Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Todd Packer said:
No we can't sign a player from ANOTHER club if we don't have a top 30 spot. A decent player isn't coming over on a train and trial contract.
You're talking about promoting from within which is totally different.
Click to expand...
I won't be holding my breathe for us to sign a player from another club equal to or better than Joff. If clearing space in the top 30 take a leaf out of Gus' book and "move on" two fringe players as he did a couple of weeks ago.

Happy to eat my words if we get an established first grade half or outside back in for the remainder of the year though... expect Atasi James to be promoted.
 
Tucker said:
You keep banging on about him being a prop.
All of his best footy last year was played at 13.
We are weak in this position.
Click to expand...

Actually, his best footy was when he finally moved to prop late in the year. He played well all year, but was clearly a front row type middle being used as a 13, and that proved correct when he went even better once moved to the front row. He is fine at lock of you want a 3rd front rower.
 
Wearyfan22 said:
I won't be holding my breathe for us to sign a player from another club equal to or better than Joff. If clearing space in the top 30 take a leaf out of Gus' book and "move on" two fringe players as he did a couple of weeks ago.

Happy to eat my words if we get an established first grade half or outside back in for the remainder of the year though... expect Atasi James to be promoted.
Click to expand...
James can play anyway he doesn't need joffa to go to do that.
We will be linking with Schuster you would think given the Fulton connection
 
Stevec said:
NRL 360 last night no more Kent but the ridicule continues as when discussing Tigers failed attempts at Munster ,Moses , Pearce and now Johnson as highly unlikely as he's happy and back home . Hooper said Tigers cant recruit these players as we are a laughing stock ! To hell with you hoops
Click to expand...
Don't trouble yourself with the rantings of morons and steer entirely clear of that show.
 
tigerap said:
I wish the club would explain this one to the fans and members…releasing Joe O and what do we get?…we have plenty of salary cap $$$…we get a roster spot for whom??….
Click to expand...
Don't worry, you'll get Lee on radio soon enough putting his foot in his mouth. If they have a deal in the works I'd prefer they keep it under wraps and I fully expect they do, targeting a back.

The plan is to bring Blore in and hope he is ready for the step up. His spot in KOE will be filled soon enough by someone showing promise in Flegg.

We've seen very recently a plan to target positions of need with our juniors and I think Joe leaving will allow us to do the same with our firsts squad.

Also pretty clear that most of Maguire's team don't fit the plans of the club. Joe, Ken, Hastings, Garner, that bench 9 with knee issues and a much lesser extent Freebairn, Dias all gone from last year's team. There's probably some others I've forgotten too.
 
Our best player last year was Hastings

Joffa looked good in an average team that got the wooden spoon

He’s not worth $450-$600k

Can’t wait to get rid of him.

He’s not a lock and he’s not a prop - he’s a benchy with no impact.

Once AD and Brooks follows we will finally be on the way up
 
WesternSuburbsBoy said:
My issue with offloading Joffa is why are we doing Parramatta favours when they've been screwing us for a decade? & why not try & get a player in return? He was also great for culture & a lot of the islander boys looked up to him.
Click to expand...
Clearing that contract IS doing us a favor...

Agreed re the islander kids...but some of them are ready now, and some really topliners will be soon.

Clearing that spot AND cap space is going to look great in a year's time.
 
king_sirro said:
Actually, his best footy was when he finally moved to prop late in the year. He played well all year, but was clearly a front row type middle being used as a 13, and that proved correct when he went even better once moved to the front row. He is fine at lock of you want a 3rd front rower.
Click to expand...
Incorrect. He played 20 games at lock and that’s where he was returning big numbers in both attack and defence.
 
tigerap said:
I wish the club would explain this one to the fans and members…releasing Joe O and what do we get?…we have plenty of salary cap $$$…we get a roster spot for whom??….
Click to expand...
That's the answer to it all

Lets say the roster spot was for Jarome Hughes for 2023 this place will be going off like a mayonnaise factory, if its for another tuki simpkins well.. wrong call.
 
king_sirro said:
Yes he did, playing as a 3rd front rower, not a modern lock. Get it? He then moved to the front row and returned even bigger numbers.
Click to expand...
No he didn’t.
He popped up all over the field creating second phase play.
You didn’t watch much last year did you?
 
Tucker said:
…and mine goes against yours. The difference is I’m not quoting salary figures nor perverting history in a futile attempt to strengthen an argument.
Click to expand...


I didn't see anyone "pervert" history. Just someone who identified that Joffa's style is that of a front rower more so then a lock. He can do a good job at lock if you don't want ball playing, I don't think anyone is arguing that.
 
tigermate said:
Our best player last year was Hastings

Joffa looked good in an average team that got the wooden spoon

He’s not worth $450-$600k

Can’t wait to get rid of him.

He’s not a lock and he’s not a prop - he’s a benchy with no impact.

Once AD and Brooks follows we will finally be on the way up
Click to expand...
Joe finished the year top 10 NRL wide in three important categories.
He was head and shoulders our best.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 334 (members: 3, guests: 331)
Back
Top