Brent Naden #256

Halbrowne61 said:
Seems that your opinion , in this case is invalid, as he’s taken an early plea and is out for 3 games. Big price for the club to pay for an ill timed and uncecessary “tackle”. Maybe he can reflect on that !!!
Click to expand...
wow, not just wrong but 'invalid' - ok...
My point is not that the tackle wasn;t a bad one, it quite obviously was - the 3 weeks is a fair enough penalty, probably even valid, and the decision to accept it is quite an obvious one.
My point was that he didn;t intentionally go in for a shoulder charge - the last minute contact on his legs turned what would have probably been a good aggressive hit into a reckless, chargeable mess.
Anyway, I'm still enjoying the afterglow of a good win - hope you are too 🙂
 
softlaw said:
wow, not just wrong but 'invalid' - ok...
My point is not that the tackle wasn;t a bad one, it quite obviously was - the 3 weeks is a fair enough penalty, probably even valid, and the decision to accept it is quite an obvious one.
My point was that he didn;t intentionally go in for a shoulder charge - the last minute contact on his legs turned what would have probably been a good aggressive hit into a reckless, chargeable mess.
Anyway, I'm still enjoying the afterglow of a good win - hope you are too 🙂
Click to expand...
Me too S, wasn’t trying to rip your head off, just thought invalid was the appropriate word.
Whether it was accidental or intentional a moot point. He’s out and we move forward.
Yes, I’m still wrapped in the afterglow of a hard fought win, exactly what I’ve been waiting for.
Now let’s repeat next Sunday.
Come on Tigers !!
 
BAGNF05 said:
Coming back from injury he turns in a 2/10 performance , gets binned in a game we are controlling and then misses three weeks with suspension. Deadset when we interviewing prospects do we base it on how many times they say “yeah nah” ?

Wests are the worst judges of character going. If this Fulton bloke can judge personality better it’s a massive win.
Click to expand...
Would be interesting to hear how he judges the character of Josh Shuster.
 
I didn’t think he hit his head at all made contact with his shoulder, really don’t think it was worth 3 weeks
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moh
It's a bit over the top but why does he have to be such an idiot. He can play. He doesn't seem like a bad guy. He does stupid stuff on the field though.
 
It wasn’t his first offence which contributed to the three weeks.

I don’t think he made contact with the head but he didn’t use his arms at all.

His own fault.
 
WesternSuburbsBoy said:
Too many brain farts…. remember he clotheslined someone last year & got sent off & hit with a 4 week suspension
Click to expand...

Exactly. It's professional footy. You can't do that stuff.

I think it was @Halbrowne61 asked me why I like Joe O. Joe O is a professional in that he doesn't do dumb stuff. Sure he can make a mistake but plays like that lose you games.

I reckon Naden can play but he isn't performing as well as he can and he needs to tighten up his game.
 
He is a bit of liability, but has some talent. Really didn't like his game last week too many errors that would normally cost us. Opportunity for some one else to take his spot if they perform well.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 3,804 (members: 9, guests: 3,795)
Back
Top