Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Camel2281]

Is there currently a reasonable replacement halfback/five eight available? I don't think so.

I'd wager there's plenty of young halves that given an opportunity would out perform Brooks

 

[Camel2281]

agreed. him or Dean Hawkins would be a decent acquisition to be our backup half.

Taaffe, Hawkins, Kurt Falls, Jonah Pezet. There's plenty of young blokes who could be great first grade halfbacks given the opportunity

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Taaffe, Hawkins, Kurt Falls, Jonah Pezet. There's plenty of young blokes who could be great first grade halfbacks given the opportunity

with Brooks as the 6 sure...

 

[tiger_scott]

Pezet has been groomed by Melbourne, doubt they would let him go without a fight. I think his old man played for the Knights? Surely they would have sounded him out about a potentially "homecoming" before chasing Brooks/Hastings. He does have big wraps on him!

 

[sleeve]

I'd wager there's plenty of young halves that given an opportunity would out perform Brooks

If there were plenty of halves around that would outperform Brooks, why did Newcastle sign a slow Hastings ?

 

[Camel2281]

with Brooks as the 6 sure...

Brooks or AD. Whoever is playing the better footy. I don't mind Brooks at 6 as a secondary playmaker on appropriate wages for his output.

I just despise seeing him stink up the joint and destroy us as 7 and being the highest paid by miles

 

[Camel2281]

If there were plenty of halves around that would outperform Brooks, why did Newcastle sign a slow Hastings ?

Because Hastings outperformed Brooks last year

 

[bptiger 0]

I'd wager there's plenty of young halves that given an opportunity would out perform Brooks

Rubbish , u think that some wet behind the ears rookie will come in and run a 1st grade side , I don’t think so . Take madden who every one thought was great , he did bugger all

 

[sleeve]

Because Hastings outperformed Brooks last year

Yeah, that makes sense, after chasing Brooks, without success.

 

[Camel2281]

Rubbish , u think that some wet behind the ears rookie will come in and run a 1st grade side , I don’t think so . Take madden who every one thought was great , he did bugger all

I do. Because Brooks has never controlled a first grade side in 180 games. Brooks has some useful attributes. However, decision making, communication and steering a team around the park are things he's never ever done

 

[Camel2281]

Yeah, that makes sense, after chasing Brooks, without success.

They chased Brooks before the 22 season before Hastings had started playing again. After the 22 season they signed Hastings within a few weeks

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Brooks or AD. Whoever is playing the better footy. I don't mind Brooks at 6 as a secondary playmaker on appropriate wages for his output.

I just despise seeing him stink up the joint and destroy us as 7 and being the highest paid by miles

don't think 2024 and beyond if he is here he will be on anywhere near what he is on in 2023

 

[SeanT]

Truly a great player.

Remember that steal he did on Ben Murdoch masila that time? Classic 😂😂

 

[Hmm]

Pezet has been groomed by Melbourne, doubt they would let him go without a fight. I think his old man played for the Knights? Surely they would have sounded him out about a potentially "homecoming" before chasing Brooks/Hastings. He does have big wraps on him!

Melbourne shouldn’t be grooming children that’s illegal

 

[sleeve]

They chased Brooks before the 22 season before Hastings had started playing again. After the 22 season they signed Hastings within a few weeks

You are changing the truth, to suit your narrative, Hastings was told he was not considered to be in the halves, and the Tigers thought Brooks was superior. Brooks was not leaving, as second choice they went for Hastings, twist it anyway you want, but those are the facts. If hastings is still playing in the halve in 2024 i will be surprised.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

Vitamin B and anti stress pills Batboy. Suggest you take a few before you have a heart attack.

Rubbish , u think that some wet behind the ears rookie will come in and run a 1st grade side , I don’t think so . Take madden who every one thought was great , he did bugger all

He did as much if not more than brooksy.

 

[weststigerman]

Yeah, that makes sense, after chasing Brooks, without success.

They wanted WT to chip in for Brooks. They were happy to pay full freight for Hastings.

 

[Garrry]

Rubbish , u think that some wet behind the ears rookie will come in and run a 1st grade side , I don’t think so . Take madden who every one thought was great , he did bugger all

I remember when Madden left Newcastle for the Wests Tigers Andrew Johns was not happy, why didn't Johns want him back now he's contract has expired?????

 

[sleeve]

They wanted WT to chip in for Brooks. They were happy to pay full freight for Hastings.

The money they paid for Hastings was rediculous, so was the signing. Hastings is a good footballer , but not a half. How do you know WT was asked to chip in anything, it's all in your imagination.
Sheens said a long time before hastings left,- Brooks is not going anywhere!
This is all rubbish, that's been covered more times then Pamela Anderson, give it a rest.

 

[Buttface]

He did as much if not more than brooksy.

Yeah, nah.