Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[bathursttiger1]

Dont know if correct with this stat,

But here is something ive noticed, when we kick off in last Saturday nights game, every kick went to the same place,
NQL RIGHT WING

I only remember our kicker kicking to the same place every time.

To NQL right wing, I do not recollect us changing our kick off once, so if what I viewed was right, we had 14 kick offs and every one of them was the same kick to the same place

What ever happened to changing your kickoffs,
Like an occasional short one, like putting ball on ground on its belly and drilling it straight at an opposition player along the ground to try and force an error, ????

That would take someone with something between their ears to actually try something different.
We don’t seem to have a player with a few brain cells.

 

[Odessa]

The issue is we shouldn't even be considering putting Galvin in the top 30 next season. He's got the same frame as Seyfarth, only he's about 20 kgs lighter. He's not ready for first grade and one off season won't be enough.
He should be on a development contract for next season, progressing to the NRL the following year. He should be wanting this too, he's not ready to get thrown to the wolves in the NRL, and there's no need to rush him. The best thing for his development would be playing flegg and NSW cup next season. I highly doubt other clubs would offer him an NRL contract for next season. He's a beanpole.

Every member of the top 30 should be able to contribute to the top 17 if called upon. Most should have proven themselves in the NRL or at least at NSW/QLD/UK level to get an NRL contract, you can have 1-2 young guns signed only on potential in the top 30, but you need to cherry pick them.

The likes of Faagatu, Laulilii (both), S Saukuru, Miller would all be more likely to play first grade next year than Galvin. TDS already has this year due to injury and lack of depth. We can't fit all these kids on nrl deals straight away.
I rate Galvin highly, i just hope we haven't wasted a precious top 30 spot on a player highly unlikely to play first grade. We don't have the quality in our 17 to have players like him as backups...

Maybe there was more upside with keeping Brooks at the Tiger's and Sheen's was looking long term and the others are just trying to plug the holes

 

[jadtiger]

When you go through several coaches can only sweep the mess under the rug for so long.

I whole magpie v tiger will never go away until they hire people who don't care about magpie or tigers.

I think you mean Balmain and not tigers,because whoever we hire should care very much about Tigers.Weststigers and making them a success

 

[Eternal Tiger]

True, like when we released Pellow and signed.... ............

He got released over the weekend, so did Manaia Cherrington, they were replaced by............

 

[Odessa]

And I don't think Galvin will play first grade next year maybe get a taste 25 Play 26 he is only 17 a baby and and hopefully in 27/28 try to earn a Start every week

 

[tony soprano]

I think you mean Balmain and not tigers,because whoever we hire should care very much about Tigers.Weststigers and making them a success

That's what I'm saying need to rid the dinosaurs and get unbiased people in board level. That's not happening now.

 

[Harvey]

And I don't think Galvin will play first grade next year maybe get a taste 25 Play 26 he is only 17 a baby and and hopefully in 27/28 try to earn a Start every week

We have not had a youngster carry so much expectation since Jake Mullaney was carving up the 20’s

 

[tony soprano]

That's what I'm saying need to rid the dinosaurs and get unbiased people in board level. That's not happening now.

Just not marina go people tho.

 

[hsvjones]

Am I the only one that thinks the longer the Latu signing goes on the less likely it even goes ahead. Other clubs will come and pounce just like normal.

 

[mactiger]

Hi don't know why everyone saying wear a basket case I think they should be a having a look at the doggies they have the so be super coach phill Gould and the mega million roster and there no better than us so maybe the media should be giving them a bit of shit and laying off us for a while

 

[Eternal Tiger]

Hi don't know why everyone saying wear a basket case I think they should be a having a look at the doggies they have the so be super coach phill Gould and the mega million roster and there no better than us so maybe the media should be giving them a bit of shit and laying off us for a while

Ever wonder how we always get compared to other teams who are going shit. We never get compared to top 8 sides.

 

[Halbrowne61]

So when do we get an answer on the Manly whizz kids ? Or is that going to drag on for months as well.

 

[tony soprano]

Am I the only one that thinks the longer the Latu signing goes on the less likely it even goes ahead. Other clubs will come and pounce just like normal.

💯

 

[hsvjones]

Did the Dogs just sign Toby Sexton from now ?
If so, how did we not look into this considering how terrible we are in the halves. Its like the light are on with no one inside working

 

[tony soprano]

So when do we get an answer on the Manly whizz kids ? Or is that going to drag on for months as well.

Don't know mate, things could change but twitter saying, despite Saturday, he signs based on fulton and future signings.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Don't know mate, things could change but twitter saying, despite Saturday, he signs based on fulton and future signings.

You mean we will actually have future signings?

 

[Tim Sheens]

Don't know mate, things could change but twitter saying, despite Saturday, he signs based on fulton and future signings.

Twitter?

 

[tony soprano]

You mean we will actually have future signings?

Probably not

 

[BalmainJnr]

Another one down.

 

[Kelce68]

He got released over the weekend, so did Manaia Cherrington, they were replaced by............

You have been banging on about lack of replacements for released players for months.

Joffa in particular, you would have mentioned in nothing short of 20 comments, all the same, along the lines of 'we let Joffa go and replaced him with ______'

Surely you know that is not the way that these things work. A new signing is not contingent on a release and a release is not contingent on a new signing. The two have nothing to do with each other.

How often does a like for like replacement happen across the league?

People have spelled out, extremely clearly, that this release wasn't designed as a replacement, it was designed as cap relief for a bench player.

Ad nauseum.

Whether or not you agree with the decision is irrelevant, it was never designed as a replacement type signing, so why do you keep mentioning the same, tired, old copy and paste?

You made your incorrect point 6 weeks ago, let it go.