Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[BlackWhiteGold]

Could say the same for Tracey both he and Trindall’s defense has been beyond ordinary.

Maybe they are agitating for a release to the WTs 🤣

 

[Kaito]

They're not going good, but it's one game.

Whole sharks team didn't turn up this arvo

 

[SeanT]

Sullivan and fainu would be a good 7 and 6 for 2024 with Api at 9

Sullivan isn't a halfback. He's not that grewt to be honest.

 

[Todd Packer]

Maybe they're going the Mitch Moses route.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

Yep Trindall is not shaping up to well, looks like he would be a waste of time and money as well.

 

[carltonleach]

Any one have any idea If we are going to extend atasi James? However it’s spelt

 

[Todd Packer]

If you judged Hynes on this game he wouldn't make the Magpies team.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Maybe they are agitating for a release to the WTs 🤣

Well they’re playing like Tigers already !

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

In fact they've both been crap, but it's still only one game.

That no one will remember for one reason or another

 

[hank37w]

From memory, Tedesco had limited playmaking skills when he started. Even now, he isn't an 'elite' playmaker at the back. His game has always been based on running and support play.

I would agree with that but Teddy was very good from day one with his kick returns and tackle breaking ability which I have yet to see with Jahream.

Not saying that he won't develop that, it's just that every time he defuses a bomb and runs I anticipate him busting a few tackles and getting into open space but unfortunately it doesn't happen.

As good as he has been when taking into consideration the number of games he has played, I think it is getting to the stage where he is being over hyped and I don't see that as being a good thing because he has a long way to go before he can be considered anywhere near one of the best performing full backs in the NRL.

 

[king_sirro]

I would agree with that but Teddy was very good from day one with his kick returns and tackle breaking ability which I have yet to see with Jahream.

Not saying that he won't develop that, it's just that every time he defuses a bomb and runs I anticipate him busting a few tackles and getting into open space but unfortunately it doesn't happen.

As good as he has been when taking into consideration the number of games he has played, I think it is getting to the stage where he is being over hyped and I don't see that as being a good thing because he has a long way to go before he can be considered anywhere near one of the best performing full backs in the NRL.

It's his defence and ability to know where to be at the right time that has him hyped IMO. To have that instinct with such inexperience is the main thing that people are noticing. Adding to that is a few moments where he has showed natural athleticism and not to mention a great involvement rate. The hype is well justified.

Once he learns to engage the defensive line rather then just passing early he will be a real weapon.

 

[lathami]

Sullivan and fainu would be a good 7 and 6 for 2024 with Api at 9

Why? They are both running halves! It would be the same as brooks and Doueihi, just doesn’t work…

 

[The Sniffer]

Any one have any idea If we are going to extend atasi James? However it’s spelt

I thought I heard somewhere he is signed for next year, could be wrong.

 

[vlad]

It’s a blessing the Sharks didn’t release Trindall to us

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Why? They are both running halves! It would be the same as brooks and Doueihi, just doesn’t work…

Sullivan can steer the ship at 7 and has done in lower grades. He hasn't really had any coaches to help him Sullivan will be fine more upside than sezer or croft

 

[hank37w]

Not quite all, there are 4 Balmain ones also.

Probably wouldn't hurt to get a bigger cabinet.

 

[Kaito]

Chammas just said at half time Robbie wants to
Go in management role. Maybe bumping Pascoe.
Don't even know if he's qualified for CEO but who
knows with this club to be honest with you lol

 

[Kaito]

@Demps we called it huh Dempsey lmao

 

[Demps]

@Demps we called it huh Dempsey lmao

Farah the boss 👑
Lesgooo

 

[hank37w]

It's his defence and ability to know where to be at the right time that has him hyped IMO. To have that instinct with such inexperience is the main thing that people are noticing. Adding to that is a few moments where he has showed natural athleticism and not to mention a great involvement rate. The hype is well justified.

Once he learns to engage the defensive line rather then just passing early he will be a real weapon.

I agree that his defence and uncanny ability to be in the right position at the right time is what is really remarkable about him, though I just wonder how effective he is organising the teams defensive efforts from the back.