Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[teddy23]

He’s done his ACL twice while with us… another club can take a punt on him.

There’s a very quality footballer in AD…. unfortunately his ACL injuries aren’t helping however I’ve seen players come back from multiple ACL injuries and finish off there careers on a high so it’s possible. Apparently AD is loved by the boys and is an underrated leader the bloke genuinely loves the club and Benji too.

It’s all dependent on whether or not we think it’s worth the risk to give him a shot. I personally think he could provide value when he’s fit. Even as a potential long term 14 in the future on less $. No club will pay AD big money in his next deal so it’s not like he’ll be on overs.

 

[DUCK]

Now we have signed Latu, Samuela, Sezer and Sullivan it will be pretty quiet on here for a bit with 1 top 30 spot available.

Hopefully Fulton can work some magic and get Rua, Kepoa and Jake Simpkin off the books and sign a quality outside back or at least keep Staines

Definitely need to keep Staines. He is far and above the best winger playing for Wests Tigers. Has speed and along with his re-signing we MUST cut loose Nofo. Surely we Tigers fans can take up a collection and pay him to stay in NSW Cup. Unfortunately he has become an embarrassment with his reads in defence and he is without doubt the worst I have seen in my 59 years watching Rugby League.

 

[Tiger-ferret]

I’d transition him to some sort of well being officer for players around the club.
He is done as a top level player

Tend to agree. We need his spot. Every other club would todo the same.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

There’s a very quality footballer in AD…. unfortunately his ACL injuries aren’t helping however I’ve seen players come back from multiple ACL injuries and finish off there careers on a high so it’s possible. Apparently AD is loved by the boys and is an underrated leader the bloke genuinely loves the club and Benji too.

It’s all dependent on whether or not we think it’s worth the risk to give him a shot. I personally think he could provide value when he’s fit. Even as a potential long term 14 in the future on less $.

I just think we as a club need the best players we can & in our position we can’t really take a chance on a guy who is coming back from a 3rd ACL reco but I see your reasoning.

 

[tony soprano]

Think we need a hard nose defensive coach to complement coaching structure

 

[Tucker]

I just think we as a club need the best players we can & in our position we can’t really take a chance on a guy who is coming back from a 3rd ACL reco but I see your reasoning.

Look, the narrative of there being a champion player inside him is far fetched for mine. Maybe f he came through a decent system, but not here, he hasn’t done squat. The fact he is a 3 time ACL tearer makes it a no brainer decision as far as I am concerned. He won’t come back.

If he is as respected and liked around the club as some say, leverage that into a post footy career job.

 

[Betterdays22]

Look, the narrative of there being a champion player inside him is far fetched for mine. Maybe f he came through a decent system, but not here, he hasn’t done squat. The fact he is a 3 time ACL tearer makes it a no brainer decision as far as I am concerned. He won’t come back.

If he is as respected and liked around the club as some say, leverage that into a post footy career job.

Not exactly the same but I remember similar chat about Benj after his 5th shoulder reconstruction. I understand they are different injuries and it's a long way back for AD but just pointing out it can happen.

 

[hammertime]

There’s a very quality footballer in AD…. unfortunately his ACL injuries aren’t helping however I’ve seen players come back from multiple ACL injuries and finish off there careers on a high so it’s possible. Apparently AD is loved by the boys and is an underrated leader the bloke genuinely loves the club and Benji too.

It’s all dependent on whether or not we think it’s worth the risk to give him a shot. I personally think he could provide value when he’s fit. Even as a potential long term 14 in the future on less $. No club will pay AD big money in his next deal so it’s not like he’ll be on overs.

I think he's part of the puzzle to fill out one of our centre roles. He'll have to resign himself to that fact and being depth for 1 and 6

We can't add another to the 2nd row. We're swimming in forwards now.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

I think he's part of the puzzle to fill out one of our centre roles. He'll have to resign himself to that fact and being depth for 1 and 6

We can't add another to the 2nd row. We're swimming in forwards now.

need a better centre option than AD
train and trial contract for 2025 maybe ? or as others have said perhaps a development role within the club ?

 

[TonyTiger]

if he was on $800k at knights, why would he come to wt for half that? Was it because he wanted to join a more professional organisation?

He doesn’t need to worry about passing the ball here, that must be a load off his mind and worth taking a haircut for.

 

[upthetigers]

I reckon we will gain olakau'atu and lose Ice to Parramatta foer 2025

I can handle that

 

[tony soprano]

well Not impressed with anything put forward , same crap as normal

Hmm, I'm pretty impressed with the Fainu signings.

 

[tony soprano]

I reckon we will gain olakau'atu and lose Ice to Parramatta foer 2025

Are they both signed up for 2025?

 

[gregjm87]

if he was on $800k at knights, why would he come to wt for half that? Was it because he wanted to join a more professional organisation?

He is on 800k this year, just Knights are picking up half the tab. He is reportedly on 650k next two years.

 

[The_Old_Fox]

I am telling you Bateman is cooked, his body language tells you everything, all Teams know how predictable he is, run sideways, palm and look for a runner, nothing changes, try assists Nil, tackle breaks 3, Line breaks Nil, Off loads 2. Just trying hard doesn't cut it for the money he is on.

Topped the tackle count with no missed tackles you can't do better than that.

 

[tony soprano]

He is on 800k this year, just Knights are picking up half the tab. He is reportedly on 650k next two years.

He needs to be more dynamic

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

a weird one
a faint whisper out of the club is that AD could find himself out of the top 30 for next year

apparently no chance of coming back in 24 and the tigers would like to free up a top 30 spot

the tigers are looking at resigning adam for 25/26 with the thought he will transition into a ball playing lock / 2nd rower

this one comes from a different source, so take with a grain of salt

desperate move to free up 1 spot....farm out Noffo, Kepoa, Simpkin, Rua and a few others first

 

[upthetigers]

we still talking about Brooks lads 😂🤦🏻‍♀️

PTSD he had putrid performances for a decade.

 

[Lestronge]

I’m no fan of AD in the halves , but how did he go from the guy you build your tam around as recently as last year , but more accurately the year before , to dead weight now ?
The answer ……. He didn’t . He was never the guy you build around as per the hype around him .. but he is definitely the guy you need in your team . He will be our best centre when he’s finally fit. He just needs to accept the role .

 

[The Chad]

I’m no fan of AD in the halves , but how did he go from the guy you build your tam around as recently as last year , but more accurately the year before , to dead weight now ?
The answer ……. He didn’t . He was never the guy you build around as per the hype around him .. but he is definitely the guy you need in your team . He will be our best centre when he’s finally fit. He just needs to accept the role .

You'll be abused for such rational thinking.