Todd Packer
Well-known member
At least you blokes are on the right track.
All the other suggestions of rejects and reserve graders during the day has had me shaking my head at how low they expect our recruitment to be.
Last edited:
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
All the other suggestions of rejects and reserve graders during the day has had me shaking my head at how low they expect our recruitment to be.
The Euan Aitken one made me throw up in my mouth.
The Penrith Panthers have landed a significant coup, luring boom rookie Paul Alamoti to the club from the Bulldogs next season.
The back-to-back champions have been in discussions with Alamoti for the past week, agreeing to terms on a deal that will see the teenager fill the Panthers’ final spot in their top 30 roster for next season.
www.smh.com.au
The back-to-back champions have been in discussions with Alamoti for the past week, agreeing to terms on a deal that will see the teenager fill the Panthers’ final spot in their top 30 roster for next season.
NRL young gun signs shock deal with Panthers
The Penrith Panthers have lured rookie Paul Alamoti to the club from the Bulldogs next season.
Betterdays22
Well-known member
Agreed. I've never been one for the fantasy football suggested signings many make on here - Munster etc but man oh man. The idea of having hymel hunt and euan Aiken as a centre/wing pairing gives me nightmares. Need to be better than that.
Solution? Probably not. Better option? I believe so.
Tucker
Well-known member
Not bad…Toa will do if we can’t sign better. He isn’t very dynamic though and pretty inconsistent. Hopefully we are adding another centre to the ranks.
cqtiger
Well-known member
We win 2 wooden spoons and people are upset about letting Seyfarth go.
Geez
Geez
BlackWhiteGold
Well-known member
Any centre recruit will be a means to an end anyway for us next season.
Round 25 backline (leading us to a fairytale top 8):
Bula
Staines
T’oa
Galvin
Ngutlik
Fainu
Sullivan
tony soprano
Well-known member
Will prob end up at Manly.
watersider
Well-known member
Just a nothing aside from today: Spoke to a mate who supports the dragons today, and he said Sullivan was 'a gun' and when asked why they let him go, he said, 'we're a sh.t club'.
This was good for two reasons:
1. I reckon fans who follow their team closely have a good read on players and he's usually the type to make fun of the tigers and ridicule our moves and signings (fair enough too). So it's at least possible to be a bit hopeful about Sullivan.
2. Good to know other fans share our eternal disappointment of supporting a struggling club.
This was good for two reasons:
1. I reckon fans who follow their team closely have a good read on players and he's usually the type to make fun of the tigers and ridicule our moves and signings (fair enough too). So it's at least possible to be a bit hopeful about Sullivan.
2. Good to know other fans share our eternal disappointment of supporting a struggling club.
Not forgetting To’a is much better suited to playing left centre/left wing due to his big left foot step, but was made to play on the right as we have no others who like playing on the right.
upthetigers
Well-known member
But the forward pack isn't the reason we won the wooden spoon. We were in a lot of games but lacked creativity in attack.
It’s players like Seyfarth who will be 14-17 at almost any NRL club and is only on a slightly better than minimum wage that helps a club build a strong roster around him.
Also being a local junior that creates the heart and soul of a club, we would be crazy to let him go.
tigerballs
Well-known member
Toa, Tupou and Reilly are good footballers, just wait and see. Add Staines and maybe another offseason find, it's a very good backline. Reilly may even start the season at 5/8 if Fainu's not ready and I think he'll excel there. John Morris is going to make a massive difference to the structure and if we can produce any sort of threat from the halves, you'll see what these kids can do. Note when Brooks was on his game, Tupou and T'oa were standouts. Staines is always a threat. All they need is a bit of room to move.
I would like to see some strike power from the 2nd rower next year.
Looking at someone that’s a bit hit or miss like Bryce Cartwright could be a risk but as he has got older and matured has become more reliable.
Playing him on one side with young Samuela Fainu on the other could give the opposition something to think about.
The better teams second rowers play 80 minutes so don’t waste an interchange.
Leaving the following as our rotating middles
Klemmer
Utoikamanu
Pole
Papali’i
Twal
Bateman- Cover outside back if needed (centre)
4th reserve
Either our young hooker ?
Or reserve half to fill in at dummy half for around 20 min and incase a half gets injured.
Would like at least one nrl centre
With some speed not one that fills in as a second rower when required but finding one looks harder than it sounds.
Buying 1x second rower (Cartwright)
Buying 1x Centre (nrl standard)
Resigning Winger (Staines)
Looking at someone that’s a bit hit or miss like Bryce Cartwright could be a risk but as he has got older and matured has become more reliable.
Playing him on one side with young Samuela Fainu on the other could give the opposition something to think about.
The better teams second rowers play 80 minutes so don’t waste an interchange.
Leaving the following as our rotating middles
Klemmer
Utoikamanu
Pole
Papali’i
Twal
Bateman- Cover outside back if needed (centre)
4th reserve
Either our young hooker ?
Or reserve half to fill in at dummy half for around 20 min and incase a half gets injured.
Would like at least one nrl centre
With some speed not one that fills in as a second rower when required but finding one looks harder than it sounds.
Buying 1x second rower (Cartwright)
Buying 1x Centre (nrl standard)
Resigning Winger (Staines)
I wonder if we even tried to sign him , I think he will be a good player . So here we go again watching all these clubs jumping in and getting player that I guess we don’t even try to sign , OH that’s right we got this great talent pool coming through that’s why reserve grade made the finals , OH they didn’t , well the junior teams made the grand finals , OH they didn’t , this obsession to play these kids who are never going to be 1st grade players has to stop , when I was at Penrith the rate was 1 in 100 made it . When ur at the bottom u got to buy hard heads and players who don’t like getting beat then when u start to win u can through a kid in here and thereThe Penrith Panthers have landed a significant coup, luring boom rookie Paul Alamoti to the club from the Bulldogs next season.
The back-to-back champions have been in discussions with Alamoti for the past week, agreeing to terms on a deal that will see the teenager fill the Panthers’ final spot in their top 30 roster for next season.
NRL young gun signs shock deal with Panthers
The Penrith Panthers have lured rookie Paul Alamoti to the club from the Bulldogs next season.
Tucker
Well-known member
Reilly has surprised me, albeit with a very limited amount of game time. He is worth persisting with as I said.
Toa can play. He needs an attitude adjustment.
Tupou…he has a lot of holes in his game. If we keep going with him, he requires a shit tonne of attention as he is an identified weak link.
Staines is a threat in space but doesn’t do the hard yakka most modern wingers do.
Our halves are unknowns.
I think in its current form, it’s the worst backline in the comp. How you can say it’s a “very good backline” when they’ve just delivered a spoon baffles me.
I’ll hold 2024 judgement until they’ve had a hard offseason and start playing next year.
Latest posts
-
-
Juniors - Pathways General Discussion- Latest: Holman Barnes #1 Fan
-
-
-
-
Staff online
-
DempsModerator