Best we can hope for is a house falling on the club admin.
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
426Tlgerland
Well-known member
I know it’s good to have these young guys coming through and it’s all a feel good story but we need to push that to the side for 1 or 2 years until we get out first grade side competitive , yes keep the pathways going but we really need to go all out and buy 6 to 8 players who are either first graders or players like say Trindal who are stuck behind good quality players , pay overs but really get the ones we need in position
if we need a lock , buy a lock
if we need a 7 , buy a 7
this is the only way to get on top
Sheens playing Toa at 5/8 , he’s a good solid centre leave him there
Brooks at 7. He’s a 6.
etc
if we need a lock , buy a lock
if we need a 7 , buy a 7
this is the only way to get on top
Sheens playing Toa at 5/8 , he’s a good solid centre leave him there
Brooks at 7. He’s a 6.
etc
supercoach
Well-known member
It’s been said before, but maybe the NRL want a couple of Sydney teams to roll over and die, so they can spread the game to geographical better time slots. Although that will not improve the talent pool
mikey
Well-known member
Being a Sydney team or not has very little do with success - it's about culture - something which both Wests and Balmain sucked at for years - with the Wests Tigers ensuring the losing pedigree only becomes stronger.
Roar_Power
Well-known member
I'll take the blunt pen every day of the week
Buttface
Well-known member
I use plastic forks, sometimes you get lucky and the prongs break off.
jrtiger
Well-known member
saturday was atrocious. no other way to look at it. 9 tries down the right edge points to where the issue is. Nofoaluma is being shopped, Wakeham is a park footballer and Papali'i has been shifted from the right to the left which has resulted in a complete lack of cohesion.
it's time for Bateman to move back to the right, with iPap to the left and Blore to the bench. if Matamua or Laulili'i aren't ready then go to market. Morgan Smithies would be ideal. tackles his ass off. if not look at Nathan Brown or Connor Watson.
Naden can move to NSW Cup. Paul Momirovski is a great option that would be available and ensures Feledy isn't blooded early. Tupou is in a slump but he's young and will get out of it. Latu is the ideal target to play 6, and while he'll have his deficiencies defensively, he'll create plenty of points. Trindall would be nice, but I'm unsure if he's the ideal option given the lack of experience in the spine sans Api. Mitchell Pearce makes sense. throw him the keys.
the middles have been up for every week barring a few games, including Saturday. happy to leave them as is but again, Bateman needs to go back to marshalling the right edge.
if we bring in some experienced types similar to Pearce, Momirovski, Brown and Watson then it ensures that we aren't blooding Galvin, Feledy, the Laulili'i's and Fa'agutu into a side that is going to get belted from pillar to post every week. at this point, with the cap space we have, we need to recruit smartly with the future in mind. if we don't then this is going to continue for longer than any of us initially planned for.
it's time for Bateman to move back to the right, with iPap to the left and Blore to the bench. if Matamua or Laulili'i aren't ready then go to market. Morgan Smithies would be ideal. tackles his ass off. if not look at Nathan Brown or Connor Watson.
Naden can move to NSW Cup. Paul Momirovski is a great option that would be available and ensures Feledy isn't blooded early. Tupou is in a slump but he's young and will get out of it. Latu is the ideal target to play 6, and while he'll have his deficiencies defensively, he'll create plenty of points. Trindall would be nice, but I'm unsure if he's the ideal option given the lack of experience in the spine sans Api. Mitchell Pearce makes sense. throw him the keys.
the middles have been up for every week barring a few games, including Saturday. happy to leave them as is but again, Bateman needs to go back to marshalling the right edge.
if we bring in some experienced types similar to Pearce, Momirovski, Brown and Watson then it ensures that we aren't blooding Galvin, Feledy, the Laulili'i's and Fa'agutu into a side that is going to get belted from pillar to post every week. at this point, with the cap space we have, we need to recruit smartly with the future in mind. if we don't then this is going to continue for longer than any of us initially planned for.
crazycat
Well-known member
Right problems, wrong solutions.
We need to sort the wing problems and totally agreed Bateman and Paps back where they belong.
Naden, however is one of our best defenders. The Cowboys game was horrible but we shouldn't be chopping him. Instead we should look at a Centre option he can pair with.
I would like Momo back, Our biggest mistake was punting him as he could have been a long term Centre. But he hasn't set the world alite at Easts, neither has Conner Watson. I don't want Bondi Dreamers here because they will set us up as a "tier 2" team.
If were going to spend the money, lets get a Winger and Centre from the same team who can defend together. Lets too get a tackling coach! We clearly did not isolate the ball in our tackles vs NQL and paid a very hefty price for that.
earl
Well-known member
Good post but I disagree with this approach. We need the kids coming in. The players you mentioned don't have it and just ensure more losses with no hope for improvement.
We need to recruit smartly but average players will always give average results.
We do have a culture, a losing one.
jrtiger
Well-known member
Naden has been a victim of his versatility and moving between the right and the left, and while I think he is excellent on his day, I think he's best served as depth. I think that Feledy will jump him eventually, but there was a reason why Momirovski filled his role and eventually won a comp in 2021 at Penrith.
I'm not asking for elite talent, I want experienced players who will mentor the kids. Momirovski provides that. knows the system, has been in a stack of successful teams (Chooks 2018, Melbourne 2020, Penrith 2021) and is readily available. poor Connor Watson has struggled with injury and Robbo's obsession with playing him as a front rower. he will do well here.
for the most part of this year, we have defended well. I attribute that to cohesion and effort. the effort on Saturday was non existent and our left and right combinations are unrecognisable from preseason. as a result, scorelines like this come to exist.
jrtiger
Well-known member
while I agree that we need to push the kids through, you can't just put them in first grade and expect them to understand what is required after 50 games. a mix of youth and experience is imperative to long term success. look at Brisbane in 2020. a complete vacuum of experience and leadership and look what happens.
I have zero doubt in terms of the talents of our youngsters. Da Silva, the Laulili'i's, Lachlan Galvin, Chris Fa'agutu, the Large brothers, Alex Conti, Heath Mason, Makasini and Jordan Miller are all future first graders who will play 200 games providing they stay injury free, but they will not stay here unless there are mentors here that can show them the way. I think that Pearce, Momirovski and one of Watson/Brown could assist in that for the next few years while they understand what is required to be a first grader, along with Klemmer, Bateman, Api, Stef and Papali'i.
BlackWhiteGold
Well-known member
Let's hope Benji/Fulton share your thinking. Like this plan.
BlackWhiteGold
Well-known member
I think @jrtiger is right in his thinking. We need another couple of experienced heads to help develop our crop of juniors.
We know one has to be a halfback whether that is Mitchell Pearce or Chad Townsend falls out of the tree or L:achlan Lam or Jack Cogger.
Another should be an outside back that is good defensively. Momo could be an option or Connor Tracey.
Connor Watson would be good as a hooker/halves/lock utility off the bench especially if Jake Simpkin and/or Rua Ngatakuira go elsewhere.
We know one has to be a halfback whether that is Mitchell Pearce or Chad Townsend falls out of the tree or L:achlan Lam or Jack Cogger.
Another should be an outside back that is good defensively. Momo could be an option or Connor Tracey.
Connor Watson would be good as a hooker/halves/lock utility off the bench especially if Jake Simpkin and/or Rua Ngatakuira go elsewhere.
jrtiger
Well-known member
Pearce and Townsend should be priority 1. guys like Trindall and Cogger priority 2. happy to run with a youngster at 6, whether that be Fainu, Metcalf, Volkman or one of our own in Galvin, Matai or otherwise.
Momirovski I think should be a high priority as you said. Tracey I think would probably opt to play for a club higher up the ladder, such is his talent. Watson I think is ideal given his versatility. covers 1, 6, 9 and 13.
Mighty_Tiger
Well-known member
Been his story for 10yrs.
Over rated on here because we live in hope.
Naden is the perfect Wests Tigers player fit based on how our club operates.
Here’s a 1/2 back out of the blue , drinkwaters brother have watched him playing in England , he has pushed Williams to 5/8 , I remember him playing here in nsw cup he was a very good player , we were on top of the pile untill he left , think he would be worth a shit would not cost a lot
I like Lam, his father would also work as the extra spoke of our coaching foursome that seems to be the way we are heading into the future.
Dennisspicer1
Well-known member
Dont know if correct with this stat,
But here is something ive noticed, when we kick off in last Saturday nights game, every kick went to the same place,
NQL RIGHT WING
I only remember our kicker kicking to the same place every time.
To NQL right wing, I do not recollect us changing our kick off once, so if what I viewed was right, we had 14 kick offs and every one of them was the same kick to the same place
What ever happened to changing your kickoffs,
Like an occasional short one, like putting ball on ground on its belly and drilling it straight at an opposition player along the ground to try and force an error, ????
But here is something ive noticed, when we kick off in last Saturday nights game, every kick went to the same place,
NQL RIGHT WING
I only remember our kicker kicking to the same place every time.
To NQL right wing, I do not recollect us changing our kick off once, so if what I viewed was right, we had 14 kick offs and every one of them was the same kick to the same place
What ever happened to changing your kickoffs,
Like an occasional short one, like putting ball on ground on its belly and drilling it straight at an opposition player along the ground to try and force an error, ????
