddenly have a spine that can win a comp.

 

[bptiger 0]

I'd say that figure is the Bulldogs offer. (as they're ahead)

I would not pay $1.4 million for Moses , would go to $900,000 maybe $1,000,000
Would chase Williams the pm 1/2 , better value at around $700,000

 

[coivtny]

$1.4m would be the upper limit for Munster, way too much for Moses. I wouldn't want to commit more than $1.1m for Moses, if that

In that case don't bother talking to him because you won't get him at that price.

 

[coivtny]

Harvey Howard went good too

You're right, I forgot about old Harvey.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

I would not pay $1.4 million for Moses , would go to $900,000 maybe $1,000,000
Would chase Williams the pm 1/2 , better value at around $700,000

Moses is definitely not a 1.4m player

 

[Devon Head]

Unfortunately 1.4M for the Tigers is about spot on to even get a look in and is about 1M to clubs like Roosters/Riff/Melb etc as they can sell success and winning culture
to a bloke. Tigers realistically can only offer a bloke a flash new COE, 7 home grounds and a sniff of being part of a team on the way up (albeit from dead last).

 

[The-moP]

View attachment 3288

Awwwww poor Tamou .. Having him (the Easter Island Statue) as player in our side, let alone being Capt .. he’s damn responsible for driving many WestsTigers supporters into a mental facility with drinking / popping pills addiction, with many others wanting to slit their wrists .. the guy was bloody awful .. to say the best about him .. !!

Thank God you’re gone .. 👍😃👍

 

[boonboon]

Moses cost all depends on where the cap lands. If it's 12m vs 9m previously then 1.4 is equivalent of 900k

 

[1eyedmel]

I would not pay $1.4 million for Moses , would go to $900,000 maybe $1,000,000
Would chase Williams the pm 1/2 , better value at around $700,000

The thing is Brooks is on the amount that you are suggesting we offer to Moses. Moses knows he is way better than him so it's just natural that he is going to want a lot more .