Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[earl]

A 700k back rower is supposed to run hard and tackle hard, he is doing neither and should have been dropped weeks ago,

I don't think he should be dropped. I think he has been okay and at one point I thought he was really good. I just think we need more from him plus we have a bunch of young guys coming through that'll want a spot.

I said the same thing about Stef a couple of weeks ago.

We need our top players to be consistently very good. Api is a classic example.

 

[Lauren]

This isn't a signing suggestion but moreso supports what a few have been stating about our forward pack being overpowered by others - ironically, I'm showing this via stats 😆.
After watching the Tongan powerhouse punish the Wests Tigers in a 30-22 win for the Warriors on Saturday night, with an effort that included 27 carries for 270 metres and a try, Johnson joined teammates and coach Andrew Webster in claiming there is no better prop in the game right now.

Top of the props: Warriors hail AFB after monster effort

Ask Warriors star Shaun Johnson for the reasons behind his outstanding 2023 season and the name Addin Fonua-Blake will feature prominently on the list.

www.nrl.com

That's crazy that one prop is providing that much of an impact for his team. Btw I am not really criticising our forwards yet only saying AFB's dominance is visibly seen without the stats to further back it up - which is what I presume a few forumers have been trying to emphasise.

 

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

This isn't a signing suggestion but moreso supports what a few have been stating about our forward pack being overpowered by others - ironically, I'm showing this via stats 😆.
After watching the Tongan powerhouse punish the Wests Tigers in a 30-22 win for the Warriors on Saturday night, with an effort that included 27 carries for 270 metres and a try, Johnson joined teammates and coach Andrew Webster in claiming there is no better prop in the game right now.

Top of the props: Warriors hail AFB after monster effort

Ask Warriors star Shaun Johnson for the reasons behind his outstanding 2023 season and the name Addin Fonua-Blake will feature prominently on the list.

www.nrl.com

That's crazy that one prop is providing that much of an impact for his team. Btw I am not really criticising our forwards yet only saying AFB's dominance is visibly seen without the stats to further back it up - which is what I presume a few forumers have been trying to emphasise.

AFB is the best prop in the game.

 

[Lauren]

AFB is the best prop in the game.

His mobility is impressive, for a big man.

 

[Needaname]

This isn't a signing suggestion but moreso supports what a few have been stating about our forward pack being overpowered by others - ironically, I'm showing this via stats 😆.
After watching the Tongan powerhouse punish the Wests Tigers in a 30-22 win for the Warriors on Saturday night, with an effort that included 27 carries for 270 metres and a try, Johnson joined teammates and coach Andrew Webster in claiming there is no better prop in the game right now.

Top of the props: Warriors hail AFB after monster effort

Ask Warriors star Shaun Johnson for the reasons behind his outstanding 2023 season and the name Addin Fonua-Blake will feature prominently on the list.

www.nrl.com

That's crazy that one prop is providing that much of an impact for his team. Btw I am not really criticising our forwards yet only saying AFB's dominance is visibly seen without the stats to further back it up - which is what I presume a few forumers have been trying to emphasise.

Good pick up Lauren. I read the article and was going to mention something similar but didn’t want to stoke the fire.
AFB is exactly what our forwards are not. I’m not sure any of the current crop can be similar. Even our juniors coming through aren’t of the same stature. He is a physical behemoth and has the endurance of a lock.
It’s fair to say it’s a high bar to reach as you’d be hard pressed arguing against him being the best prop in the game. Numbers like Hass and impact like JFH.

 

[boonboon]

The thing is he played just as well last year when they won very few games. It’s not the pack where we need to invest more.

 

[tony soprano]

This isn't a signing suggestion but moreso supports what a few have been stating about our forward pack being overpowered by others - ironically, I'm showing this via stats 😆.
After watching the Tongan powerhouse punish the Wests Tigers in a 30-22 win for the Warriors on Saturday night, with an effort that included 27 carries for 270 metres and a try, Johnson joined teammates and coach Andrew Webster in claiming there is no better prop in the game right now.

Top of the props: Warriors hail AFB after monster effort

Ask Warriors star Shaun Johnson for the reasons behind his outstanding 2023 season and the name Addin Fonua-Blake will feature prominently on the list.

www.nrl.com

That's crazy that one prop is providing that much of an impact for his team. Btw I am not really criticising our forwards yet only saying AFB's dominance is visibly seen without the stats to further back it up - which is what I presume a few forumers have been trying to emphasise.

Middle prop like this bloke are very important in the modern game. Sadly our team do not have one. They persist with stephano and he an impact prop.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

Middle prop like this bloke are very important in the modern game. Sadly our team do not have one. They persist with stephano and he an impact prop.

Im on the fence with Stef to be honest he has flashes of being decent, but then there's a fair bit of plodder about him. He also has a few mistakes and 6 agains at crucial times in him.
I know he's young and props mature later on but in all honesty i see him having a fair NRL career nothing outstanding. Certainly not Origin worthy imo.

 

[Stevec]

Anybody who watched the dogs game would conclude you would crazy to consider recruiting Luke Thompson he's a dud !
I know recruiting is hard but we can't just take anyone who's available

 

[TurnStyle]

Mate he is a good player. I just don’t think he’s a fullback. He’s better suited at 5/8.

I reckon he’d be a great 14 off the bench late in each half.

Agree. He's shown he's far better at 5/8.

I don't really see his value as a 14, but depending on the team it could work.

Hopefully he finds his place back at Penrith.

 

[Needaname]

Sounds like a bit of a coup picking up Havea.... Well done Fulton

Curious who we picked him up from.
Highlights show he was part of our Macarthur tigers team.

 

[Nounny]

Did you see the size of Havea on the video , big mobile unit !

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Did you see the size of Havea on the video , big mobile unit !

In the past we may have lost him to the Eels, Roosters or other clubs looking in the South West for junior talent. That we have retained him is a vote of confidence for our pathways system and all the staff involved in the programme.

 

[earl]

Anybody who watched the dogs game would conclude you would crazy to consider recruiting Luke Thompson he's a dud !
I know recruiting is hard but we can't just take anyone who's available

I have to assume that this is a stupid media beat up via his manager or something like that. It makes no sense.

 

[TigerTone]

Did you see the size of Havea on the video , big mobile unit !

who's Havea?

 

[tony soprano]

In the past we may have lost him to the Eels, Roosters or other clubs looking in the South West for junior talent. That we have retained him is a vote of confidence for our pathways system and all the staff involved in the programme.

Comes down to money

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/nrl-agenda-roosters-spine-shakeup-with-finals-hopes-in-the-balance-wests-tigers-retention/news-story/cf0f50109199542fabbd01315ad873c4

MARKET WATCH – WESTS TIGERS

The Wests Tigers have been busy on the open market but the club has now turned its attention to retention as they continue to rebuild their roster.

Breakout out star Junior Tupou has been identified as a retention priority and the club is moving to lock him in before the powerful outside back can hit the market on November 1.

The club has started extension talks with Tupou’s management and are confident they can keep him at Concord.

Tupou, along with boom fullback Jahream Bula, have emerged as one of the positives in an otherwise disappointing season at Concord.

Earlier this year, the Tigers had also identified a number of players free to leave at the end of the season, including forward Shawn Blore, hooker Jake Simpkin and winger David Nofoaluma.

But it’s understood the club has now had a change of heart on at least one player on that list.

Coaching staff now want Blore to see out the rest of his deal until the end of season 2024.

A number of Super League clubs, like Hull KR, had shown interest in the backrower but the Tigers are likely to reject any release offers.

 

[balmain boy]

Did you see the size of Havea on the video , big mobile unit !

He's not that big and remember he's up against other 14 or 15 year olds who may not have devloped yet.

For his size he has a god step and fend, but he's got to be able to keep doing that as he moves up the grades too.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

It should be a given we are looking to extend Tupou.

I'd hope we look to extend Blore too not just see out his contract.

 

[balmain boy]

Curious who we picked him up from.
Highlights show he was part of our Macarthur tigers team.

He's been with us the past couple of years i think. But only very young, like 14 now i think...